2004-2005 Ryan Shapiro, Lee Heinzelman Grease
2005-2006 Ryan Shapiro, Eric Schlossberg Les Miserables
2006-2007 Matthew Wharton, Stephanie Miele Wicked
2007-2008 Jason Sarte, James Caldarise The Chronicles of Narnia
2008-2009 James Caldarise, Christopher Bentivenga Moulin Rouge
2009-2010 Courtney Rago, Nicholas Bentivenga The Mask of Zorro
2010-2011 Courtney Rago, Sarah Bentivenga The Journey of Man
2011-2012 Sarah Bentivenga, Matthew Showerman Viva Carnivale
2012-2013 Michael Raia, Casey Lau Primary Suspect: Mancini
2013-2014 Michael Raia, Samantha Trembly Piano Man: The Music of Billy Joel
2014-2015 Samantha Trembly, Priya Khosla, Brian McCann Cult Songs on the 70’s and 80’s
2015-2016 Brian McCann, Shannon Brunner, Samantha Collins The Search Among the Stars
2016-2017 Shannon Brunner, Mackenzie Parke, Annesha Datta Cartoon Craziness
2017-2018 Annesha Datta, Riti Shah, Riley McGowan Harry Potter - The Music
2018-2019 Beth Grossman, Ruan Jamolod, Julia Oliveria Avatar - The Music
2019-2020 Julia Oliveria , Ashley Xique Shades of Latin
2020-2021 Ashley Xique, Kene Echezona The Music of Chicago