The discovery of galaxies began in the sixth century BC when Persian astronomers wondered whether the white light of the Milky Way (Figure 1‑20) might be the combined light of many stars. Little did people realize when they were arguing about the Copernican model that the solar system is a tiny part of a galaxy with 100 billion stars, which is a tiny part of a universe with 100 billion galaxies.
Figure 1‑20. A view of the Milky Way. Credit: Steve Jurvetson. Used here per CC BY 2.0.
Galileo’s 8X magnification telescope revealed that the white light of the Milky Way is the combined light of many stars. Scientists in the 18th detected faint elliptical nebulae, and Immanuel Kant combined this information along with the line shape of the Milky Way (Figure 1‑19) to reason that galaxies have a disk shape and we are within in one of those disks, the Milky Way. Scientists in the 19th and 20th century identified the arms of the Milky Way and the structure of galaxies in the Universe.
In the 18th century, Charles Messier (1730-1817) was searching for comets, which Europeans viewed as signs from God. Nebulae distracted Messier, so he made a catalog of their locations in order to avoid mistaking them for comets. As it turned out, his catalog of 110 nebulae (blurry objects) turned out to be more important than any comet. His catalogue became the famous Messier list (Figure 1‑21). Many of the objects in the Messier list are nearby galaxies and globular clusters (clusters of stars in our galaxy). For example, Messier object M31 is the Andromeda Galaxy, which is in the third column and third row (Figure 1‑21), and globular cluster M5 (Messier 5) has hundreds of thousands of stars. The letter M stands for Messier, and 5 refers to the fifth object in his list. Other objects are stellar nurseries where clusters of stars are forming (Eagle Nebula M16) and dying stars (M57). With his small 4-inch telescope with his eye, Messier only dimly saw the objects in Figure 1‑21 .
Figure 1‑21. Messier Objects. Credit: NASA.
Immanuel Kant hypothesized that disk-shaped nebulae might be galaxies of stars. Kant thought that the Milky Way forms a line because it is a disk-shaped galaxy, and we are within the galaxy. Kant hypothesized that just as the solar system is a disk with planets orbiting a large mass at the center, so the Milky Way is a disk of orbiting stars with a large mass at the center. We now know that the large mass in the center of the Milky Way is an enormous black hole.
Kant proposed the island universe theory, which is that countless galaxies are floating in space. This idea was ahead of its time and was not confirmed until the 20th century. Kant envisioned the collapse of individual clouds in space to centers of gravity and the subsequent spreading out of a rotating disk in space, such as the Milky Way spiral galaxy and the Sombrero spiral galaxy (Figure 1‑22). In additional to spiral galaxies, there are elliptical and irregular galaxies, which are not flat disks.
Figure 1‑22. The Sombrero Galaxy is a spiral galaxy with 800 billion stars. Credit: NASA.
Figure 1‑23. William Herschel polishing mirror with his sister Caroline. Credit: Wellcome collection. 1896 lithograph. https://wellcomecollection.org/works/hs76suwh CC-BY-4.0
Increasing the length of telescopes increases magnification, and increasing the diameter of mirrors increases resolution. In the 19th century, the Herschels (brother-sister) and the Rosses (husband-wife) built the largest telescopes. William Herschel was a musician who became interested in astronomy, and he spent 16 hours per day polishing mirrors and making telescopes. Caroline, his younger sister, fed him so that William did not need to let go of the polishing stone (Figure 1‑23). Although Caroline did not directly polish mirrors, she was heavily involved in their scientific work.
The Herschel’s largest telescope (Figure 1‑24) was 40 ft long but never worked. Their next largest telescope was 20 ft long and was used to map the heavens. After William passed away, Caroline continued their work by cataloging the nebulae that they observed, which formed the basis of the New General Catalogue (NGC) of 6,200 nebulae.
Figure 1‑24. The Herschel’s 40 ft long telescope that never worked. Credit: Leisure Hour, 1867.
One of the their most significant discoveries was the planet Uranus. They also mapped the Milky Way by setting their telescope at 683 positions and counting the number of stars at each position. Their observations revealed that many more stars were along the line of the Milky Way than in directions perpendicular to the Milky Way. This observation provided the first empirical evidence that the Milky Way was in the shape of a disk. The Herschels assumed that all the stars (or other visible objects) had the same intrinsic brightness, which was incorrect, and led to an error in their estimate of the size of the Milky Way. Herschel also thought that all the clusters and galaxies that he could see with his telescope were within the Milky Way, which was also incorrect.
Figure 1‑25. Lord Rosse’s drawing (1845) of the Whirlpool Galaxy.
Lord Rosse built a 72-inch diameter telescope in 1845, with which he was able to see individual stars in distant galaxies. The telescope was called the Leviathon, and it was even featured in one of Jules Verne's novels. The images from this telescope provided support for Kant’s island universe theory. Rosse's partner in astronomy was his wife, Mary Rosse. Mary had a darkroom in their castle, and she experimented with new photographic techniques. The human eye is a poor collector of the dim light of telescopes. The eye is primarily designed to collect bright light in the daytime; however, photographic plates could collect the dim light of stars for extended periods and form images of distant nebulae. Based on their observations, Lord Rosse drew an image of the Whirlpool Galaxy (Figure 1‑25).
Figure 1‑26. Henrietta Swan Leavitt working at her desk in the Harvard College Observatory. Margaret Harwood - American Institute of Physics, Emilio Segrè Visual Archives. Public domain.
In 1904, Kapteyn, a Dutch astronomer, observed that half of the stars were moving in one direction, and the other half of stars were moving in the other direction. This revealed that the Milky Way is indeed rotating, and he drew a whirlpool representation of the Milky Way that was like Rosse’s image in Figure 1‑25.
In 1912, Henrietta Leavitt (Figure 1‑26) discovered Cepheid variable stars, which pulsated at a rate that was related to their brightness. This enabled her to calculate the distance to the stars and thus the distances to the galaxies that contained them. This ability to determine the distances to galaxies was one of the most crucial factors in the development of the Big Bang model.
In 1917, Harlow Shapley used Leavitt’s pulsating stars to determine the shape and size of our galaxy. He did this by looking for globular clusters that had pulsating stars in the Milky Way. He calculated that the Milky Way is 100,000 light-years in diameter, and that the sun is 30,000 light-years from the center of the Milky Way. He thus proved that the sun is not at the center of the Milky Way. However, Shapley was wrong about one thing. He thought all of the other galaxies were within the Milky Way. Shapley and his wife, Martha, worked together at Mt Wilson observatory and Harvard Observatory. Martha wrote many scientific papers on eclipsing stars and other aspects of astronomy.
Heber Curtis observed a nova in the “nearby” Andromeda Galaxy (left), which indicated that the Andromeda Galaxy (Figure 1‑27) was 500,000 light-years from us. This meant that the Andromeda Galaxy was outside of the Milky Way. In 1926, Edwin Hubble also showed that distant galaxies were far outside of the Milky Way and that the universe is much bigger than just our galaxy.
In the 1950s, scientists discovered a persistent hiss in the radio frequencies that came from the center of the Milky Way. They realized that the source was a massive black hole at the center of the galaxy, which was exciting the hydrogen gas around it. In 1952, scientists used this hiss to map the spiral structure of the Milky Way. Finally, scientists used various parts of the electromagnetic spectrum to confirm that there are four arms in the Milky Way.
Figure 1‑27. The Andromeda Galaxy (the closest large galaxy to the Milky Way). Credit: Adam Evans. Used here per CC BY 2.0.
The Milky Way is in the Local Group (Figure 1‑28), which is a small cluster of galaxies containing the Andromeda Galaxy, a few small galaxies, and several dwarf galaxies. The galaxies in the Local Group are close enough for gravity to bind together, such that the group does not expand with the universe. Therefore, there is not necessarily a redshift in galaxies in the Local Group. The second largest galaxy in the Local Group, the Andromeda Galaxy, is moving toward the Milky Way, causing a blueshift. Other clusters of galaxies, such as the Virgo Cluster (upper left cluster in Figure 1‑29), are much farther away and are not bound by gravity to the galaxies in the Local Group. Therefore, there is a redshift in galaxies in the Virgo Cluster and all other distant galaxies.
Figure 1‑28. The Local Group of galaxies with two large galaxies and many small and dwarf galaxies (Milky Way is at the center). Credit: Antonio Ciccolella. Used here per CC BY-SA 4.0.
Figure 1‑29. The Virgo Cluster (65 million light years away), Local Group, and other relatively close galaxies. Credit: NASA/WMAP Science Team, Cal Tech.
The Local Group and Virgo Cluster are part of the Laniakea Supercluster (Figure 1‑30), which contains 100,000 galaxies and expands with the universe. The position of the Milky Way in the Local Group is advantageous for life since there have been no galactic mergers with other large galaxies, but there are also dwarf galaxies that are absorbed into the Milky Way, helping to maintain the structure of the Milky Way. Scientists estimate that there are two trillion galaxies in the Universe, so the Laniakea Supercluster has just 0.01% of the galaxies in the Universe.
Figure 1‑30. The Laniakea Supercluster of galaxies, which contains the Local Group (blue text) as well as 100,000 other galaxies. Credit: Andrew Colvin. Used here per CC BY-SA 4.0.
Milky Way in night sky. Credit: Bruno Gilli/ESO. Used here per CC BY 4.0.