Book Review: Quetta
Reviewed by Nathan, Grade 6, 28/11/25
Quetta by Gary Crew and Bruce Whatley is a sad and emotional book. It was first published in 2002, so it’s a pretty old book. It’s based on a real event, the sinking of the RMS Quetta. Over 150 people lost their lives in the book and in real life, making it tragic. The pictures and colours are amazing but gloomy at the same time.
I chose this book in Reading after I finished my first review (see How to Make a Bird). At first, I thought it was a story about a sinking ship the author made up by using their imagination, but then I realised that this actually happened in real life. Realising this, it instantly changed my mood from bored to sorrowful. This might happen to you when you read the book.
In the book, the main problem begins when Mutassa, a survivor of the disaster, and Captain Brown, the ship captain, are in court to decide who gets to adopt a little girl who also survived the sinking. In court, Mutassa tells the magistrate about how he saved the girl on the night of the sinking. But the magistrate is rude and keeps interrupting him. Mutassa ignores and goes on to tell what happened.
The style of the book is gloomy but cool at the same time. The pages of the book look old and the whole story is written in old English. But it’s also disturbing at the same time as it features the people who lost their lives on the night. The overall style of the book is about death and depression. The illustrator used mostly dark colours, for example, the pages where the ship is sinking is only in dark colours like dark blue, black and grey. This shows the terror people had to go through on the night of the disaster. Therefore, these things make the book sad, emotional and gloomy.
The theme of Quetta is “the simple act of caring is heroic” as in the story, Mutassa saves a little girl. Without his help, the girl would’ve drowned as other people would have been more focused on saving themselves. That’s one aspect of why the book is so deep.
Overall, Quetta is a miserable and unhappy story. It talks about the people who died on the sinking of the RMS Quetta. I would recommend this book for people ages 11 and up as the old English and the theme of death in the book might be confusing and frightening for younger people. I give Quetta ⅘ stars. So when you finish reading this review, go get the book and have a look. You’ll definitely shed a tear.