RECORDS

Buckeye Central Baseball Records

INDIVIDUAL GAME RECORDS

Hitting

HITS 5 Brooks Spiess 2005 (Lucas)

Josh Kocher 2007 (Colonel Crawford)

Austin Moyer 2007 (Riverdale)

Tyler Erwin 2010 (Plymouth)

Sam Shafer 2010 (Lucas)

Justin Herrnstein 2012 (Lucas)

Casey Geissman 2022 (Cardington)

HOME RUNS 3 Justin Herrnstein 2012 (Lucas)

RBI 9 Justin Herrnstein 2012 (Lucas)

STOLEN BASES 6 Adam Paynter 2012 (St. Peter’s) (7TH ALL TIME IN OHIO)

RUNS 6 Justin Herrnstein 2012 (Lucas)

DOUBLES 3 Alex Finney 2010 (Riverdale)

TRIPLES 2 Tyler Erwin 2012 (Crestline, St. Peter’s)

BASE ON BALLS 4 Tyler Shade 2008 (Lucas)

Mike Blackford 2013 (Tiffin Calvert)

Caydin Jarvis 2025 (Mansfield Christian)

Pitching

STRIKEOUTS 16 Sam Shafer 2011 (Bucyrus, Wynford)

Alex Kanney 2022 (Mohawk, Bucyrus)

LEAST HITS IN CG 0 (5 IP) Chase Finney 2011 (Carey)

0 (5 IP) Clay Green 2021 (New Riegel)

0 (5 IP) Austin Estridge 2025 (Plymouth)

0 (6 IP) Tanner Zaebst 2016 (St. Peter’s)

0 (7 IP) Josh Dentinger 2018 (Bucyrus)

INDIVIDUAL SEASON RECORDS

HITTING

HITS 49 Justin Herrnstein 2012

44 Derek Erwin 2007

43 Tyler Erwin 2010

43 Sam Shafer 2011

42 Brooks Spiess 2004

42 Josh Kocher 2007

42 Sam Shafer 2010

41 Adam Paynter 2012

40 Austin Moyer 2007

40 Alex Finney 2011

HOME RUNS 8 Jarrod Clady 1995

7 Derek Erwin 2006, 2007

5 Derek Erwin 2004

5 Sam Shafer 2011

5 Tyler Erwin 2011, 2012

4 Aaron Frazee 1995

4 Travis Vanderpool 2001

4 Joe Flood 2002

4 Austin Moyer 2007

4 Tyler Erwin 2010

4 Justin Herrnstein 2012

4 David Williams 2009

RBI 43 Derek Erwin 2007

40 Jacob Zeiter 2012

38 Justin Herrnstein 2012

37 Derek Erwin 2006

36 Tyler Erwin 2010

35 Sam Shafer 2010

34 Tyler Erwin 2011

34 Sam Shafer 2011

31 Josh Kocher 2007

31 Alex Finney 2011

30 Brooks Spiess 2004

30 Austin Moyer 2007

30 Tyler Erwin 2012

STOLEN BASES 37 Thomas Kaple 2012

35 Caydin Jarvis 2025

33 Justin Herrnstein 2012

32 Adam Paynter 2012

31 Adam Paynter 2011

30 Heath Jensen 2024

27 Eric Guttenberg 2002

27 Grant Loy 2015

26 Corey Guttenberg 2003

26 Grant Loy 2016

RUNS 47 Adam Paynter 2012

46 Justin Herrnstein 2012

44 Aaron Marcum 2007

43 Derek Erwin 2007

43 Tyler Erwin 2011

42 Tyler Erwin 2010

41 Adam Paynter 2011

38 Derek Erwin 2007

37 Alex Finney 2010

37 Tyler Erwin 2012

AVERAGE .494 Brooks Spiess 2004

.478 Derek Erwin 2007

.477 Jacob Hiler 2024

.473 Derek Erwin 2004

.457 Josh Kocher 2007

.454 Sam Shafer 2009

.453 Sam Shafer 2011

.449 Alex Finney 2011

.446 Derek Erwin 2006

.445 Justin Herrnstein 2012

.443 Eric Guttenberg 2002

.438 Grant Loy 2016

.436 Brooks Spiess 2005

.434 Tyler Erwin 2010

.427 Tyler Erwin 2011

.424 Kevin Fortney 2006

.424 Tyler Erwin 2012

.420 Sam Shafer 2010

.413 Brady Biglin 2019

.411 Corey Guttenberg 2002

.411 Aaron Marcum 2007

.406 Eric Guttenberg 2001

.402 Austin Moyer 2006

.402 Jacob Zeiter 2012

.400 Josh Kocher 2006

DOUBLES 11 Austin Moyer 2007

11 Sam Shafer 2010

10 Brooks Spiess 2005

10 Austin Pifher 2008

10 Tyler Erwin 2010

10 Jacob Zeiter 2012

10 Eric Hanes 2014

10 Tanner Zaebst 2014

9 Derek Erwin 2005

9 Sam Shafer 2009

9 Jacob Zeiter 2011

TRIPLES 9 Tyler Erwin 2012

6 Justin Herrnstein 2012

3 Adam Paynter 2012

3 Jacob Zeiter 2012

3 Jordan Herrnstein 2013

2 Kevin Fortney 2006

2 Tyler Erwin 2010

2 Sam Shafer 2010

2 Justin Herrnstein 2011

2 Paul Richardson 2011

TOTAL BASES 79 Tyler Erwin 2012

Justin Herrnstein 2012

AT BATS 116 Adam Paynter 2012

110 Justin Herrnstein 2012

109 Alex Kanney 2021

102 Adam Paynter 2011

101 Austin Moyer 2007

101 Casey Geissman 2021

100 Sam Shafer 2010

100 Thomas Kaple 2012

99 Tyler Erwin 2010

98 Sam Shafer 2008

98 Jordan Herrnstein 2014

PLATE APPEARANCES 133 Adam Paynter 2012

126 Justin Herrnstein 2012

123 Tyler Erwin 2012

122 Alex Kanney 2021

121 Tyler Erwin 2010

120 Adam Paynter 2011

118 Sam Shafer 2010

117 Tyler Erwin 2011

116 Thomas Kaple 2012

116 Jacob Zeiter 2012

116 Casey Geissman 2021

BASE ON BALLS 28 Chase Finney 2012

26 Caydin Jarvis 2025

24 Kaiden Vaughn 2021

23 Tyler Erwin 2012

22 Jacob Zeiter 2010

22 Jacob Zeiter 2012

22 Lance Cole 2025

22 Austin Estridge 2025

21 Alex Finney 2010

21 Tyler Erwin 2011

21 Elliot Geissman 2022

HIT BY PITCH 9 Tanner Zaebst 2015

ON BASE PERCENTAGE .637 Jarrod Clady 1995

SLUGGING PERCENTAGE .859 Tyler Erwin 2012

SACRIFICES 8 Mike Blackford 2014

8 Brady Biglin 2017

5 Alex Finney 2011

5 Adam McGinnis 2013

4 Josh Kocher 2006

4 Aaron Marcum 2006, 2007

4 Kyle Carney 2007

4 Zac Campbell 2009

4 Adam Paynter 2010

4 Ryan Wilfer 2013

4 Cody Roberts 2016

4 Jacob Shade 2016

4 Josh Dentinger 2017

4 Justin Dentinger 2019

4 Brady Kerschner 2019

4 Clay Green 2022

GAMES PLAYED 30 Tyler Erwin 2010, 2012

Tyler Shade 2010

David Walsh 2010

Sam Shafer 2010

Adam Paynter 2010, 2012

Bryce Christy 2012

Thomas Kaple 2012

Justin Herrnstein 2012

Jacob Zeiter 2012

CONSEC. GAMES WITH HR 4 Tyler Erwin 2011 (11TH ALL-TIME IN OHIO)

PITCHING

WINS 8 Derek Erwin 2006

8 Tyler Erwin 2010

8 Sam Shafer 2011

7 Kevin Fortney 2006

7 Tyler Erwin 2012

7 Alex Kanney 2022

6 Adam Fritz 2004

6 Derek Erwin 2007

6 Abram Kaple 2008

6 Josh Dentinger 2018

6 Alex Kanney 2021

STRIKEOUTS 116 Sam Shafer 2011

113 Alex Kanney 2022

105 Josh Dentinger 2018

92 Sam Shafer 2010

90 Brady Biglin 2019

84 Tyler Erwin 2012

73 Isaac Hiler 2024

70 Rocky Riley 1995

67 Alex Kanney 2021

64 Tyler Erwin 2011

SHUTOUTS 3 Josh Dentinger 2018

Alex Kanney 2022

ERA (MIN 25 IP) 1.01 Sam Shafer 2011

1.14 Kaiden Vaughn 2021

1.14 Caydin Jarvis 2025

1.57 Brent Hays 2007

1.58 Josh Dentinger 2018

1.62 Tyler Erwin 2012

1.67 Austin Lutz 2014

1.71 Paul Richardson 2011

1.77 Bart Kehres 2002

1.80 Alex Kanney 2021

1.81 Alex Kanney 2022

1.99 Matthew Summers 2019

IP 69 Sam Shafer 2010, 2011

66 1/3 Josh Dentinger 2018

66 Alex Kanney 2021

65 2/3 Alex Kanney 2022

65 1/3 Brady Biglin 2019

65 Tyler Erwin 2012

60 2/3 Isaac Hiler 2023

56 2/3 Isaac Hiler 2024

56 1/3 Austin Lutz 2013

54 2/3 Rocky Riley 1995

SAVES 6 Aaron Marcum 2006

APPEARANCES 15 Brent Hays 2007

COMPLETE GAMES 8 Tyler Erwin 2012

Josh Dentinger 2018

Alex Kanney 2021

INDIVIDUAL CAREER RECORDS

HITTING

AT BATS 379 Sam Shafer 2008-11

361 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

354 Alex Finney 2008-11

321 Derek Erwin 2004-07

314 Corey Guttenberg 2001-04

303 Adam Paynter 2009-12

292 Grant Loy 2013-16

287 Tanner Zaebst 2013-16

274 Adam Fritz 2002-05

272 Austin Pifher 2006-09

HITS 154 Sam Shafer 2008-11

146 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

133 Alex Finney 2008-11

122 Derek Erwin 2004-07

109 Corey Guttenberg 2001-04

108 Grant Loy 2013-16

103 Adam Paynter 2009-12

102 Brooks Spiess 2002-05

94 Adam Fritz 2002-05

92 Aaron Marcum 2004-07

HOME RUNS 21 Derek Erwin 2004-07

16 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

11 Sam Shafer 2008-11

9 Joe Flood 1999-02

9 Adam Fritz 2002-05

8 Jarrod Clady 1992-95

6 Scott Ehrman 2000-03

6 Josh Kocher 2004-07

5 Corey Guttenberg 2001-04

5 Brooks Spiess 2002-05

5 Justin Herrnstein 2009-12

RBI 129 Derek Erwin 2004-07

119 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

105 Sam Shafer 2008-11

89 Jacob Zeiter 2009-12

81 Alex Finney 2008-11

73 Austin Pifher 2006-09

67 Justin Herrnstein 2009-12

66 Josh Kocher 2004-07

64 Grant Loy 2013-16

63 Corey Guttenberg 2001-04

63 Adam Fritz 2002-05

STOLEN BASES 80 Grant Loy 2013-16

77 Adam Paynter 2009-12

73 Tanner Zaebst 2013-16

69 Sam Shafer 2008-11

63 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

54 Justin Herrnstein 2009-12

52 Caydin Jarvis 2025-26

51 Corey Guttenberg 2001-04

49 Jake Tidaback 1999-02

48 Heath Jensen 2021-24

RUNS 148 Tyler Erwin 2009-12 (8TH ALL-TIME IN OHIO)

126 Sam Shafer 2008-11

112 Adam Paynter 2009-12

111 Alex Finney 2009-11

97 Corey Guttenberg 2001-04

97 Aaron Marcum 2004-07

92 Tanner Zaebst 2013-16

83 Grant Loy 2013-16

77 Eric Guttenberg 1999-02

76 Brooks Spiess 2002-05

AVERAGE .445 Derek Erwin 2004-07

.421 Brooks Spiess 2002-05

.406 Sam Shafer 2008-11

.404 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

.399 Josh Kocher 2004-07

.398 Jacob Hiler 2021-24

.382 Aaron Marcum 2004-07

.381 Alex Finney 2008-11

.377 Justin Herrnstein 2009-12

.370 Grant Loy 2013-16

DOUBLES 32 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

29 Sam Shafer 2008-11

24 Alex Finney 2008-11

24 Jacob Zeiter 2009-12

23 Derek Erwin 2004-07

22 Tanner Zaebst 2013-16

20 Grant Loy 2013-16

19 Eric Hanes 2011-14

18 Brooks Spiess 2002-95

18 Austin Lutz 2013-15

TRIPLES 12 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

8 Justin Herrnstein 2009-12

5 Adam Paynter 2009-12

3 Kevin Fortney 2003-06

3 Sam Shafer 2008-11

3 Jacob Zeiter 2009-12

3 Jordan Herrnstein 2012-14

3 Grant Loy 2013-16

BASE ON BALLS 76 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

71 Alex Finney 2008-11

60 Sam Shafer 2008-11

54 Jacob Zeiter 2009-12

53 Kaiden Vaughn 2019-22

52 Derek Erwin 2004-07

50 Corey Guttenberg 2001-04

49 Isaac Hiler 2021-24

49 Seth Parsons 2013-16

47 Tanner Zaebst 2013-16

45 Austin Estridge 2022-25

HIT BY PITCH 19 Seth Parsons 2013-16

SACRIFICES 11 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

TOTAL BASES 250 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

GAMES PLAYED 115 Sam Shafer 2008-11

115 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

110 Alex Finney 2008-11

102 Corey Guttenberg 2001-04

102 Seth Parsons 2013-16

100 Tanner Zaebst 2013-16

97 Derek Erwin 2004-07

97 Jeremiah Fishpaw 2023-26

96 Adam Fritz 2002-05

96 Josh Dentinger 2015-18

CONSECUTIVE STARTS 115 Sam Shafer 2008-11

PITCHING

WINS 22 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

17 Derek Erwin 2004-07

17 Sam Shafer 2008-11

13 Austin Lutz 2013-15

13 Alex Kanney 2019-22

12 Adam Fritz 2002-05

11 Abram Kaple 2006-09

11 Josh Dentinger 2015-18

10 Jake Tidaback 1999-02

9 Corey Guttenberg 2001-04

9 Matt Temple 2001-04

9 Kevin Fortney 2003-06

9 Tanner Zaebst 2013-16

STRIKEOUTS 296 Sam Shafer 2008-11

229 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

201 Alex Kanney 2019-22

187 Josh Dentinger 2015-18

168 Austin Lutz 2013-15

165 Brady Biglin 2016-19

145 Isaac Hiler 2021-24

142 Kaiden Vaughn 2019-22

140 Grant Loy 2013-16

139 Jeremiah Fishpaw 2023-26

SHUTOUTS 4 Sam Shafer 2008-11

Tyler Erwin 2009-12

Josh Dentinger 2015-18

ERA (MIN 50 IP) 1.87 Caydin Jarvis 2025-26

2.10 Alex Kanney 2019-22

2.28 Brent Hays 2006-09

2.37 Josh Dentinger 2015-18

2.41 Matthew Summers 2017-20

2.48 Kaiden Vaughn 2019-22

2.49 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

2.49 Austin Lutz 2013-15

2.57 Kevin Fortney 2003-06

2.75 Derek Erwin 2004-07

SAVES 6 Aaron Marcum 2004-07

IP 212 2/3 Sam Shafer 2008-11

188 1/3 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

157 1/3 Austin Lutz 2013-15

150 Alex Kanney 2019-22

140 Corey Guttenberg 2001-04

139 1/3 Isaac Hiler 2021-24

137 1/3 Derek Erwin 2004-07

134 Brady Biglin 2016-19

133 Josh Dentinger 2015-18

127 2/3 Austin Estridge 2022-25

APPEARANCES 44 Sam Shafer 2008-11

44 Tyler Erwin 2009-12

40 Brent Hays 2006-09

33 Derek Erwin 2004-07

32 Tanner Zaebst 2013-16

32 Jeremiah Fishpaw 2023-26

30 Adam Fritz 2002-05

30 Austin Estridge 2022-25

29 Austin Lutz 2013-15

28 Grant Loy 2013-16

28 Alex Kanney 2019-22

28 Isaac Hiler 2021-24

TEAM GAME RECORDS

RUNS 35 St. Peter’s 2014 (18th ALL TIME IN OHIO)

HITS 23 Cardington-Lincoln 2022

HOME RUNS 4 Bucyrus 2007

Lucas 2012

STOLEN BASES 18 St. Peter’s 2015

DOUBLES 7 Carey 2014

TRIPLES 3 Crestline 2012

BASE ON BALLS 17 Lucas 2008

St. Peter’s 2014

RUNS IN INNING 16 St. Peter’s 2014

TEAM SEASON RECORDS

WINS 23 2011, 2012

RUNS 258 2012

AVERAGE .356 2004, 2006

HOME RUNS 17 2004, 2010

RBI 217 2012

GAMES 30 2010, 2012

ERA 2.32 2011

SHUTOUTS 6 2011, 2012

COMPLETE GAMES 15 2011

STOLEN BASES 154 2012

BASE ON BALLS 169 2012

DOUBLES 62 2010

TRIPLES 22 2012

SACRIFICES 28 2011

CONSECUTIVE WINS TO OPEN SEASON 10 2010

CONSECUTIVE WINS IN A ROW 11 2011

LEAGUE TITLES 2 1973, 2012

SECTIONAL CHAMPS 17 1966, 1968, 1972, 1979, 1980, 1982, 2003,

2006, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011,

2012, 2019, 2022, 2025

DISTRICT CHAMPS 6 1966, 1980, 1982, 2008, 2010, 2011

REGIONAL RUNNER-UP 2 1980, 1982

HIGHEST STATE RANKING 3rd 2010, 2011

HIGHEST FINAL STATE RANKING 4th 2011

STATE RANKED 4 2007 (9th), 2010 (7th), 2011 (4th),

2012 (6th)

CONSECUTIVE GAMES WITHOUT 113 2008-2012 (8TH LONGEST STREAK IN OHIO

BEING SHUTOUT HISTORY)

Page updated

Report abuse