All team Most Valuable Players were voted on by their teammates.
There was no season in 2020 due to Covid-19. 2020's senior class are all represented as MVP's as their season was taken from them.
2007 Derek Erwin
2008 Abram Kaple
2009 Abram Kaple
2010 Tyler Erwin
2011 Sam Shafer
2012 Justin Herrnstein
2013 Bryce Christy
2014 Eric Hanes
2015 Austin Lutz
2016 Grant Loy and Tanner Zaebst
2017 Trent Craft
2018 Josh Dentinger
2019 Brady Biglin
2020 Matthew Summers, Justin Dentinger, Connor McCarthy, Nick Ramey
2021 Alex Kanney
2022 Alex Kanney
2023 Isaac Hiler
2024 Heath Jensen
2025 Austin Estridge
2026 Lance Cole, Jeremiah Fishpaw