The criteria for 'good' design is dependant on the context, and the user.
Below is Dieter Rams' 10 principles of good design. Are these the only criteria you can think of?
Innovation: Good design pushes boundaries and introduces innovative solutions to problems.
Usefulness: Design should serve a purpose and enhance the usability of a product or space.
Aesthetic: Aesthetic considerations are vital; design should be visually appealing and evoke positive emotions.
Understandability: Users should easily comprehend the design and its functionalities.
Unobtrusiveness: Good design does not distract but enhances the user experience subtly.
Honesty: Design should be transparent, conveying its purpose and functionality honestly.
Longevity: Sustainable design considers the durability and longevity of products, minimizing environmental impact.
Environmental Friendliness: Responsible design considers the ecological consequences, emphasizing sustainability.
Functionality: Design must prioritize functionality, ensuring it effectively meets user needs.
Innovative Details: The success of design often lies in the thoughtful consideration of intricate details.
Good design is inherently subjective and varies from person to person. It is influenced by individual tastes, preferences, and experiences, making it a deeply personal concept.
Design is contextual, meaning that what constitutes good design depends on the specific environment, culture, and purpose of the project. A design that works well in one context may not be suitable for another.
Design is intertwined with societal values and power structures. Political considerations in design involve addressing issues of accessibility, representation, and the impact of design decisions on diverse communities.
Universal Aspects: Certain design principles are universally appreciated, such as functionality, simplicity, and aesthetic appeal. These transcend cultural boundaries.
Culturally Specific Elements: Cultural context heavily influences design preferences. Colours, symbols, and materials may hold different meanings and significance in various cultures.
Equitable Use: Design accommodates people with diverse abilities, ensuring everyone can use it.
Flexibility in Use: Design provides various ways to use it, catering to a wide range of user preferences and abilities.
Simple and Intuitive Use: Good design is easy to understand, promoting a seamless user experience.
Perceptible Information: Design communicates information effectively, considering different sensory abilities.
Tolerance for Error: Design minimizes hazards and adverse consequences, forgiving of user errors.
Low Physical Effort: Design minimizes physical effort, promoting accessibility for all users.
Size and Space for Approach and Use: Adequate space is provided for various body sizes and mobility aids.
Read more about the Design Council UK's comprehensive understandings of how designers can apply inclusive design conceptions to their specific fields of work.
Material Selection: Sustainable design considers the life cycle of materials, opting for eco-friendly and recyclable options.
Waste Reduction: Circular design minimises waste by considering the end-of-life disposal and recycling possibilities.
Energy Efficiency: Sustainable design prioritizes energy-efficient solutions to reduce environmental impact.
Ecosystem Considerations: Design decisions assess the broader ecological impact, preserving biodiversity and natural ecosystems.
Seamless Integration: Design seamlessly integrates into users' lives without drawing unnecessary attention.
Effortless Experience: Users interact with the design effortlessly, focusing on the intended purpose rather than the design itself.
User-Centred Approach: Invisible design prioritizes user needs and experiences, emphasizing usability over visual aesthetics.