“Superman” is a song where Taylor describes a boy who left her and hopes he will eventually come back to her when the time is right. She is shown desperately pining for him, looking out a window and wishing that every call was from him.

She explained the meaning of the song before one of her performances: "This is about, well, a guy, as usual. This was a guy that I was sort of enamored with. This song got its title by something that I just said randomly in conversation. When he walked out of the room, I turned to one of my friends and said, ‘It’s like watching Superman fly away.’"