Embedded Files
Summary
Summary
Exposition:
The story opens with Silas, an unemployed student, staying at his sister Bernice's apartment in New York City. Bernice is bold, emotionally intense, and often impulsive, while Silas is more reserved, critical, and distant. Bernice arrives home one day excited about a street performer named Dove, whom she just met and gave her number to.
Inciting Incident:
Bernice begins a relationship with Dove, and the relationship quickly progresses and they have a sudden marriage. Despite Silas's objections and their mother's disapproval, Bernice invites Dove into her life and her home, forever changing the apartment’s emotional and physical space.
Rising Action:
As the three attempt to live in the cramped apartment, tensions rise. Bernice becomes increasingly disapointed with her marriage and Dove’s immaturity. She starts isolating herself and immersing herself in books about colonialism, Black history, and global Black struggles. Her health begins to deteriorate, but doctors dismiss her symptoms as stress-related. Silas begins to witness her health decline more closely.
Climax:
Bernice suffers a seizure while at home. Silas, shaken, calls emergency services and accompanies her to the hospital. Despite multiple tests, the doctors find nothing conclusive. She returns home, only to later suffer a massive stroke that ultimately leads to her death.
Falling Action:
Bernice's death affects both Silas and their mother. Within the characters we can see feeling. of grief, guilt, and emotional paralysis following Bernice's death. Silas cannot bring himself to speak publicly at her service, and their mother lashes out at everyone she holds responsible—including Silas and Dove. Silas quietly begins writing a private eulogy for himself as a way to cope.
Resolution:
Time passes. Silas finds a job and contacts Dove, who comes to collect his things. In a tense final encounter, Silas confronts Dove with the cruel statement that Bernice never truly loved him, using this moment to project his own unresolved grief and guilt. The story ends with Dove emotionally devastated, and Silas reflecting silently in the apartment that still holds the memory of his sister.
Form Of Literature
Form Of Literature
Witness by Jamel Brinkley is a short story, a literary form that is defined by its concise length, focused narrative, and emphasis on character and theme over plot complexity. Short stories typically revolve around an important moment or conflict in the lives of a few central characters, showing a small part of their inner and outer worlds. This form allows for emotional depth, thematic richness, and stylistic experimentation and Witness is a great example of all of these qualities.
Genre
Genre
Jamel Brinkley’s Witness can be categorized as both psychological fiction and urban fiction . . .
Psychological fiction focuses on the inner workings of a character’s mind, exploring their emotions, thoughts, and personal struggles. In Witness, much of the narrative is driven by Silas’s internal conflict. His guilt over neglecting Bernice, his resentment toward his responsibilities, and his struggle to process grief.
Urban fiction is characterized by its setting in a city environment and its focus on the realities of urban life, including themes of race, class, economic struggle, and social issues. Witness is rooted in New York City, with its characters navigating the challenges of city living, such as economic struggles.
Literary Devices
Literary Devices
1. Metaphor
1. Metaphor
Example: "She could crowd you out of your life with the enormity of her own."
This metaphor compares Bernice’s overwhelming presence to something so large it can push others out of their own lives. It shows how emotionally intense she could be to those close to her, especially Silas
2. Personification
2. Personification
Example: "The chill from outside clung to her body.”
The chill is personified as if it has the ability to “cling.” This gives the cold a living quality and creates an image of Bernice entering the apartment still wrapped in the tension and discomfort of the outside world.
3. Hyperbole
3. Hyperbole
Example:
"Everything I saw on the way back to the apartment became the object of my anger. The cracks in the sidewalks, the dust on the parked cars, the slowness of the occasional pedestrian—it all seemed jammed full of stupidity."
This is an example of hyperbole, an extreme exaggeration used to show Silas’s emotional state. His grief and frustration became more intense, showing how affected he is by Bernice’s illness and death.
Themes
Themes
Family & Obligation
Silas struggles with his role in Bernice’s life, knowing that she needs support but also feeling exhausted by it. Silas struggles with his role in Bernice’s life, knowing that she needs support but also feeling exhausted by it.
Emotional Labor & Responsibility
Silas feels the pressure of being Bernice’s support system but struggles with how much he should take on. The story explores the weight of emotional labor. How much of ourselves we should dedicate to helping others, even when we are struggling? Silas is torn between his own needs and the responsibility he feels toward Bernice, raising questions about personal boundaries in relationships.
Healthcare & Societal Expectations
Bernice’s struggles with her physical health and her emergency room visit suggest the toll of mental and emotional burdens. The story critiques how society often neglects mental/physical health, especially for women of color. The story critiques how society often neglects mental/physical health, especially for women of color.
Being a Passive Observer vs. Taking Action
The title Witness itself suggests that Silas often takes on the role of an observer rather than an active participant in Bernice’s struggles. The title Witness itself suggests that Silas often takes on the role of an observer rather than an active participant in Bernice’s struggles.
Application of Literary Criticism: Marxist criticism
Application of Literary Criticism: Marxist criticism
Marxist criticism analyzes literature through the perspective of class struggles, economic power structures, and material conditions. In Witness, Jamel Brinkley highlights the economic instability of the characters, the social pressures they face, and how class differences shape their relationships and struggles. The story critiques the systemic inequalities that effect people of color.
One way Witness fits into marxist criticism is through talking about the financial struggles of Silas and Bernice. Silas, an unemployed adult, is forced to rely on his sister’s generosity, in order to survive in an expensive city like New York. Bernice, despite having a stable job as a high school guidance counselor, carries the financial burden of supporting her brother while also dealing with the stress of her job, and the deterioration of her physical health. This exposes the economic burdens placed on individuals in lower-middle-class positions.
Additionally, the story critiques systemic inequities in healthcare. Bernice’s medical concerns are dismissed as stress-related, which show how marginalized people, especially Black women, are often ignored by the medical system. This reflects how capitalist institutions, including healthcare, don't prioritize those who need care the most. Bernice’s death can be seen as a consequence of these class-based inequalities, reinforcing how the working class and people of color face systemic neglect.
Page updated
Google Sites
Report abuse