Nicholas Starling was a sixteen-year-old boy who in October 2016 murdered his younger brother Harley. During Nicholas's questioning, he admitted to murdering his brother over a fight about Halloween candy they had before the night. Harley was bludgeoned and stabbed by his older brother on October 30th. During the investigation, a lot of evidence was found supporting the idea Nicholas was the murderer such as his clothing with Harley's blood on them and him being the only one on his grandmother's security cameras. He also showed signs of The Homicidal Triad. Harley was described as a sweet boy who always made people smile.