Genre Overview:

The “Commentary” genre allows writers to express their opinions, insights, and analysis on a specific topic. Unlike purely informative essays, commentaries are subjective and often engage with current events, cultural phenomena, or intellectual debates. Writers use this genre to share their perspective, critique, and offer thought-provoking commentary.

Genre in Action:

Commentaries appear in various forms, such as op-eds, blog posts, video essays, social media threads, courtrooms, etc. They tackle diverse subjects, from politics and technology to art and lifestyle. For instance, a commentary might explore the impact of social media algorithms on mental health, analyze the symbolism in a recent film, or discuss the implications of a scientific discovery. Take the sports world for example, networks like ESPN and Fox engage heavily in the Commentary genre. For example, as the host of The Herd, Colin Cowherd brings a distinctive approach to sports commentary. Cowherd isn’t afraid to challenge conventional wisdom, often sparking debates and encouraging listeners to think critically about sports-related topics. His show centers on specific sports stories, diving deep into analysis.  Additionally, his interviews with athletes, coaches, and analysts add depth to his commentary, revealing behind-the-scenes details and personal perspectives. Ultimately, Cowherd combines thought-provoking opinions, topic-driven discussions, and engaging interviews to provide a comprehensive commentary on the sports world. Another example to consider is debating. Take the famous debater John Farmer. Farmer’s nonviolent direct-action tone drew inspiration from Mahatma Gandhi’s principles, emphasizing peaceful resistance and social change. In 1935, Farmer's Wiley College debate team faced off against the reigning champions, the University of Southern California. The topic: “Should the United States recognize the Soviet Union?” Farmer, armed with facts and conviction, dismantled opposing arguments. His words cut through prejudice and ignorance, revealing the power of reason and empathy. Wiley College emerged victorious, and Farmer became a legend—the Great Debater.  In a more general sense, our lives revolve around how we see the world and how we believe it can be better. In light of this, never forget your inherent bias and always do your utmost to expand your knowledge and understanding of the topic before giving your opinion. 

Remember - The best-received comments are those that are made from a place of experience, knowledge and understanding. One great way to do this is by playing the "Believing and Doubting" game. First, passionately defend your stance on your topic, then use the same vigor to disagree with your thesis. At the end of the process, take time to reflect and find rational ground. 

Commentary in Practice:

Free Write

1. How has a recent event or social issue affected you personally? Share your thoughts and emotions.

2. How has technology changed the way we communicate, connect, or perceive the world? Discuss its impact.

3. Analyze the role of media (news, social media, entertainment) in shaping public opinion. Is it a force for good or harm?

4. Imagine you’re an education policymaker. What changes would you implement to improve the system?

5. Predict a trend or development that will significantly impact society in the next decade.

Mini-Activity: Analyzing a Recent Event

Step 1: Select a recent event or issue that interests you. It could be a political development, a cultural phenomenon, or a scientific breakthrough.

Step 2: Gather information about the event from reliable sources. Understand its context, implications, and various perspectives.

Step 3: Write Your Commentary. 

1. Introduce the event and your viewpoint.

2. Analyze its significance, impact, or underlying causes.

3. Discuss potential solutions or further exploration.

4. Engage with readers by asking questions or inviting discussion.

Step 3: Edit your commentary for clarity, coherence, and conciseness. Ensure your argument is compelling and well-supported.
Step 4: Share your commentary with peers or online communities. Engage in thoughtful conversations about the topic.

Questions to ask AI

1. How can I ensure that my commentary engages readers and provokes thought?

2. How do I select a topic for my commentary?

3. Are there instances where objectivity is more appropriate in commentary writing?

4. How do I address opposing viewpoints in my commentary?

5. What strategies can I use to refute counterarguments effectively?

6. What elements should be included in my thesis statement for a commentary?

7. What is an example of a commentary that is clear and impactful?

8. What types of evidence (statistics, anecdotes, expert opinions) strengthen a commentary?

9. How do I integrate examples seamlessly into my writing?

10. How do I strike the right tone for my commentary? Serious, conversational, or passionate?