Formerly known as The Muff 'n' Men, the team was founded in 2007 and is now the top competitive Mixed Club team in Pittsburgh.

In 2015, the team was forced to compete as "The Muffin Men" by USA Ultimate, after ranking Nationally during the Regular Season.

In 2016, Alloy went undefeated at Mid-Atlantic Regionals and claimed the program's first bid to Nationals.

In 2017, Alloy fell to Philadelphia AMP in finals and took 2nd place at Mid-Atlantic Regionals.