District: St Charles Ave - Full Control
Owner: Clinton L Szubinski
HDLC Staff: Michala Daniels
Rating: Contributing
Applicant: Loretta Harmon
Permit #: 25-14311-HDLC
Description: Renovation of a Contributing rated, two-story, single-family residential building including new entry to carriage house.
Previous ARC Recommendations:
07/22/25: The ARC recommended conceptual approval with the details to be worked out at the staff level with the proviso that the new door needs to be submitted to the HDLC for approval.
05/20/25: The ARC found that the proposed overhang and overall massing of the new entry overwhelm the historic structure. The applicant is encouraged to try cantilevering the overhang so that the columns and porch can be removed. The massing should be reduced, and the gable roof retained. The applicant is also encouraged to explore alternative designs that result in overhangs that are more subordinate and complementary to the historic building. Additionally, the ARC recommends presenting multiple design schemes for the overhangs and overall massing to aid in further review and discussion.
Scheme D
Scheme F
Scheme D
Scheme F
Scheme D
Scheme F