How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a drop-in filter pack built specifically for a 6-quart air fryer with ClearCook and OdorErase, choose Naroote Air Fryer Replacement; if you need a cheap, universal sponge filter that fits almost any air fryer you already own, choose TiaoBug Charcoal.
• Naroote's biggest strength: It's purpose-built for 6-quart fryers with ClearCook and OdorErase, so fit and function are matched to a specific machine rather than guessed at.
• Naroote's biggest trade-off: That specificity cuts both ways — if your fryer isn't a 6-quart ClearCook/OdorErase model, this pack isn't for you.
• TiaoBug's biggest strength: One-size 100% sponge construction and a 12-piece pack mean broad compatibility and plenty of spares for almost any air fryer.
• TiaoBug's biggest trade-off: "Universal" is a compromise — a one-size sponge won't be tailored to any single fryer's filter housing the way a model-specific filter is.
• Pick Naroote if you own a 6-quart ClearCook/OdorErase fryer and want filters engineered for that exact housing.
• Pick TiaoBug if you want a flexible, multi-piece sponge pack that works across most common air fryers.
Naroote's pack is a compatibility-first product. The filters are made from fiber and sized at roughly 16 x 5 cm (about 6.3 x 2.0 inches), each weighing around 16 grams. That's a thin, light filter designed to slot into the top-mounted filter housing of a 6-quart fryer with ClearCook and OdorErase. The whole point of the design is that it doesn't ask you to improvise — it's shaped for one class of machine.
The job it does is twofold: it traps grease and smoke particles, and it uses the replaceable-filter approach to cut down lingering cooking odors. If you cook fish, onions, or anything with a strong aroma, that second function is the one you'll notice most. The kit ships with 8 filters, which matters because these are consumables — you're not buying one filter, you're buying a rotation.
Replacement is genuinely simple in concept: unplug the unit, lift the filter housing off the top, dispose of the old filters, and seat the new ones. No tools, no disassembly.
Who should buy it: owners of a 6-quart ClearCook/OdorErase fryer who want filters that are guaranteed to fit and who want a multi-pack so they aren't reordering constantly.
TiaoBug Charcoal: Who It's For
TiaoBug takes the opposite approach. Instead of fitting one machine precisely, it aims to fit as many as possible. The filters are 100% sponge — soft and porous by design — and the white color gives them a clean, neutral look inside the fryer. The pack comes with 12 pieces, which is the real story here: you get a healthy stock of spares.
The one-size format is the selling point and the limitation at the same time. It means the filter is meant to drop into most common air fryers rather than being cut for a specific housing. For a lot of buyers that's exactly what they want — a simple consumable they can swap in and out without hunting for a model number. Installation and removal are described as straightforward, and that's the whole maintenance story: pull the old one, drop in a new one.
The sponge material is aimed at absorbing oil residue and odors rather than acting as a precision-engineered component. For everyday home cooking and baking, that's a reasonable job description. It's not trying to be a high-spec part; it's trying to be an easy, plentiful one.
Who should buy it: people with a common air fryer who want a universal sponge filter and don't want to think hard about compatibility, plus anyone who likes having a dozen spares on hand.
Who should skip it: owners of a 6-quart ClearCook/OdorErase fryer who want a filter that's matched to their housing. If fit precision matters more to you than flexibility, the universal sponge isn't the right call.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for exact fit on a 6-quart ClearCook/OdorErase fryer → Naroote. The filter is sized and specified for that housing.
• Best for broad compatibility → TiaoBug. One-size sponge is designed to fit most common air fryers.
• Best if you want a filter built around odor-erase technology → Naroote. The replaceable-filter design is tied to that function.
• Best for grease and smoke particle capture as a stated function → Naroote. Its description explicitly covers trapping grease and smoke.
• Best for a simple sponge-style consumable → TiaoBug. 100% sponge, soft and porous, no complexity.
• Best if you already know your exact fryer model → Naroote. Specificity rewards you when you're certain.
• Best if you own multiple air fryers or aren't sure of your model → TiaoBug. Universal sizing travels better.
In my opinion, the deciding question isn't which filter is "better" — it's whether you know your fryer. If you own a 6-quart ClearCook/OdorErase unit, I'd buy the Naroote pack. It's designed for that exact housing, it's built around odor and grease capture, and 8 filters is a solid rotation for a consumable you'll replace regularly. Paying attention to fit beats paying attention to piece count when the filter actually has to seat correctly.
If you don't have that specific fryer, or you'd rather have a universal sponge and a dozen spares, TiaoBug is the more sensible pick. It won't be tailor-made for your machine, but it's designed to work across most of them, and that flexibility is worth more than precision you can't use.
FAQ
Naroote includes 8 fiber filters, each around 16 grams and roughly 16 x 5 cm. TiaoBug includes 12 sponge filters in a one-size format. TiaoBug gives you more pieces; Naroote gives you a model-specific fit.
Physically it's a one-size sponge meant to fit most common air fryers, so it may seat in many units. But it isn't designed for that specific housing, so I wouldn't expect the same tailored fit as the Naroote filter.
Neither listing states a fixed interval, so it comes down to use and how much odor or grease buildup you notice. That's exactly why the multi-packs matter — Naroote's 8 and TiaoBug's 12 both give you a stock to rotate through. Check the current price on Amazon before deciding which pack size suits your cooking frequency.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Covermates Keepsakes Air Fryer vs HQT Air Fryer Replacement, Croask Replacement Air Fryer vs E-far 11.8: Air Fryer Fried, OLIKIUS Air Fryer Replacement vs LHSHAD Air Fryer Liners