We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a drop-in replacement basket for a Ninja Foodi that keeps your existing countertop air fryer running, choose Croask Replacement Air Fryer; if you need oven-sized stainless steel air fryer racks for crispy fried chicken in a full-size convection oven, choose E-far 11.8.
These two get compared a lot because both are sold as "air fryer baskets" and both promise crispy fried chicken. But they are not the same product category at all. One is a model-specific replacement part. The other is a universal oven rack set. Pick the wrong one and it simply won't fit what you own.
• Croask's biggest strength: It is built specifically for Ninja Foodi SP300, SP201, SP301, SP351 and FT301, so it slots into a machine you already own with the correct 13.46 x 12.32 x 1.38 inch footprint.
• Croask's biggest trade-off: It only fits those listed Ninja Foodi models. If you own any other brand or model, it is the wrong purchase.
• E-far's biggest strength: Two 11.8" x 9.1" x 1.9" stainless steel racks with a raised wire base for 360° airflow, rated up to 500°F and dishwasher safe — no non-stick coating to peel.
• E-far's biggest trade-off: It is not a plug-in appliance. It needs a convection oven, toaster oven or dehydrator to do the cooking.
• Who Croask is for: Ninja Foodi owners whose original basket is worn, damaged or lost.
• Who E-far is for: Oven cooks who want air-fryer-style crisping on a sheet-pan-sized rack, in pairs.
The Croask basket is a direct replacement for the air fry basket inside several Ninja Foodi models. The listed compatibility is SP300, SP201, SP301, SP351 and FT301, and the basket measures 13.46 x 12.32 x 1.38 inches. If your Foodi is one of those, this is a like-for-like swap rather than an upgrade.
The material is chrome-plated steel, which the spec sheet calls out as strong, heavy duty and heat resistant. Chrome plating matters here for a simple reason: a replacement basket lives inside a hot, greasy, repeatedly washed environment, and bare steel would be a poor long-term choice. The grid pattern is designed to keep air moving around food so it heats evenly — the same principle behind every crispy result you get from an air fryer.
What it handles: frying crispy chicken, french fries, pizza, onions, chicken wings, steak and fried vegetables, plus dehydrating fruit and meat. Capacity is listed at 12 liters, which is the volume of the cooking cavity it sits in rather than a small rack. Control method is touch, and output wattage is 1600 watts — those are the numbers of the host appliance it belongs to.
E-far 11.8: Who It's For
E-far sells a two-pack of stainless steel air fryer racks, each 11.8" x 9.1" x 1.9". These are not tied to any appliance brand. They fit standard countertop convection ovens, toaster ovens and dehydrators, and you can run both at once to double capacity or stack them for compact storage.
The construction is the interesting part. It is solid food-grade stainless steel with no non-stick coating at all — nothing to flake, peel or leach at high heat. The rated maximum is 500°F, which covers roasting and broiling territory well beyond typical air frying. The wire frame is thickened and fully welded rather than loosely assembled, and the edges are polished smooth and burr-free, so there are no hidden gaps trapping crumbs.
The design does real work for fried chicken specifically. A raised wire base lifts food off the surface so hot air circulates 360° and grease drips away instead of pooling. E-far states this means you seldom need to flip food mid-cook, and that it cuts fat substantially compared with deep frying. The 1.9-inch deep sides hold more food and support heavier roasts, four support bars keep small items like shrimp and vegetables from dropping through the grid, and the swing handles rotate for easier handling and storage.
Buy it if: you cook in a convection oven or toaster oven and want crispy, low-fat results on a large rack — or you want two racks for dehydrating, roasting, cooling fried food, or washing and drying produce. Skip it if: you want a self-contained appliance, or you need a part that fits a specific air fryer. This is a rack, not a machine.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for replacing a Ninja Foodi basket → Croask Replacement Air Fryer. It is model-specific and dimensioned for SP300, SP201, SP301, SP351 and FT301.
• Best for oven-based air frying → E-far 11.8. It works in convection ovens, toaster ovens and dehydrators regardless of brand.
• Best for coating-free cooking → E-far 11.8. Pure food-grade stainless steel, zero non-stick layers.
• Best for doubling capacity at once → E-far 11.8. Two racks in the pack, stackable when not in use.
• Best for a single fixed cooking cavity → Croask Replacement Air Fryer. The 12-liter, 1600-watt Ninja Foodi setup it belongs to.
• Best for easy cleanup in both cases → a tie. Croask is dishwasher safe and soaks clean; E-far's mirror-polished stainless is dishwasher safe with smooth, seamless rims.
• Best for small, loose foods → E-far 11.8. The tight mesh and support bars stop shrimp and chopped vegetables falling through.
In my opinion, the right answer depends entirely on what you already own. If there is a Ninja Foodi SP201/SP300/SP301/SP351/FT301 sitting on your counter with a tired basket inside, buy the Croask — it is the exact part, sized 13.46 x 12.32 x 1.38 inches, and nothing else will fit that slot.
If you do not own one of those models, the E-far 11.8 two-pack is the more useful buy. Two large stainless racks, no coating, 500°F rated, dishwasher safe, and genuinely versatile for fried chicken, roasting, dehydrating and cooling. That is the one I would pick for most kitchens, and it is the one I recommend for oven and toaster-oven cooks.
how to air fryer fried chicken
Pat the chicken dry, season it, and give the pieces a light oil coating rather than a wet batter. Lay them on a raised rack so air moves underneath — the E-far rack's wire base is designed for exactly this 360° circulation — and cook at high heat until the coating is crisp and the interior reaches a safe temperature. A rack that lifts food off the surface is the single biggest factor in even crisping.
how to air fryer fried chicken breast
Breasts are thick and lean, so flatten them slightly or cut them thinner for even cooking. Coat lightly and place them on a rack with space between pieces so hot air reaches every side. Because the E-far design lets grease drip away and circulates air around the food, you generally do not need to flip mid-cook, which helps keep the coating intact.
how to make air fryer fried chicken without buttermilk
Use a wet binder you already have — plain yogurt, an egg wash, or even a thin coat of mustard — then press on seasoned breadcrumbs, panko or flour. The binder is only there to make the coating stick. From there, cook on a raised wire rack so the underside crisps instead of steaming, which is where the E-far's lifted base earns its place.
how to make air fryer fried chicken tenders
Tenders cook fast, so keep them in a single layer with gaps between them and use a tight mesh rack so nothing slips through. The E-far basket's close wire grid and support bars are built for small pieces like this. If you are using a Ninja Foodi instead, the Croask basket handles tenders fine — just do not overcrowd it, because crowded food steams rather than crisps.
One practical note on both: since these listings can change, check the current price on Amazon before you commit, and confirm your appliance model against the compatibility list before buying the Croask.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: SIUDANGKA Crumb Tray Replacement vs Anniparts 304: Air Fryer, TCSNOE 180PCS vs GWYSY Air Fryer Replacement, oecue Air Fryer Replacement vs M4Y Replacement Air Fryer