How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a wider 8.74-inch grill pan that fits Power XL 5 QT baskets and includes a built-in handle plus four rubber bumpers, choose oecue Air Fryer Replacement; if you need a tray sized for Ninja AF101, AF150, or AF161 with a heat-flowing perforated design that keeps food evenly heated, choose M4Y Replacement Air Fryer.
• oecue Air Fryer Replacement — biggest strength: a stainless steel grill plate with a double-layer non-stick enamel coating, a handle for lifting it out of a hot basket, and four rubber bumpers included in the pack.
• oecue Air Fryer Replacement — biggest trade-off: it is built for Power XL 5 QT only, and the brand itself warns it is not suitable for other models.
• M4Y Replacement Air Fryer — biggest strength: a heat-flowing design with air holes across the tray so heat moves between the top and bottom of the food, plus compatibility with several Ninja models.
• M4Y Replacement Air Fryer — biggest trade-off: it is tied to Ninja AF101, AF150, and AF161 (plus a few related Ninja lines), so it is useless if you own a different brand.
• Who each pick is for: oecue for Power XL 5 QT owners who want a handled, bumper-cushioned grill pan; M4Y for Ninja AF101/AF150/AF161 owners who want even airflow and a simple dishwasher-safe tray.
The oecue Air Fryer Replacement is a 5 QT round grill plate measuring 8.74 inches across and about 0.2 inches thick, made from food-grade stainless steel with an enameled, double-layer non-stick coating. The coating is PTFE-based and the brand states the materials are BPA-free and meet FDA standards. In practice, that means you get a flat, perforated-style crisper plate you can drop into the basket to lift food off the bottom — the kind of setup that helps fries, wings, and vegetables crisp instead of steaming in their own drippings.
What I like most about the design is the handle. Anyone who has tried to fish a hot plate out of an air fryer basket knows the problem: tongs slip, fingers get close to hot metal, and food goes flying. A handle solves that in one motion. The four rubber bumpers are a smart second detail too — they sit on the underside of the plate and keep it from rattling or scratching the basket coating while the air circulates.
M4Y Replacement Air Fryer: Who It's For
The M4Y Replacement Air Fryer is a round stainless steel tray with a non-stick coating, an 8-inch diameter, and a compact profile that fits neatly into the basket. Its headline feature is the heat-flowing design: the tray has enough air holes across its surface that hot air passes through from top to bottom, which is exactly what you want when you are trying to cook food evenly rather than char one side and leave the other pale.
Compatibility is the other half of the story. M4Y builds this tray for Ninja air fryer models AF101, AF150, and AF161, and the listing also references AF141, AF181, SL401, and SL451, along with FD401 Foodi and OP300–OP500 crisper plate replacement use. That is a genuinely useful spread if you own one of those Ninja machines, because the tray fits the basket properly and stays stable while the air fryer runs. A tray that shifts around mid-cook is annoying at best and messy at worst.
Who should buy it: Ninja AF101, AF150, or AF161 owners who want a dishwasher-safe replacement tray with strong airflow and a non-stick surface that wipes clean by hand if you would rather not run the machine. Who should skip it: anyone outside that Ninja family. If your air fryer is a Power XL, a Chefman, a Dash, or a GoWise, this tray is not made for your basket, and the brand's own note asks you to confirm your model before ordering.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for Power XL 5 QT owners → oecue Air Fryer Replacement. It is designed specifically for that 5 QT basket and measures 8.74 inches across.
• Best for easy handling while cooking → oecue Air Fryer Replacement. The built-in handle lets you lift the plate out of a hot basket without tongs.
• Best for even airflow around food → M4Y Replacement Air Fryer. The heat-flowing perforated design pushes hot air through the tray from top to bottom.
• Best for protecting your basket from scratches → oecue Air Fryer Replacement. Four rubber bumpers are included to cushion the plate and keep it from sliding.
• Best for a low-fuss dishwasher cycle → either one. Both trays are dishwasher safe, and both use a non-stick coating that wipes down easily by hand.
• Best for a food-grade material story → either one. Both are stainless steel with non-stick coatings and food-grade safety language, so neither has an edge there.
• Best for anyone who has not measured their basket yet → neither, until you check. Both brands warn that the fit has to match your exact model.
In my opinion, the choice comes down to one question: which air fryer is sitting on your counter? If it is a Power XL 5 QT, I would buy the oecue Air Fryer Replacement — the handle and the rubber bumpers are the kind of small design choices that make daily cooking less irritating, and the 8.74-inch size is made for that basket. If you own a Ninja AF101, AF150, or AF161, I would buy the M4Y Replacement Air Fryer instead, because compatibility beats everything else and the heat-flowing hole pattern is a real advantage for even cooking. Neither is a universal part, so match the model first and the rest falls into place.
FAQ
how to clean ninja air fryer grill pan
Take the tray out of the basket once it has cooled, then either run it through the dishwasher or hand wash it with warm water and a soft sponge. The M4Y tray has a non-stick coating, so the brand notes that oil residue comes off with a gentle rub rather than scrubbing.
A grill pan sits inside the basket and lifts food off the bottom so air circulates underneath. Note that neither tray here is made for Philips models — the oecue plate is built for Power XL 5 QT and the M4Y tray for Ninja AF101, AF150, and AF161 — so check your basket size before buying any replacement plate.
how long to grill paneer in air fryer
Paneer cooks fast because it is a soft, high-moisture cheese, so a short cook at a moderate-to-high temperature is the usual approach, turning the pieces once so both sides brown. Using a perforated tray like the M4Y Replacement Air Fryer helps the hot air reach the underside, which is what gives you an even sear instead of a pale bottom.
will this tray fit my air fryer if it is not a Power XL or Ninja
No. The oecue Air Fryer Replacement is designed for Power XL 5 QT and the brand states it is not suitable for other models, and the M4Y Replacement Air Fryer is made for specific Ninja models including AF101, AF150, and AF161. Both brands ask you to confirm your model and measure your basket before ordering.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GWYXC Air Fryer Replacement vs TEHAUX Air Fryer Silver, oecue 10 vs CURTA 8: Air Fryer Baking Pan, Sufeasdf Handles vs GXCSY Air Fryer Replacement