We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a mess-free, high-volume supply of disposable liners that keep your Emeril Lagasse 26QT trays clean with almost zero effort, choose TCSNOE 180PCS; if you need a sturdy stainless steel crumb tray that actually replaces a worn or missing pan and stands up to heavy, greasy cooking, choose GWYSY Air Fryer Replacement. These two accessories are often bought by the same kind of shopper — someone with the extra-large French-door air fryer oven — but they solve completely different problems. One is about convenience and cleanup. The other is about hardware. Here is how I'd decide between them.
• TCSNOE 180PCS — biggest strength: 180 food-grade, unbleached parchment liners (60 perforated + 120 standard) sized for the Emeril Lagasse 26QT, heat-resistant to 450°F, so you can line a tray, cook, then toss the mess.
• TCSNOE 180PCS — biggest trade-off: These are disposable consumables. They protect a tray you already own, but they are not a replacement part — once the 180 sheets are gone, you buy again.
• GWYSY Air Fryer Replacement — biggest strength: A 13''×12.5''×1'' food-grade stainless steel crumb tray plus 4 baking mats, dishwasher safe and rated up to 480°F — a real, reusable hardware replacement.
• GWYSY Air Fryer Replacement — biggest trade-off: It is a single tray with a required preheat step (300°F for 10 minutes before first use) and a careful-cleaning warning, so it demands more attention than tossing paper.
• Who each pick is for: TCSNOE 180PCS for the cook who hates scrubbing and wants everyday convenience; GWYSY Air Fryer Replacement for the cook whose original tray is damaged, warped, or missing and who wants durable stainless steel.
TCSNOE 180PCS is, at its core, a cleanup solution. It's a 180-piece set of parchment paper liners built specifically to fit the Emeril Lagasse Extra Large 26QT French door air fryer toaster oven combo. The set splits into 60 perforated sheets and 120 standard sheets, which matters more than it sounds: the perforated ones let air circulate for crispier results, while the standard sheets are better for baking, roasting, and reheating where you want a solid barrier against grease and crumbs. That mix gives you a liner for basically any tray in the machine.
Who should buy it? If you use your 26QT oven several times a week and you're tired of soaking and scraping trays, this is the low-effort route. It suits busy home cooks, batch-cookers, and anyone who values convenience over doing dishes. Who should skip it? If your actual tray is broken, bent, or missing, liners won't fix that — they sit on top of a tray you still need. And if you prefer a reusable setup with no recurring consumable, this isn't that. If cost over the long run matters to you, it's worth checking the current price on Amazon against how often you'd restock, since 180 sheets is a finite supply.
GWYSY Air Fryer Replacement: Who It's For
GWYSY Air Fryer Replacement is the opposite kind of product: it's hardware, not a consumable. The centerpiece is a stainless steel crumb tray measuring 13''×12.5''×1'', designed for the Emeril Lagasse 26QT Extra Large Air Fryer with French doors. This is the part you'd reach for when the original tray has warped, gotten damaged, or gone missing and you want to keep the oven running rather than replace the whole appliance.
Two details stand out from the spec sheet. First, the material: food-grade stainless steel, BPA-free, non-toxic and tasteless, meeting FDA standards. Second — and this is the one buyers tend to miss — there's a required preheat step. Because of how the stainless steel behaves, you're supposed to preheat the set at 300°F for 10 minutes before first use. The manufacturer is explicit that skipping this can cause the pan to deform, bend, or be damaged, shortening its lifespan. The tray itself is rated up to 480°F, but that preheat is non-negotiable.
Cleaning is a genuine plus: it's dishwasher safe, and the description notes that even stuck-on splatter comes off after a quick soak. The trade-off is a warning — don't scrub it with a rough abrasive cloth or metal balls, or you risk damaging the finish. Alongside the tray you get 4 baking mats, which broadens what you can do: grilling, baking, frying, and handling everything from chicken wings and fries to vegetables, pizza, and steak.
Who should buy it? Anyone whose 26QT oven needs a replacement tray, or who wants a more durable, reusable stainless steel surface instead of disposable liners. Who should skip it? If your trays are perfectly fine and your real pain point is cleanup, a reusable tray still means washing it — the liners solve that problem more directly. Also, measure your device first, as the maker advises, to confirm the 13''×12.5'' footprint fits.
• Best for zero-scrub cleanup → TCSNOE 180PCS. Disposable, non-stick liners catch grease and crumbs so trays stay spotless.
• Best for replacing a damaged or missing tray → GWYSY Air Fryer Replacement. It's an actual stainless steel crumb tray, not a liner.
• Best for crispiness control → TCSNOE 180PCS. The 60 perforated sheets are made for airflow and crispy results; the 120 standard sheets handle baking and roasting.
• Best for long-term durability → GWYSY Air Fryer Replacement. Stainless steel rated to 480°F and dishwasher safe, built to be reused rather than thrown away.
• Best for bulk convenience → TCSNOE 180PCS. 180 sheets means you're set for a long stretch of everyday cooking without restocking.
• Best for versatility across foods → GWYSY Air Fryer Replacement. The tray plus 4 baking mats cover grilling, baking, and frying for wings, fries, veg, pizza, and steak.
• Best for low-maintenance buyers → TCSNOE 180PCS. No preheat ritual, no abrasive-cleaning warnings — just line, cook, toss.
• Best for hands-on cooks who don't mind a little care → GWYSY Air Fryer Replacement. The required 300°F, 10-minute preheat and gentle cleaning are a fair trade for a reusable part.
My Verdict
In my opinion, these aren't really competitors — they're complements, and the right pick comes down to what's actually broken or annoying in your kitchen. If your 26QT oven works fine and your only complaint is the scrubbing, I'd buy TCSNOE 180PCS: the 60 perforated plus 120 standard liners cover crisp and bake jobs, and the cleanup savings are immediate. If your tray is damaged, warped, or gone — or you simply want durable stainless steel instead of disposables — I'd buy GWYSY Air Fryer Replacement, and I'd follow that preheat step exactly as stated. For most people with a working oven and a dish-aversion, the liners win. For anyone fixing hardware, the tray wins.
No. It's a set of 180 disposable parchment liners (60 perforated, 120 standard) that sit on your existing trays. It protects and simplifies cleanup, but you still need a tray underneath.
The stainless steel crumb tray measures 13''×12.5''×1'' and is designed for the Emeril Lagasse 26QT Extra Large Air Fryer with French doors. The maker advises measuring your device before ordering to confirm fit.
Yes. The manufacturer states you should preheat the set at 300°F for 10 minutes before first use, otherwise the stainless steel may deform, bend, or be damaged. The tray is rated up to 480°F after that.
It depends on your need, not just the number. TCSNOE gives you 180 disposable liners for convenience; GWYSY gives you a reusable stainless steel tray plus 4 baking mats. For current pricing on both, check the price on Amazon before deciding.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: SOIMISS Air Fryer Basket vs MAGICLULU Replacement Air Fryer, oecue Air Fryer Replacement vs M4Y Replacement Air Fryer, DOITOOL Toast Rack Holder vs GWYSY 13″×13″Air: Air Fryer