How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• Covermates Keepsakes Air Fryer — biggest strength: a two-layer quilted polyester shell with polyfiber padding that slips over an air fryer or deep fryer to block dust, grease and scratches when the appliance isn't in use.
• Covermates Keepsakes Air Fryer — biggest trade-off: it is a cover, not a part. It does nothing for cooking performance, and it only fits appliances up to 20"W x 15"D x 11"H.
• HQT Air Fryer Replacement — biggest strength: a food-grade 304 stainless steel crisper tray with a double-layer non-stick coating, a lift-out handle and a dishwasher-safe design, sized for 7QT PowerXL, GoWise and similar baskets.
• HQT Air Fryer Replacement — biggest trade-off: it is a single-purpose insert. If your tray is fine, it has nothing to offer you, and it will not fit every air fryer on the market.
• Who each pick is for: Covermates Keepsakes Air Fryer is for the person whose counter, pantry shelf or cabinet is crowded and dusty; HQT Air Fryer Replacement is for the person whose existing crisper plate has scratched, peeled or vanished.
Think of this as the "put it away properly" side of air fryer maintenance. The Covermates Keepsakes Air Fryer is a slip-on appliance cover made from two layers of quilted polyester filled with polyfiber padding, finished in a deep red diamond-stitched pattern. It slides over your air fryer or deep fryer and shields it from the things that quietly age a countertop appliance: dust settling on the vents, cooking grease drifting across the counter, and the small scratches that come from being nudged around a crowded shelf.
The fit is the part you need to check before buying. It's designed for appliances up to 20"W x 15"D x 11"H (50.8 x 38.1 x 27.9 cm). Measure your air fryer with the basket in place — that's the footprint the cover has to swallow. If your unit is larger, this isn't the one.
Who should buy it: anyone who stores an air fryer on an open counter, in a pantry, or in a cabinet and wants it to look tidy and stay clean between cooks. It's also a decent fit for a household with limited cabinet space, where appliances live out in the open and collect whatever the kitchen throws at them. Who should skip it: anyone who uses their air fryer daily and leaves it out mid-project, or anyone whose appliance exceeds those dimensions. A cover only pays off if the appliance actually spends time covered.
HQT Air Fryer Replacement: Who It's For
This is the "restore the inside" side of maintenance. The HQT Air Fryer Replacement is a crisper tray — the perforated grill plate that sits in the bottom of your air fryer basket so air can circulate under the food. It's made from food-grade 304 stainless steel, BPA-free and described as non-toxic and tasteless, with a double-layer non-stick coating applied so the surface resists flaking.
The design details are what make it practical. The air circulation pattern is meant to let hot air move under and around the food for more even crisping, and there's a handle built in so you can lift the tray straight out of the basket instead of digging at it with a spatula. It's dishwasher safe, which matters more than it sounds — the tray is the part of an air fryer that collects the most baked-on grease. In the box you get the grill plate, four rubber bumpers that protect the basket's non-stick surface from metal-on-metal scraping, and a non-stick cleaning cloth.
Fit is where you need to be careful. The tray measures 10.3 x 9.5 inches and is intended for 7QT air fryers, specifically PowerXL and GoWise, along with Dash, Gourmia, Emeril Lagasse and Uten models. HQT's own guidance is blunt and worth repeating: measure your basket before ordering. Brand names don't guarantee a match across model years. And when you clean it, keep abrasive pads and metal scrubbers away from the coating — that's the whole reason the soft cloth is included.
Who should buy it: anyone whose original crisper plate has lost its coating, warped, or gone missing, and anyone who wants a second tray so they can cook back-to-back batches without washing in between. Who should skip it: anyone with a 5QT or 8QT basket, or anyone whose current tray is still in good shape. This is a replacement part, not an upgrade you'd buy on a whim.
• Best for protecting an appliance you're not using → Covermates Keepsakes Air Fryer, for its quilted dust and scratch barrier.
• Best for restoring cooking performance → HQT Air Fryer Replacement, because a fresh crisper tray directly affects how evenly food browns.
• Best for dusty counters and open shelving → Covermates Keepsakes Air Fryer, which is exactly the scenario the padded shell was designed around.
• Best for easy cleanup after greasy batches → HQT Air Fryer Replacement, thanks to the dishwasher-safe stainless tray and lift-out handle.
• Best for households with limited cabinet space → Covermates Keepsakes Air Fryer, since it lets an appliance live on the counter without looking like clutter.
• Best for 7QT PowerXL or GoWise owners → HQT Air Fryer Replacement, which is sized specifically for that basket class.
• Best for long-term peace of mind → Covermates Keepsakes Air Fryer, which carries a 3-year warranty against material and craftsmanship defects.
• Best if you're unsure what you need → measure first. If your appliance is under 20"W x 15"D x 11"H and spends time stored, you want the cover. If your basket is 7QT and the tray is worn, you want the insert.
In my opinion, these two aren't really competing — they're two stages of the same maintenance routine, and most people searching both names need to figure out which stage they're in. If I had to point one shopper at one product, I'd send the 7QT PowerXL owner with a scratched, flaking crisper plate straight to the HQT Air Fryer Replacement, because a degraded tray is a functional problem that affects every meal you cook. If your air fryer works fine but looks grimy and dusty sitting on the counter, I'd buy the Covermates Keepsakes Air Fryer instead. Buy for the problem you actually have, and check the current price on Amazon before you commit either way.
No. It's a fabric cover that slips over the outside of an air fryer or deep fryer for dust, grease and scratch protection during storage. It contains no cooking components and doesn't go inside the appliance.
It's designed for 7QT baskets, including PowerXL and GoWise, and measures 10.3 x 9.5 inches. HQT recommends measuring your basket before ordering, because fit varies between brands and models even at the same quart size.
Yes, for larger stains — the fabric is stain-resistant and handles a wash. Spot cleaning with mild soap and water and air drying is the everyday option. Avoid bleach and fabric softener to protect the material.
Wash it gently. HQT specifically warns against rough abrasive cloths and metal scouring balls, which is why a soft non-stick cleaning cloth is included in the package. The four rubber bumpers also help prevent the tray from scraping your basket.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: OLIKIUS Air Fryer Replacement vs LHSHAD Air Fryer Liners, Croask Replacement Air Fryer vs E-far 11.8: Air Fryer Fried, SOIMISS Air Fryer Basket vs MAGICLULU Replacement Air Fryer