Trust the Process
Introduction
“Where do I start?” is a question I quibbled with when I was asked by two of my friends to tutor them in English two years ago. Despite my continuous attempts at designing a curriculum that would suit my students’ needs, I never had the full picture of what it takes to design a “perfect course.” When I had the chance to work independently, I had floating questions that roamed without a linear order about the process: where to access good material, how to choose them and why, how do I know what my learners need? Should I consider their needs to begin with or should I be the one making the decisions about what they need? These concerns, among others, led me to reject their request to tutor them.
In the course of the LTS program, I encountered the book: Designing language courses: A guide for teachers by Kathleen Graves. Graves (2000) states, “course design tended to be portrayed as a more-or-less systematic process with results that did not resemble the messy, multi-faceted, two-steps-forward one-step-back process that I had experienced in my own designing of courses and recognized in that of teachers I worked with.” (p.2). The first time I was introduced to this concept, I realized that curriculum development is an iterative process and that it was normal for me to ask these questions. In fact, asking these questions is the driving force and the starting point of curriculum design.
Artifact #1: Scope and Sequence Chart from (LT 630 – Curriculum and Materials Design)
I chose to showcase the scope and sequence chart that I created for LT 630 because it captures the key elements of the EFL curriculum I designed for this course. The skill areas around which I built the curriculum were informed by the hypothetical needs analysis that I also developed as part of the class. While creating it, I had my former EFL learners in mind and imagined the linguistic and communicative needs they would likely have.
Although the initial stages of conceptualizing the course were far from linear, as I grappled with decisions about what to include and what to omit, the design process gradually took shape and ultimately followed a backward design approach. According to Richards (2013), backward design begins with specifying learning outcomes and using them as the foundation for developing instructional processes and input. What excites me most about this chart is that I was able to map out a meaningful progression of pragmatic skills, which would allow me to intentionally integrate pragmatics into instruction if I were to implement this course in the future. Also, I focused on integrating receptive and productive skills in a communicative way. Something I have always wanted to do as a language teacher is to create a language course that views language as a situated social practice and integrates culture and subjectivity in it in a way that moves away from the notion that language is only about grammar and vocabulary. When learners understand not only what to say but also how to use language appropriately in authentic contexts, the learning experience becomes more meaningful and relevant (Ishihara, 2017). Creating this chart gave me the chance to put this concept into a tangible artifact that integrates instruction on communicative and pragmatic functions of linguistic forms through media-based materials helping compensate for the limited access to authentic contexts in an EFL classroom.
Artifact #2: Lesson plan #2 (LT 536 – Design for Language Learning Systems)
Pairing my practice using inquiry-based learning and what I learned in LT 536 – Design for language learning systems – about student-centered classrooms, I created this lesson plan. At the outset of designing this lesson, I went through a mental visualization process wherein I asked myself one question: “What seems more plausible for me and useful for learners: teaching adult language learners how to write a cover letter, from the lexical items to grammatical structure and organization, or guiding them to find these elements out themselves and let their questions about the process guide their linguistic production?” I ultimately opted for the latter.
I designed this lesson to be an inquiry process that follows the following progression: “Investigation, exploration, search, quest, research, pursuit and study [are] the main activities in inquiry process [as well as the involvement of the learner’s community]” (Kuklthau, Maniotes & Caspri, 2007 as cited in Rejeki, S., 2017, p.137). When it comes to writing instruction, students often look for a road map to guide them through the writing process. This lesson reflects the initial steps of the process approach to writing, while incorporating inquiry, model analysis, and opportunities for students to find their own voices and explore the questions most relevant to them. These elements promote critical thinking and make learning more meaningful, particularly for adult learners whose existing autonomy and agency should be fostered and respected.
Artifact #3: mini lesson plans (LT 539 – Design for learning language pronunciation)
In contexts where learners have limited proficiency, it makes sense for pronunciation to be integrated in a course centered on various language skills wherever it naturally fits. This is why I chose to showcase these mini pronunciation lesson plans: one seizes the opportunity to weave pronunciation instruction into a grammar lesson, while another pairs pronunciation features with common spelling patterns.
Designing this artifact gave me a significant confidence boost in my abilities as a language teacher. I came to realize that pronunciation instruction can be as flexible and versatile as the context, learners' needs, and course affordances allow. All of the lesson plans follow parts of Celce-Murcia et al.'s (2010) communicative framework that consists of 5 stages of pronunciation instruction moving from analysis of the pronunciation feature and listening discrimination to three gradual stages of practice: controlled, guided, and communicative practice. In this framework, learners progress from knowledge and analysis to scaffolded production of the pronunciation feature that facilitates automaticity.
In this artifact, pronunciation instruction is integrated into lessons primarily dedicated to grammar objectives, so I used only the first three stages of the communicative framework proposed by Celce-Murcia et al. (2010). For instance, I was able to set a pronunciation objective within a grammar lesson with a focus on “that” as a relative pronoun VS. “that” as a demonstrative. The goal was to have students realize how word stress can vary depending on its grammatical function. For example, “that” as a demonstrative carries a bigger functional load than “that” as a relative pronoun. Thereby, it’s stressed in the former condition and reduced in the latter. After that, students get the chance to discriminate between “that” in different grammatical cloaks. As they’re exposed to that, their consciousness of the pronunciation-function link is strengthened. Ultimately, this experience shifted my perspective on pronunciation teaching from something intimidating and highly specialized to something that can be naturally and purposefully integrated into language instruction.
Artifact #4: Pragmatics activity (LT 538 – Teaching and Learning Pragmatics)
This activity showcases pragmatics instruction focused on sarcasm in English through the implementation of the IPIC model: a model that combines the four components – knowledge, analysis, awareness and subjectivity. These components come together to assess the interactional, pragmatic and intercultural competence without neglecting the dynamic nature of interaction (Sykes et al., 2020). In designing this activity alongside my colleagues Hekal Musya and Kiunnai Innokenteva, we intentionally targeted objectives that fostered learners' knowledge of linguistic forms, analytical skills, pragmatic awareness, and subjectivity.
Designing an activity around such a broad and nuanced linguistic function as sarcasm was challenging. Goddard and Levisen (2025) discuss how the meaning of the word “sarcasm” has changed in English. The traditional meaning describes sarcasm as aggressive and meant to hurt or criticize someone. A newer meaning describes sarcasm as playful and humorous, often used to entertain rather than attack. So, we made the task flexible enough to allow learners to explore the various function of sarcasm through presenting two sitcom scenes from the show “Modern Family” where sarcasm is used once to build solidarity and another time to criticize in a playful manner, compare, and draw upon their own understanding and experiences with sarcasm in their first languages and cultures. The analysis part is what I am mostly proud of as it allows learners to look deeper at every verbal and non-verbal cue that leads to understanding the sarcastic remark. Learners were presented a table where they were to analyze relationship between interlocutors, context; identify utterances that seemed funny, exaggerated, or simply hard to understand; and analyze any verbal and non-verbal cues that lead to the intended meaning.
The activity would further extend learners' understanding by inviting them to create captions for muted sitcom scenes, requiring them to infer meaning from contextual and non-verbal information alone. This would not only enhance their ability to interpret non-verbal cues but also highlight the importance of recognizing language as a social practice in which communication extends well beyond words themselves.
Celce-Murcia, M., Brinton, D., Goodwin, J. M., & Griner, B. (2010). Teaching pronunciation : a course book and reference guide (Second edition.). Cambridge University Press. http://catdir.loc.gov/catdir/enhancements/fy0914/2009028065-t.html
Goddard, C., & Levisen, C. (2023). Contrastive metapragmatics and the shifting semantics of “sarcasm” in English and Danish. Intercultural Pragmatics. https://doi.org/10.1515/ip-2023-3006
Graves, K. (2000). Designing language courses : a guide for teachers. Heinle & Heinle.
Ishihara, N. (2017). Teaching pragmatics in support of learner subjectivity and global communicative needs: a peace linguistics perspective. Idee in Form@zione, 6(5), 17–32.
Munro, M.J. and Derwing, T.M. (1995), Foreign Accent, comprehensibility, and intelligibility in the speech of second language learners. Language Learning, 45: 73 - 97. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-1770.1995.tb00963.x
Richards, J. C. (2013). Curriculum approaches in language teaching: forward, central, and backwards design. RELC Journal, 44(1), 5-13.
Sykes, J.M., Malone, M.M., Forrest, L., Sağdıç, A. (2020). Affordances of digital simulations to measure communicative success. In: Peters, M., Heraud, R. (eds) Encyclopedia of Educational Innovation. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-13-2262-4_90-2