North Carolina Department of Insurance (NCDOI)

Warning: It is advised to contact your lawyer before doing this.

While the NCVMB handles complaints regarding veterinary professional conduct and medical care, they do not have jurisdiction over insurance disputes.

If your concern involves a Pet Insurance Company or the Vet's Malpractice Insurance: If you believe an insurance provider has unfairly denied a claim, acted in bad faith, or engaged in deceptive practices, you should file a separate complaint with the North Carolina Department of Insurance (NCDOI).

• Agency: NCDOI Consumer Services Division

• Action: File an Online Complaint

• Phone: 855-408-1212

The North Carolina Department of Insurance (NCDOI) absolutely investigates claims of false medical records used for insurance. This falls under the jurisdiction of their Criminal Investigations Division (CID).  In North Carolina, insurance fraud—including the use of falsified medical records—is a felony offense.

Note: The NCVMB regulates the veterinarian; the NCDOI regulates the insurance policy. Filing with one does not automatically notify the other.

More Related Resources & Advocacy

Joey’s Legacy A non-profit organization providing a network of experts and support for families seeking justice after veterinary negligence or malpractice.

StopVetMal.com An advocacy site dedicated to raising awareness about veterinary malpractice and providing tools for owners to hold negligent professionals accountable.

PETA: Veterinary Malpractice and Grooming Accidents An educational guide on your legal rights and the steps you can take if your pet is injured during a medical or grooming procedure.

Vet Abuse Network A resource hub offering specific guidance on how to document evidence and navigate the complex process of filing formal board complaints.

Veterinary Litigation Consultants  Expert analysis service

Legal Assistance & Legislative Advocacy

The North Carolina Bar Association's Lawyer Referral Service

919-677-8574

https://www.ncbar.org/public/find-an-nc-lawyer/

Veterinary malpractice cases in North Carolina are generally heard in NC District or Superior Courts for monetary damages. For damages $25,000 or less, cases are typically heard in District Court (including Small Claims), while claims exceeding  $25,000 fall under Superior Court.  The NC Veterinary Medical Board (NCVMB) handles licensing complaints but not monetary disputes.

Be aware that legal fees can be high.  Some report rates of $250 - $500 per hour.  Some report a required retainer fee of $10,000.  Some report consultaton fees of $300.

An expert witness is typically required. (Exceptions: In rare cases where the error is so obvious that a layperson can understand it without professional help, an expert might not be required, often using the res ipsa loquitur (the thing speaks for itself) doctrine.)

Consider carefully if this fight is worth the time, money, and emotional toll.  

Small Claims Court - For cases under a set dollar amount, often $10,000.  It varies, so look up your county.  Fees to file are typically reasonable.

Key Considerations for Small Claims:

Alternative Evidence: While a live expert is ideal, some small claims courts may accept a detailed letter or affidavit from another veterinarian to prove the breach of care.

The Burden of Proof: You must prove that the vet's act or omission violated professional standards.

Cost vs. Reward: Expert witness fees can exceed $2,000–$5,000, which may be more than the economic value of the pet, as damages are typically limited to the fair market value of the animal, not sentimental value.

When Experts Aren't Needed: In rare situations where the negligence is obvious to a layperson (e.g., operating on the wrong leg), an expert might not be required, but this is risky

ALDF: Find an Attorney A guide to locating legal professionals who specialize in animal law and can assist with pet-related litigation.

ALDF: Steps to Take After Veterinary Harm Actionable advice on how to respond and document evidence if you suspect a veterinarian has committed malpractice.

ALDF: Reporting Injury or Death A comprehensive overview of your legal rights and the steps to take when a pet is injured or killed by a third party.

ALDF: Legal Assistance Request A direct portal to request legal resources or guidance from the ALDF team for specific animal-related legal issues.

Animal Policy Group A specialized resource for those looking to engage in pet industry advocacy and push for legislative changes to animal welfare laws.

Disclaimer: This website contains links to external sites and personal accounts shared by third parties. These stories and opinions are the sole responsibility of the original authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of How to Report the NCVMB: A Resource Guide.

·         No Verification: We have not independently investigated or verified the factual accuracy of these accounts.

·         No Endorsement: Providing a link to a third-party story does not constitute an endorsement or a guarantee of the information provided.

·         Use at Your Own Risk: Readers should exercise their own judgment when reviewing third-party content. We are not liable for any damages or legal consequences arising from the use of or reliance on these external resources.

Legal Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer. This information is for educational purposes only and should not be taken as legal advice. Use of this information does not create an attorney-client relationship.