Roseanna Gives Birth # 4

In the spring of 1881, Roseanna gave birth to a daughter.

The baby lived only a short time.

The loss broke Roseanna’s spirit. She withdrew from the world, her grief compounded by the feud’s growing violence. Her story became a symbol of the feud’s cruelty — a young woman caught between loyalty and love, punished by both.

Roseanna’s tragedy did not end with her child’s death. Later that year, Kentucky authorities attempted to arrest Johnse Hatfield on charges related to moonshining. When they captured him, Roseanna learned of the arrest and made a decision that shocked both families:

She warned the Hatfields.

Despite everything — the betrayal, the humiliation, the heartbreak — Roseanna could not bear to see Johnse imprisoned. Her warning allowed the Hatfields to intervene and rescue him from custody.

The McCoys saw her actions as treason. The Hatfields saw them as proof of her lingering loyalty. Roseanna saw them as the last act of a love she could not fully abandon.

Roseanna’s story did not end with reconciliation or forgiveness. She lived the rest of her life in sorrow, her health declining, her spirit broken. She died young, remembered as one of the feud’s most tragic victims.

Her romance with Johnse did not unite the families. It divided them further. It added bitterness to every interaction, suspicion to every gathering, and anger to every whispered conversation along the Tug Fork.

The feud was no longer just about hogs, trials, or old grudges.

It was about betrayal, heartbreak, and the destruction of innocence.

And the next chapter would bring the feud into its darkest phase — a killing that would ignite the valley and push the families toward open war.  Family stories remind us that  Johnse convinced Roseanna they could build a life together and started slipping off in the woods. The romance was intense and Roseanna was warned that Johnse was a womanizer and no good could come of it.

The romance between Roseanna McCoy and Johnse Hatfield had begun with hope — a rare moment when two young people from opposite sides of the Tug Fork River believed love could overcome bitterness. But by 1881, that hope had collapsed under the weight of betrayal, family pressure, and the growing hostility between the Hatfields and McCoys.

Roseanna returned home heartbroken, disgraced, and pregnant. Her decision to leave the Hatfields and return to her family did not bring comfort. Instead, it placed her at the center of one of the feud’s most tragic and symbolic events — the birth and death of her child, remembered for generations as the Baby of the Feud.

When Roseanna walked back into the McCoy home, she did so alone. Her family did not greet her with sympathy. Randolph McCoy, stern and proud, believed she had betrayed the family by consorting with a Hatfield. Her mother, Sarah, was torn between compassion and the crushing weight of the feud’s expectations.

Roseanna lived in emotional isolation. She had left her family for love, endured humiliation in the Hatfield household, and returned with nothing but heartbreak. The valley whispered about her. Neighbors judged her. Even her own kin kept their distance.

She carried her child quietly, without celebration, without support, and without the hope of reconciliation.

In the spring of 1881, Roseanna gave birth to a daughter. The baby was small, fragile, and sickly from the start. Some accounts say she was born prematurely. Others say she suffered from illness that the isolated mountain community could not treat.

Roseanna cared for her child with fierce devotion. She held her close, sang to her, and tried to shield her from the feud’s bitterness. But the baby’s health declined rapidly. There were no doctors nearby, no medicines, and no resources to save her.

Within weeks, the child died.

The loss shattered Roseanna. She had already endured betrayal, humiliation, and isolation. Now she faced the death of the only innocent thing born from her love with Johnse.

The baby was buried quietly, without ceremony, in a small grave near the McCoy home.

Her death became a symbol of the feud’s cruelty — a life lost before it had a chance to begin.

The Baby of the Feud became more than a personal tragedy. It became a symbol of the feud’s destructive power. In a valley where families fought over hogs, land, pride, and vengeance, the death of an innocent child revealed the human cost of the conflict.

Some residents whispered that the baby’s death was a sign — a warning that the feud would only bring suffering. Others saw it as the final severing of any hope that the Hatfields and McCoys might reconcile.

Roseanna withdrew from the world. Her grief was overwhelming. She rarely spoke. She rarely left home. Her health declined. Her spirit faded.

She had loved a Hatfield. She had lost her child. And she had become a living reminder of the feud’s tragedy.

While Roseanna mourned, Johnse Hatfield moved on with startling ease. He married Nancy McCoy, Roseanna’s cousin, sealing his betrayal and deepening the bitterness between the families.

Nancy’s marriage to Johnse was seen by many as a deliberate insult — a way to humiliate Roseanna and provoke the McCoys. Whether intentional or not, the marriage added fuel to the feud’s growing fire.

Roseanna watched from a distance, her heartbreak compounded by the knowledge that Johnse had replaced her without hesitation.

Later that year, Kentucky authorities attempted to arrest Johnse Hatfield on charges related to moonshining. When they captured him, Roseanna learned of the arrest and made a decision that stunned both families:

She warned the Hatfields.

Despite everything — the betrayal, the humiliation, the death of her child — Roseanna could not bear to see Johnse imprisoned. Her warning allowed the Hatfields to rescue him from custody.

The McCoys saw her actions as treason. The Hatfields saw them as proof of her lingering loyalty. Roseanna saw them as the last act of a love she could not fully abandon.

Her decision widened the divide between the families and set the stage for the violence that would soon engulf the valley.

Roseanna’s story did not end with healing or reconciliation. She lived the rest of her life in sorrow, her health failing, her spirit broken. She died young, remembered as one of the feud’s most tragic victims.

Her child — the Baby of the Feud — became a symbol of innocence lost, a reminder that the feud’s victims were not only the men who carried rifles, but the women and children caught in the crossfire of pride, vengeance, and betrayal.

The valley would not forget Roseanna. And it would not forget her child.

The feud was no longer a series of disputes. It was a tragedy unfolding in real time.

And the next chapter would push the families toward open war — a killing that would ignite the valley and lead directly to the bloodshed of 1887.

By the mid‑1880s, the Hatfield–McCoy feud had evolved from a series of disputes into a simmering conflict marked by bitterness, betrayal, and bloodshed. The Hog Trial had divided the families. The killing of Bill Staton had added violence. The Roseanna–Johnse tragedy had deepened emotional wounds. And the riverbank execution of the McCoy brothers had pushed the feud into a new, darker phase.

But the valley had not yet seen the kind of organized violence that would define the feud’s most infamous years.

That moment arrived in 1887, when a group of Hatfields ambushed a McCoy relative in a killing that shocked the Tug Valley and set the stage for the catastrophic events of New Year’s Night.