Sam and Paris Mccoy Arrested # 3

Sam and Paris McCoy were arrested and put on trial. But unlike the Hog Trial, this case ended differently. The court ruled the killing was in self-defense, and the McCoy brothers were acquitted.

The Hatfields saw the verdict as a miscarriage of justice. The McCoys saw it as vindication.

The valley saw it as a sign that the feud was no longer simmering — it was beginning to boil.

By the early 1880s, the Hatfields and McCoys were no longer simply neighbors with old grudges. They were two powerful families locked in a growing conflict. The Hog Trial had drawn the first clear line between them. The killing of Bill Staton had drawn the second.

The feud was not yet at full force, but the path was set.

The next spark would come from a place no one expected — a romance between two young people from opposite sides of the river.

By the early 1880s, the Tug Valley was a place where old grudges mixed with new pressures. The Hog Trial had deepened the divide between the Hatfields and McCoys. The killing of Bill Staton had added blood to the bitterness. Suspicion lingered in every hollow, every gathering, every whispered conversation along the river.

But the feud had not yet exploded.

That moment came on August 7, 1882, at an election ground near the Kentucky–West Virginia border — a place where families gathered to vote, trade goods, drink whiskey, and socialize. Election days in the mountains were not quiet affairs. They were rowdy, crowded, and often fueled by alcohol. Arguments were common. Fights were expected.

But no one expected the violence that erupted between the Hatfields and McCoys that day — violence that would claim lives, deepen hatred, and set the feud on a path toward tragedy.

Election grounds were social centers in the mountains. Men arrived early, often on horseback, carrying rifles or pistols as casually as pocketknives. Women brought children. Vendors sold food and drink. Music played. Whiskey flowed freely.

On this particular day, members of both families were present. The Hatfields arrived in force, including Ellison Hatfield — Devil Anse’s brother. The McCoys were there as well, including three of Randolph’s sons: Tolbert, Pharmer, and Bud.

The atmosphere was tense but not yet hostile. The families had crossed paths before without violence. But the valley’s simmering resentment hung in the air like humidity.

All it needed was a spark.

The spark came when Tolbert McCoy confronted Ellison Hatfield. Accounts differ on what started the argument. Some say Ellison insulted Tolbert. Others say Tolbert accused Ellison of cheating him in a business deal. Still others claim the dispute began over politics.

Whatever the cause, the argument escalated quickly. Voices rose. Insults flew. Whiskey fueled tempers.

Then the first blow was struck.

Tolbert hit Ellison. Ellison fought back. Pharmer and Bud McCoy joined the fray. The fight turned violent, chaotic, and bloody. Knives flashed. Fists flew. The crowd scattered.

When the fight ended, Ellison Hatfield lay on the ground, stabbed twenty-six times and shot once.

He was still alive — barely — but mortally wounded.

The McCoy brothers were immediately seized by Hatfield supporters. The election grounds erupted in panic. Word spread like wildfire: The McCoys have killed Ellison Hatfield.

The feud had crossed a line.

When news reached Devil Anse Hatfield, he reacted with fury. Ellison was his brother — loyal, respected, and beloved. Devil Anse gathered a group of armed men and rode hard to capture the McCoy brothers.

He found them already in custody, held by local officials who intended to transport them to Pikeville for trial. But Devil Anse refused to let the law handle the matter. He believed the McCoys had committed murder, and he intended to deliver justice himself.

The Hatfields seized the prisoners, overpowering the guards. They took Tolbert, Pharmer, and Bud McCoy into West Virginia, holding them under guard while Ellison fought for his life.

For two days, the McCoy brothers waited — knowing their fate depended on whether Ellison lived or died.

Ellison Hatfield lingered for nearly forty-eight hours. His wounds were too severe. Despite the efforts of family and neighbors, he died on August 9, 1882.

When Devil Anse received the news, he made his decision.

The McCoy brothers would die.

Devil Anse ordered his men to take the McCoy brothers to the banks of the Tug Fork River. The place was symbolic — the river that divided the families would now witness the feud’s first major act of vengeance.

The brothers were tied to pawpaw bushes along the riverbank. They begged for mercy. They pleaded for their lives. But Devil Anse believed he was delivering justice for his murdered brother.

The Hatfields opened fire.

Tolbert, Pharmer, and Bud McCoy were executed by firing squad. Their bodies fell into the mud along the river’s edge.

The killings shocked the Tug Valley. Some residents believed the McCoys had deserved punishment for Ellison’s death. Others believed Devil Anse had crossed a moral line. But everyone agreed on one thing:

The feud had become deadly.

The Election Day Fight and the riverbank execution marked a turning point. The Hatfields believed they had avenged Ellison’s murder. The McCoys believed their sons had been murdered in cold blood.

The valley took sides. Families whispered. Neighbors argued. Tension thickened like fog along the river.

The feud was no longer a simmering conflict. It was a war.

And the next chapter would bring the feud into its most tragic and heartbreaking phase — a romance between two young people from opposite sides of the river.

A romance that could have united the families.

Before the Hatfields and McCoys became locked in a cycle of bloodshed, there was a moment — brief, fragile, and full of possibility — when the feud might have ended before it truly began. That moment came through a romance between two young people from opposite sides of the Tug Fork River: Roseanna McCoy and Johnse Hatfield.

Their story has been told for more than a century, often romanticized, sometimes exaggerated, but always remembered as the feud’s most heartbreaking chapter. It was a love that could have united the families. Instead, it deepened the divide and set the stage for tragedy.

In the fall of 1880, the Hatfields and McCoys gathered at an election day celebration in Pike County, Kentucky. Election days were social events — filled with music, food, whiskey, and crowds from both sides of the river. Despite the simmering tension between the families, gatherings like these were common.

It was here that Roseanna McCoy, the beautiful, soft‑spoken daughter of Randolph McCoy, met Johnse Hatfield, the charismatic, handsome son of Devil Anse. Johnse was known for his charm. Roseanna was known for her kindness. Their attraction was immediate.

They talked. They laughed. They walked together along the edge of the crowd. And by the end of the day, they were inseparable.

For a moment, the feud seemed far away.

Roseanna and Johnse’s relationship grew quickly. They met in secret along the Tug Fork, away from the eyes of their families. Roseanna crossed into West Virginia to visit Johnse. He crossed into Kentucky to see her. Their romance was innocent, hopeful, and full of the promise of a future neither family could imagine.

But the valley was not a place where secrets stayed hidden.

When the McCoys learned of the relationship, they were furious. Randolph McCoy believed his daughter had betrayed the family by consorting with a Hatfield. The Hatfields, meanwhile, were suspicious of Roseanna’s intentions and worried she might be used to gather information.

The young couple found themselves caught between two powerful families, each demanding loyalty and obedience.

The pressure became unbearable. Roseanna, torn between her family and her love for Johnse, made a bold and heartbreaking decision: she left her home and moved into the Hatfield household.

It was an act of courage — and desperation.

Devil Anse allowed her to stay, but the Hatfield women did not welcome her. They saw her as an outsider, a McCoy, and a potential threat. Roseanna endured isolation, suspicion, and constant scrutiny. She had left her family for love, but found herself alone in a house full of strangers.

Still, she stayed. She believed in Johnse. She believed their love could overcome the feud.

But Johnse’s loyalty was not as strong as hers.

In early 1881, Johnse traveled to Pikeville for supplies. While there, he met Nancy McCoy, Roseanna’s cousin. Nancy was lively, flirtatious, and eager for attention. Johnse, easily swayed and notoriously fickle, began courting her almost immediately.

Roseanna learned of the betrayal through whispers and gossip. Her heartbreak was devastating. She had left her family, endured humiliation, and risked her safety — only to be abandoned by the man she loved.

Johnse soon married Nancy, sealing the betrayal.

Roseanna returned home, pregnant and disgraced.

Roseanna’s return to the McCoy home was not met with sympathy. Her family saw her as a traitor who had brought shame upon them. She lived in emotional isolation, carrying the weight of her choices and the pain of Johnse’s betrayal.