House Burned

The Attack Details    Improvisation

• Event Date: January 1, 1888, just before dawn.

• Location: Blackberry Creek (Pond Creek/Hardy area) in Pike County, Kentucky.

• Perpetrators: Roughly 12 to 13 Hatfield family members and allies led by Jim Vance (uncle to Devil Anse Hatfield) and Cap Hatfield.

• Casualties: Children Alifair McCoy and Calvin McCoy were shot and killed; matriarch Sarah McCoy was brutally bludgeoned and left for dead.

• Outcome for Patriarch: Randolph McCoy escaped into the snowy woods, but his home was completely reduced to ashes

By the late 1880s, newspaper readers across much of the United States were encountering reports about the Hatfields and McCoys. The feud between these two Appalachian families wasn't just regional news. It traveled through wire services and reprints into papers hundreds of miles from the Tug Fork River valley, the kind of story editors kept feeding to readers who couldn't seem to get enough of it.

That reach is what makes the feud such a useful entry point for thinking about historical newspapers and family history research. The families became nationally famous because editors turned a regional conflict into a dramatic and often sensational story for readers far beyond Appalachia. But in the newspapers of the era, the Hatfields and McCoys also appeared the way your ancestors did: in local columns, in community notices, in brief items that had nothing to do with violence at all.

If you want to understand how your ancestors lived, what they read, and what shaped their world, old newspapers are one of the most direct paths you have. The Hatfield-McCoy feud is a useful illustration of why.

Historical newspapers covered the Hatfield-McCoy feud from the early 1880s through the early 1890s, with the most intense coverage following the New Year's Night Massacre of January 1, 1888. Papers from local Kentucky and West Virginia titles to regional papers in Ohio ran the story. Searching newspapers from this era can help family historians understand the historical context their ancestors lived through and find their own family members mentioned in local community coverage.

The Feud and the Newspapers That Covered It

The Hatfield and McCoy families lived on opposite sides of the Tug Fork River, which forms the border between Pike County, Kentucky, and what was then Logan County, West Virginia. The Hatfields, led by William Anderson "Devil Anse" Hatfield, were a prosperous timber family on the West Virginia side. The McCoys, led by Randolph "Old Ranel" McCoy, farmed on the Kentucky side.

Later accounts often trace some of the bitterness to the Civil War era. Many members of both families supported the Confederacy, while Randolph McCoy's brother, Asa Harmon McCoy, served in the Union Army and was killed shortly after returning home. Historians, however, caution that no single event or dispute fully explains the violence that followed. The West Virginia Encyclopedia notes that various explanations have been offered, including differences originating in the Civil War and strains caused by the rapid industrialization of the region, but that none adequately explains the depth of bitterness between the neighbors on the Tug Fork.

Violence flared in 1882 when three of Randolph McCoy's sons fatally stabbed Ellison Hatfield, Devil Anse's brother, during an election day celebration. The Hatfields took the McCoy brothers by force, held them in West Virginia, and when Ellison died of his wounds, tied them to pawpaw bushes and shot all three dead. Their deaths became one of the feud's defining episodes and deepened the cycle of threats, arrests, revenge, and violence that followed.

The violence escalated dramatically on New Year's Night, 1888, when a group of Hatfield men crossed into Kentucky, surrounded the McCoy family cabin, set it on fire, and killed two of Randolph's children: Alifair and Calvin. The newspaper of the time reported that Sarah McCoy had been struck or shot in the head and left unconscious. Later historical accounts generally describe her as having been severely beaten during the attack. Randolph escaped into the woods in his nightclothes while, according to the contemporary report, at least fifty shots were fired around him.

That raid triggered a major wave of national coverage. Newspapers continued to revisit the feud as posses pursued suspects, courts considered the interstate arrests, defendants went to trial, and coverage continued through the February 18, 1890, execution of Ellison "Cottontop" Mounts, the only person legally executed for a feud-related crime.

What the Local Papers Were Saying

The Big Sandy News in Louisa, Kentucky, was one of the papers closest to the action. Louisa sits at the junction of the Big Sandy and Levisa Fork rivers, about 40 miles from the heart of Hatfield-McCoy territory. When the January 1888 raid happened, the paper reported it in plain, specific language.

The January 5, 1888, edition of the Big Sandy News, published just four days after the raid, ran a piece headlined "The Hatfields Again." It relayed a letter from J. Lee Ferguson, the Pike County Attorney, describing the attack in detail: the cabin set on fire, Alifair shot dead at the door, Calvin killed as he tried to escape. A $500 reward had been posted for three Hatfields for earlier murders. The paper noted the raid appeared to be an attempt to finish what had started years before.

What's striking about reading this clipping today isn't just the violence. It's the geography. Ferguson wrote from Pikeville. The letter went to a judge. The Big Sandy News published it four days after the attack. That's how information moved in 1888: through letters and local editors, and then outward into papers that reprinted and relayed the reports.

A reader in a nearby Kentucky county may have encountered this same account within days of the raid.