Introduction to Tuckman's Model:
Every stage of team development has recognizable features and characteristics. Trying to understanding why things are happening in certain ways can be a critical and important part of a self-evaluation process. Tuckman's five stages are useful guidelines to recognize what a team is going through. Team development is not always a linear process but having a way to identify and understand causes for changes in the team behaviors can help the team improve its process and productivity. Identifying changes can also assist in getting to know another person in a different way.
In the beginning of a project, when a new team forms, individuals will be unsure of the team's purpose, how they fit in, and whether they'll work well with one another. They may be anxious, curious, or excited to get going. During the forming stage people are introducing themselves and trying to get to know each other. People tend to be on their best behavior and also tend to be more polite than normal. People will tend to be apprehensive and timid.
In the storming stage, people start to push back against each other. Conflict and friction can form between team members as their true intensions surface and work ethics may clash with other members of the team. During this stage people most likely will go through an adjustment phase. Some people can become confrontational and argumentative. People can be vying for a position or will tend to be independent and start working on their own.
Now that they know one another better, your team members will feel more comfortable asking for help and offering constructive feedback. They'll form a commitment to the team's goals, and they should make good progress toward it. During this stage, conflict can be resolved with and handled and a sense of cooperation starts to begin. The team begins to share a common goals and start taking on more responsibilities. A fine line can form between speaking up or staying silent to keep the peace.
This is the stage where people start to work together and troubleshoot, brainstorm, and start to collaborate. Decision making skills are shared to complete a task and all member's are utilizing and identifying everyone's individual strengths to accomplish one goal. During this stage the team are motivated and knowledgeable. They have acquired relevant competency to complete tasked and are able to conduct decision making processes with little to no supervision.
The job is done, some relationships formed can and will continue. During this stage the team has completed the goals and tasks. They are separating from the group to start on a new team with new tasks. The team will break up at this stage. Feeling of loss and sadness can start to weigh on the teams minds.
Please watch this informative video.
Introduction to Piaget's Four Stages of Cognitive Development:
Piaget believed that children take an active role in the learning process, acting much like little scientists as they perform experiments, make observations, and learn about the world. As kids interact with the world around them, they continually add new knowledge, build upon existing knowledge, and adapt previously held ideas to accommodate new information.
During the sensorimotor stage, children go through a period of dramatic growth and learning. As kids interact with their environment, they continually make new discoveries about how the world works. an infant is observing the new world around them and is testing different reflexes and movements during their first developmental stage.
Tuckman Forming Stage Comparison:
Just like in the forming stage of Tuckman's model, people are polite and or nervous, trying to get to know the group and are learning about others. If I say one thing, this person reacts this way or this person is nice and this person is mean. Judgements can start to form.
Sensorimotor Stage
At this stage, kids are still learning but can struggle with logic and taking the point of view of other people. They also often struggle with understanding the idea of constancy. During this stage, children have difficulties thinking about more than one thing or situation at one time. Egocentrism refers to the child's inability to see a situation from another person's point of view. The egocentric child assumes that other people see, hear, and feel exactly the same as the child does.
Tuckman Storming Stage Comparison:
Just like in the storming stage, people seem to struggle seeing eye to eye and will assume they know better than others making it difficult for them to see a situation from another persons point of view.
Preoperational Stage
During this stage, children also become less egocentric and begin to think about how other people might think and feel. Kids in the concrete operational stage also begin to understand that their thoughts are unique to them and that not everyone else necessarily shares their thoughts, feelings, and opinions. Rational thinking and organized thoughts begin to develop. This can be a huge turning point in the child's cognitive development. Children can now mature enough to use logical thought or operations
Tuckman Normalizing Stage Comparison:
Teams can start tolerating the whims and fancies of the other team members. They accept others as they are and make an effort to move on. The danger here is that members may be so focused on preventing conflict that they are reluctant to share controversial ideas.
Concrete Operational Stage
The final stage of Piaget's theory involves an increase in logic, the ability to use deductive reasoning, and an understanding of abstract ideas. At this point, adolescents and young adults become capable of seeing multiple potential solutions to problems and think more scientifically about the world around them. Children can start manipulating ideas in their head. The child can approach problems in a systematic and organized manner, rather than through trial-and-error.
Tuckman Performing Stage Comparison:
By this time, the team can be motivated and knowledgeable. The team members are now competent, autonomous and able to handle the decision-making process without supervision. Dissent is expected and allowed as long as it is channelled through means acceptable to the team.
Formal Operational Stage
Similarities of Tuckman and Piaget Stage Theories:
Just like Piaget stages, Tuckman's stages have potential to not progress into the next stage. Some groups will never transition out of the storming stage just as some children never reach the formal operational stage. We all can and do act like children when we don't understand something or don't want to admit we did something wrong. I think when we have new experiences and meet new people we seem to revert back to having to learn how to behave all over again. Even though both these theories differ from each other, it seems that they follow the same framework and can both be used to help us understand each other and open ourselves up to always be learning from each other.
Please watch another informative video.
Please try out the quiz below to test your knowledge of Tuckman's model by matching the behavior's to the correct Tuckman stage.
Works Cited:
Home. MindTools. (n.d.). Retrieved December 7, 2022, from https://www.mindtools.com/pages/article/newLDR_86.htm#:~:text=Psychologist%20Bruce%20Tuckman%20described%20how,your%20team%20to%20perform%20better.
CROGERS@wcupa.edu. (n.d.). Collaborative on-line research and learning. Tuckman's Stages of Group Development - WCU of PA. Retrieved December 7, 2022, from https://www.wcupa.edu/coral/tuckmanStagesGroupDelvelopment.aspx#:~:text=Tuckman's%20model%20explains%20that%20as,conscious%20of%20it%20or%20not.
Cherry, K. (2022, May 2). What is Piaget's theory of cognitive development? Verywell Mind. Retrieved December 7, 2022, from https://www.verywellmind.com/piagets-stages-of-cognitive-development-2795457