Facilitating Discussion
Safe Space
Get to know students
Avoid public correction of errors
Allow students to seek clarification in English/Chinese
Provide frequent opportunities for peer interaction
Let students speak when they are ready
Silence
What is going on during silence?
Students are thinking
Students don't understand
Students are shy
Students are don't feel like talking
What can we do?
Give time for students to respond
Rephrase what we asked or said
Share own opinion or experience
admit difficulty and ask another question
Simple to Complex Questioning
Start with simple questions, so students can build ideas and context.
This line of questioning can lead to students understanding their topic more and more critical thinking.
EX:
What is your favorite food?
How often do you eat your favorite food?
Would you eat your favorite food everyday?
Would you replace all the food you eat with your favorite food?
If you replaced all your meals with your favorite food, what would happen to your body?
Does your favorite food have enough nutrition for a healthy diet? Why?
Start with simple questions related to students
Then ask slightly more challenging questions
Ask a little more challenging question students can discuss in groups
Reflection
This can be as simple as reviewing or asking student what was talked about.
Take a few notes on what students talked about and verbally review what was talked about.
Write what students say on the white board, or type words on a projected document. Review the document at the end of the class.
Ask the students what was talked about or what kinds of questions were asked.
Have students share their answers to the whole class.
Phrases to Elicit Opinions
Questions
Do you think/believe that...?
Do you have an opinion on … ?
Do you have any opinions on/about … ?
In your experience, … ?
What’s your view on … ?
What do you think about...?
Responses
I think/believe that ...
From what I understand ...
As I understand it ...
What I mean is …
In my opinion / My opinion/understanding is …
Clarification Phrases
Questions
What do you mean by …?
Do you mean...?
Could you say that again / repeat, please?
If I understand you correctly, you mean... [ ]. Correct?
Could you give an example?
Could you be more specific, please?
Responses
Let me rephrase that...
Let me explain that in more detail...
Let me put it in another way...
If I could rephrase that...
In other words...
To say this differently...
Agreement and Disagreement
Agreeing
I agree (with)...
I hold the same view.
I support that.
I couldn't agree more / I strongly agree.
That's true / right / correct.
That's a good idea.
Disagreeing
I don't think so.
I'm afraid I disagree.
I'm not sure I agree.
I beg to differ.
I see things differently.
Not necessarily.
(I don't think) That's not always true.
(I believe) That's not always the case.
I'm not so sure about that.
Other Useful Phrases
Signposting
Today, we're going to discuss/talk about...
Our first/second/next/last question is about...
This question is a little bit more difficult/ easier.
To summarize...
Directing the Conversation
Does anyone else have an opinion on this?
And what about you?
We haven't heard from you yet. Do you have an opinion?