Debates lesson
Watch the video about Telemedicine. Take notes on the key aspects discussed in the video, including benefits, technologies used, and case studies.
Investigate and find at least three examples of telemedicine services currently available in our city. This can include hospitals, clinics, or telehealth platforms that offer remote consultations. Provide a brief description of each example and any relevant contact information.
Be prepared to share your findings and reflections in debates. You will have a few minutes to present your local examples of telemedicine and your thoughts on its benefits and challenges. Prepare some information on the following topics:
What are the key advantages and disadvantages of telemedicine?
What statistics or empirical evidence support your side of the argument?
Think of potential counterarguments for the other side, and prepare responses that address misconceptions or highlight the strengths of your position.
Split into two groups: Group A and Group B.
Discuss: Group A will focus on the advantages of telemedicine, while Group B will focus on the disadvantages.
Research: Use your notes and any additional resources you have to gather key statistics, examples, and potential real-life implications to support your argument.
Prepare your presentation: Organize your points logically and decide who will present each part during the debate.
You can get 5 points for your prepared presentation
Present your arguments: Each group will present their points for a total of 7 minutes. Group A will present first, followed by Group B.
Be clear and concise: Ensure that each member contributes to the presentation and that arguments are supported by empirical evidence (key statistics or examples that support your position, potential real-life implications of telemedicine based on your perspective).
Be careful: for language mistakes you lose points.
Conduct the rebuttal: Each group will have 5 minutes to respond to the opposing team's points. Focus on counterarguments and addressing any misconceptions. For each counterargument you get 1 point (maximum 5 points).
Open the floor for questions: After the rebuttal, invite your groupmates to ask questions about both sides of the debate. For each question you get 1 point (maximum 5 points).
Engage respectfully: Listen carefully to questions and provide thoughtful responses.
Reading
Look through the text. Find the synonyms of the following words in the text:
Widespread infection
Increase
Resistance
Precaution
Care
Antidote
An outbreak of the virus in northern China has prompted some online alarm but experts say the risk of another Covid-like pandemic is low
Human metapneumovirus (HMPV) is a respiratory disease that causes flu or cold-like symptoms, but can increase risks or lead to more serious complications like bronchitis or pneumonia, particularly among the elderly, young children, and immunocompromised people.
The disease is in the same family as respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), and has been around since at least 2001 when it was first identified in the Netherlands. Its outbreaks are concentrated during colder seasons.
Cases have been surging in northern China, particularly among children, according to local authorities. The country’s centre for disease control (CDC) has warned people to take precautions with health and hygiene, but has also pushed back against online claims of overwhelmed hospitals and fears of another Covid-like pandemic.
“Respiratory infections tend to peak during the winter season,” Chinese foreign ministry spokesperson Mao Ning said on Friday.
“The diseases appear to be less severe and spread with a smaller scale compared to the previous year.”
The apparent increase in cases is likely partly due to new technology more easily detecting and identifying HMPV, experts told the Guardian.
Also, “I think we’re just more cautious of outbreaks now”, said Dr Jacqueline Stephens, a senior lecturer in public health at Flinders University in Australia. “Everyone is hypervigilant, and you hear this term human metapneumovirus and it sounds kind of scary.”
The symptoms of HMPV are similar to a cold or flu, and it is one of several viruses often lumped under a broad definition of the “common cold”, said Stephens. It is not a notifiable disease like Covid-19 or influenza.
“There’s a range of others … that are not notifiable because they are very common and lots of people get them. They make us feel terrible for a few days but if we rest and recuperate for a few days then we get better,” said Stephens.
HMPV can lead to more serious illnesses like bronchitis and pneumonia among elderly people, very young children, and people who are immunocompromised.
“It certainly can and does cause severe disease, that’s why I think it’s important that people know it’s out there,” said said Prof Paul Griffin, director of infectious diseases at Mater Health Services in Brisbane.
“The challenge is at the moment there’s not much we can do except educate people [that] it’s around to reduce transmission. There’s no vaccine or antivirals, although there are some vaccines in development,” said Griffin.
HMPV is not like Covid-19, in that it has been around for several decades and there is a level of immunity in the global population from past infections, the experts said. Covid-19 was a new disease which had never infected humans before, driving the pandemic-level spread.
“I don’t think we’re necessarily concerned about a pandemic with this virus, but the surge in cases and impact it’s having are significant,” said Griffin. “A good lesson can be taken [from the pandemic] to reduce the spread, particularly given we don’t have vaccines or antivirals for HMPV.”
“For a number of years [during Covid] we were good at precautions for reducing the numbers, now we are doing less, and we’re seeing a rebound,” said Griffin.
“I’m certainly not suggesting we go back to the harsh restrictions of Covid, but staying home, practising good cough and sneeze etiquette, and hand hygiene are so important during the winter season.”
Both experts also urged people not to go to work while sick, and Stephens suggested wearing a mask if you do have to go into the community, to prevent further infecting others, especially those at higher risk.
Reading
Read the text one more time. Match the headlines with the correct paragraphs.
A. What should we do about it?
B. How serious is HMPV and what are the symptoms?
C. Why is HMPV in the news?
D. Who is most at risk from human metapneumovirus?
E. How worried should we be about the virus?
Compare Human Metapneumovirus (HMPV) and COVID-19. Fill in the table and tell others their similarities and differences. You can use any additional resources to look for information.