How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Elnwnnkc Silicone Air Fryers — biggest strength: food-grade silicone rated up to 230°C with a metal-reinforced frame, nonslip corners and a central grip, plus a fit tailored to AF451, AF400 and DZ401 baskets.
• Elnwnnkc Silicone Air Fryers — biggest trade-off: the fit list is narrow, so if your air fryer isn't one of those models, this guard may not seat properly.
• HEALLILY Stainless Steel Splatter — biggest strength: a stainless-steel mesh design marketed as universally compatible, so it can move with you between air fryer models and is easy to clean.
• HEALLILY Stainless Steel Splatter — biggest trade-off: there's no listed temperature rating or model-specific fit, and a rigid round screen won't grip a basket the way a fitted silicone guard does.
• Who each pick is for: Elnwnnkc for owners of the listed models who want a fitted, hand-liftable cover; HEALLILY for anyone who wants a flexible, brand-agnostic mesh screen.
Elnwnnkc's splatter guard is the more tailored of the two. It's built from food-grade silicone rated to 230°C, wrapped around a metal-reinforced frame that the brand claims delivers 40% higher heat resistance than alternatives — a claim worth weighing as a manufacturer statement rather than a lab result, but the design intent is clear: a cover that holds its shape under high-temperature air frying without warping. The reinforced nonslip corners and central grip tell you this is meant to be handled. You lift it off by the middle, not by poking at the edges with a utensil.
So who should buy it? If you own one of those three models and you're tired of wiping down the counter after every batch of fries, this is the cleaner match. It's also the better pick if you want something you can grab and rinse by hand rather than juggle. Who should skip it? If your air fryer isn't on that list, don't force it — a fitted guard that doesn't fit defeats the purpose. And if you're the type who wants one accessory to follow you across future air fryer upgrades, the model-specific fit works against you here.
HEALLILY Stainless Steel Splatter: Who It's For
HEALLILY takes the opposite approach: instead of fitting one basket, it tries to fit all of them. The guard is a stainless-steel mesh screen, listed at roughly 8.86 x 8.86 x 0.12 inches and weighing about 3.52 ounces. The brand leans hard on universal compatibility, describing it as a replacement shield that works across various air fryer models. If you've replaced an air fryer before, or you own more than one, that flexibility is genuinely useful.
The mesh is doing double duty. First, it lets heat through evenly, so food cooks thoroughly rather than sitting under a solid lid. Second, it catches oil as it splashes, which keeps the interior of the fryer and your countertop tidier. HEALLILY also frames it around a healthier kitchen — reducing oil fumes in the air while you cook. That's a reasonable benefit of any splatter screen, and it's the kind of thing that matters if you fry or roast often in a small kitchen without great ventilation.
Stainless steel is the practical story here. It's a material people associate with durability, it doesn't absorb odors the way some soft materials can, and it's straightforward to rinse. The trade-off is that the sheet lists no temperature rating, so there's no stated ceiling to compare against Elnwnnkc's 230°C figure. And a flat, rigid round screen doesn't grip a basket. It sits on top rather than locking into place, which means it's more of a cover than a fitted component.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for a confirmed, model-specific fit → Elnwnnkc Silicone Air Fryers (listed for AF451, AF400 and DZ401).
• Best for universal compatibility → HEALLILY Stainless Steel Splatter, which is designed to fit various air fryer models.
• Best for high-heat reassurance → Elnwnnkc Silicone Air Fryers, with food-grade silicone rated up to 230°C.
• Best for durability material → HEALLILY Stainless Steel Splatter, built from stainless steel.
• Best for easy handling → Elnwnnkc Silicone Air Fryers, thanks to the central grip and nonslip corners.
• Best for even heat distribution → HEALLILY Stainless Steel Splatter, whose mesh design is meant to let heat pass through.
• Best for reducing oil fumes → HEALLILY Stainless Steel Splatter, which is explicitly framed around a healthier cooking environment.
• Best for airflow while frying → Elnwnnkc Silicone Air Fryers, which states it maintains airflow while blocking splatter.
In my opinion, the right call comes down to one question: do you know your air fryer model? If you own an AF451, AF400 or DZ401, I'd buy the Elnwnnkc Silicone Air Fryers guard. The fitted size, the 230°C silicone, the nonslip corners and the central grip add up to a cover that behaves like a real component of your fryer rather than an accessory resting on top. If your model isn't on that list — or you want one screen that travels with you across air fryers — I'd go with the HEALLILY Stainless Steel Splatter instead. It trades a tailored fit for flexibility and stainless-steel practicality. For me, the fitted option wins when it fits; the universal option wins when it doesn't.
FAQ
The sheet lists food-grade silicone rated up to 230°C, and the brand says the metal-reinforced frame adds 40% more heat resistance than alternatives. That's a manufacturer claim, but the stated silicone ceiling gives you a concrete number to work with.
HEALLILY markets it as universally compatible with various air fryer models, so it's the safer bet if you don't know your exact model or you switch fryers. Just note there's no model list and no stated temperature rating, so you're relying on the brand's compatibility claim.
Both are designed for easy cleaning. The Elnwnnkc guard is silicone with a central grip you can lift by hand; the HEALLILY screen is stainless steel mesh, which rinses well and won't absorb food odors. Neither is hard to deal with.
The sheets here don't cover pricing, so check the current price on Amazon before deciding — the button on this page takes you there. Weigh that against fit: if your air fryer is on Elnwnnkc's list, the tailored fit is usually worth prioritizing; if it isn't, HEALLILY's universal design is the more flexible buy.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GWYXC Air Fryer Accessories vs BBQ-PLUS Stainless Steel Splatter, Cosori Iconic Stainless Steel vs HOMLOVE 18QT: Best Air, HEIPON Perforated Silicone Baking vs Yomvzake Air Fryer Jumbo