How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• GWYXC's biggest strength: one large 13.5" × 12.3" × 1.6" rectangular food-grade steel basket with a mesh design that circulates heat 360° around the food, so you don't have to flip halfway through.
• GWYXC's biggest trade-off: it is a size-specific part. If your oven cavity isn't big enough for a 13.5-inch basket, it simply won't fit, and you have to measure before ordering.
• BBQ-PLUS's biggest strength: a purpose-built 7.6" × 7.6" fine-mesh shield, sold as a 2-pack, made to catch splatter and keep the heater of a Ninja Foodi Smart XL grill clean and smoke-free.
• BBQ-PLUS's biggest trade-off: it does one narrow job. It protects the heating element; it doesn't add cooking surface, and it only fits the grill models listed.
• Who GWYXC is for: anyone who owns a Ninja Foodi 13-in-1 SP351/SP301/SP201 countertop oven and wants a bigger, healthier cooking surface.
• Who BBQ-PLUS is for: anyone who owns a Ninja Foodi Smart XL FG551/FG550/BG500A/DG551 grill and is tired of scrubbing grease off the heater.
Think of GWYXC as an upgrade to the cooking surface you already have. It's a rectangular replacement basket and wire rack sized at 13.5" × 12.3" × 1.6", built from food-grade steel that's BPA-free, non-toxic and tasteless, and stated to meet FDA standards. The mesh floor is the interesting part: instead of a solid tray, the open weave lets hot air move around the food from every direction, which is why the manufacturer says you get even browning without flipping. In practice that means you set your temperature and time, walk away, and come back to food that's cooked through on both sides.
The shape matters as much as the material. A rectangle this wide fits more chicken wings, bacon strips, meatballs, fish fillets, potato wedges or vegetables in a single layer than a small round basket does, and a single layer is exactly what you want for crisping. It also works as a general oven and baking rack for cookies and cakes, and you can use it as a plain grill basket for fruit, vegetables or even holding tableware and cups at a party. Cleanup is dishwasher-safe, and the brand notes that a quick soak loosens stuck-on food. One caution they repeat more than once: don't scrub it with abrasive cloths or metal balls, because that will wear the non-stick surface.
So who should buy it? If you own a Ninja Foodi 13-in-1 SP351, SP301 or SP201 countertop toaster oven and you want to cook larger portions with less oil, this is a straightforward fit. If you're buying it as a gift for someone with that oven, or you want one accessory that can air-fry, grill and bake, it covers a lot of ground. Who should skip it? Anyone who hasn't measured their oven interior. The listed maximum is 13.5 inches long, and the brand explicitly asks you to check the inside diameter of your appliance first. If you own a different brand or a smaller air fryer, don't assume this drops in.
The BBQ-PLUS shield is a different kind of accessory entirely. It isn't a cooking surface; it's protection. Each screen measures 7.6" × 7.6" and is made from food-grade stainless steel chosen for strength and rust resistance. The fine mesh is the whole point: it sits over the heating element of a Ninja Foodi indoor grill and catches the grease and fat that would otherwise splatter upward. The brand's stated benefits are that it keeps the heater clean, prevents smoking, protects the heating element so it lasts longer, and makes cooking safer overall.
If you've ever grilled fatty foods indoors, you know the failure mode: grease hits a hot element, the kitchen fills with smoke, and you're left scraping a baked-on layer off the heater. A shield addresses that at the source. It's also designed to be genuinely easy to live with. Installation and removal are meant to be tool-free, and the edges are smoothed and burr-free so you don't nick your fingers when you pull it out. Cleaning is the same story as the GWYXC: if food residue lands on the mesh, soapy water handles it, and it's dishwasher safe.
Who should buy it? The fit list is specific, and that's a feature, not a bug: Ninja Foodi Smart XL 6-in-1 FG551, FG550, BG500A and DG551, plus the broader IG600/IG601/IG651 and AG300/AG301/AG302/AG400 families mentioned in the description. If you own one of those and you grill indoors often, a 2-pack means you always have a clean one ready while the other soaks. Who should skip it? Anyone expecting it to cook food, and anyone with a grill that isn't on the compatibility list. It's a wear part, not a gadget.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for protecting your appliance → BBQ-PLUS Stainless Steel Splatter. It shields the heating element from grease.
• Best for cooking larger batches in one go → GWYXC. The 13.5" × 12.3" rectangular footprint holds more in a single layer.
• Best for reducing smoke while grilling indoors → BBQ-PLUS. The ultra-fine mesh is designed to catch splatter before it reaches the heater.
• Best for even browning without flipping → GWYXC. The mesh design promotes 360° heat circulation.
• Best for a quick, low-effort cleanup → both. Both are dishwasher safe and both recommend soapy water for stuck-on residue.
• Best for gifting → GWYXC. It works as a general oven rack and grill basket, so it's useful beyond air frying.
• Best for a multi-unit household → BBQ-PLUS. The 2-pack means one in use, one clean.
• Best for buyers who hate measuring first → BBQ-PLUS, if your model is listed. Compatibility is spelled out by model number, so there's less guessing.
In my opinion, these two don't really compete, so the honest answer is "buy the one that matches the job." If I owned a Ninja Foodi SP-series countertop oven and wanted to cook more food, more evenly, with less oil, I'd buy the GWYXC basket. It's the more versatile purchase: it air-fries, grills and bakes, and the mesh design does the work you'd otherwise do with a spatula. If I owned one of the listed Ninja Foodi indoor grills and my problem was grease and smoke rather than capacity, I'd buy the BBQ-PLUS splatter shields without hesitating. Only one of these improves what you can cook; the other protects the machine that cooks it. Check the current price on Amazon and confirm your model number before either.
FAQ
No. They're specified for models including FG551, FG550, BG500A, DG551, plus the IG600/IG601/IG651 and AG300/AG301/AG302/AG400 families. Match your model number first.
Yes, both are dishwasher safe. GWYXC asks you to avoid abrasive cloths or metal balls, and BBQ-PLUS notes soapy water removes residue.
They solve different problems, so value depends on your appliance. If you need more cooking space, GWYXC is the useful buy; if you need to stop grease hitting the heater, BBQ-PLUS is. Worth noting: BBQ-PLUS ships as a 2-pack, so you get a spare.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Cosori Iconic Stainless Steel vs HOMLOVE 18QT: Best Air, GXF Air Fryer Cooking vs GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement, HEIPON Perforated Silicone Baking vs Yomvzake Air Fryer Jumbo