Methodological Approach
This qualitative research effort started in April 2025 to examine the impact of the recent withdrawal of USG support to civil society democracy actors and their societies. We understood that capturing what was happening everywhere all at once was not possible and chose to zoom in on the subset of watchdog and advocacy organizations as frontline democracy barometers in Serbia and Ukraine given geopolitical and democracy support considerations.
Within this targeted approach, we completed two steps to ensure a robust purposive sample. First, we identified a set of NGOs in Serbia and in Ukraine based on selection criteria of 1) active presence in the country; 2) organizational function as a think tank, watchdog or an advocacy organization; 3) mission focused on democracy programming; 4) active and functioning as of 2024; and 5) track record of USG funding support.
Second, the initial sample was reviewed by peer professionals with nuanced knowledge of the situation on the ground for validity, relevance, accuracy, completeness and inclusivity. With their added inputs, in total, we identified forty-five organizations, twenty-one in Serbia and twenty-four in Ukraine.
Due to varying response rates primarily due to availability, some concern about further political exposure, and political happenings in the countries during the summer months, we eventually conducted interviews with thirteen NGOs in Serbia and sixteen NGOs in Ukraine from June through August 2025. Interviews were conducted remotely based on a specifically designed structured interview guide with the NGO representatives. Interviews were approximately an hour in length and in some cases conducted in local language if requested, otherwise English. Most interviews were conducted by at least two of the three researchers for consistency and coverage in notetaking, but without recording. Notes from all meetings were coded, anonymized and analyzed by our team to co-create findings and recommendations for this policy brief without the use of AI.
Limitations
As noted above, this purposive sample was targeted and intentional due to broader limitations of conducting this type of research. That being said, we further recognized and have tried to mitigate the following potential limitations:
Feedback bias: Interviewees understood that we represented no organization or entity. And the atmosphere of the interviews was as peers and collegial. Yet respondents’ feedback on their organization and or situation could have at least unconsciously been done with a presentational viewpoint towards external donors or actors with hopes of additional support. We attempted to mitigate this dynamic by being transparent about our reasons for conducting the research and ensuring that interviewees were invited to be included as part of the brief presentation and discussion.
Nature of online interviews: Meeting in person in the NGO office or at least the café of choice of interviewees would have been much preferable for garnering even a richer set of impressions and data than online Zoom and related platform formats. However, we endeavored to create a casual atmosphere via the remote interview platform, and this combined with interviewees’ significant experience and use of online platforms usually created a conducive environment for in-depth interviews.
Fact-checking restrictions: Interviews included some statements made by interviewees that we could not corroborate given that we did not do a fact-checking exercise or assessment per se. Yet as experienced practitioners in the region we were able to identify, discuss, and code trends based on different levels of confidence in the data and to come to a presentation of data that we feel is based on robust evidence.
No external actor inputs: Interviews referenced their relationships with external donors and policy actors multiple times in the interviews, but due to the scope of our research, we did not interview donors mentioned or currently active in these countries. We tried to mitigate the danger of ‘one-sidedness’ by primarily focusing on external actor related themes coming out of the interviews that had multiple data points in both countries.
Reaction and reflection timing: We chose the timing for interviews for the summer when we anticipated most organizations have had their hardest times behind and had a better sense of the future. Yet in some senses, interviews from June through August were both too early and too late. Advocates had had time to absorb the situation and deal directly with it, but they also had not had adequate time to see the mid-term impacts on their societies and their organizations. Most were still ‘in the thick of everyday putting out of fires’ in very dynamic political contexts that could change daily. We tried to address this by focusing first on ‘end of the year’ trajectories and then beyond in hopes that this stepped progression be an aid for them in planning what next.
Serbia
1. Balkan Investigative Reporting Network Serbia
2. Belgrade Centre for Security Policy
4. Centre for Contemporary Politics
5. Center for Research, Transparency, and Accountability
6. Belgrade Centre for Human Rights
7. Center for Free Elections and Democracy
8. Helsinki Committee for Human Rights in Serbia
10. International and Security Affairs Center Fund
11. Partners Serbia
12. Slavko Curuvija Foundation
13. Trag Foundation
Ukraine
14. Anti-Corruption Action Center
15. Anti-corruption Center "MEZHA"
16. Centre for Democracy and the Rule of Law
17. Center for Civil Liberties
18. Centre for Economic Strategy
19. Centre of Policy and Legal Reform
20. Centre UA
21. CHESNO Movement
23. Detektor Media
24. DiXi Group
26. Ilko Kucheriv Democratic Initiatives Foundation
28. Transparency International Ukraine
29. Ukrainian Helsinki Human Rights Union