Student OOO | June 3, 2026
Nonfiction: The criminal Justice system is unjust because prisoners are continued to be dehumanized and killed.
Have you ever thought about what inmates face in prison in their day to day lives? Should everyone have to be in prison if they committed a crime? Are all prisoners bad people? Many reporters and researchers have argued that prisons are filled with death, overcrowding, and inequality, while others point out that many individuals are wrongfully sentenced or face unfair treatment within the criminal justice system. Although prisons are often presented as places for rehabilitation and justice, many correctional systems have been criticized for prioritizing punishment rather than helping incarcerated individuals. When prisons hold large populations and create dangerous environments, prisoners are often forced to fight for survival every day while hoping for eventual freedom. Authors like Emily Gale, Corey J. Elder, and Eric Finley all wrote articles based on their experiences with being incarcerated. Many articles and the social protest novel, Chain-Gang All- Stars, demonstrate an extreme reality where the criminal justice system is at the forefront of society and where incarcerated individuals must literally fight for their lives in order to earn release. The novel creates a dystopian world where prisoners are forced into televised death matches for public entertainment, forcing readers to question how society views those who are incarcerated. Although this novel is fictional, the exaggerated world reflects real concerns about modern prisons and the ways punishment can sometimes outweigh rehabilitation. In Chain-Gang All-Stars, and throughout many articles from incarcerated individuals, Nana Kwame Adjei-Brenyah reveals how the criminal justice system is unjust by proving how prisoners are exploited for entertainment, stripped of their humanity, and denied true freedom, demonstrating that the system values punishment and profit over justice and freedom.
In prison, a lot of the time, inmates fight just to bring their anger out on someone rather than keeping it bottled up. Prison affects a lot of inmates' mentality and mental health, and sometimes they spiral and end up becoming a very different person if or when they get released. In the fictional book Chain-Gang All-Stars, prisoners are forced to fight death matches in order to survive during their time in prison. Even if an inmate is trying to be better and does not want to stay locked up forever, they have no choice but to kill others in order to survive. However, my question is: Should people who served their time and try to be a much better person be able to get released? When prisoners do fight, it usually attracts people's attention and they seem to be really entertained by it. They start cheering, screaming, and hollering for prisoners murdering each other (Adjei Brenyah, 261). Viewers finding entertainment in these fights and in other people dying prove that they have no empathy for prisoners just because of the stereotype that all prisoners are awful people and deserve to be trapped in prison. The inhumane treatment that inmates face is a huge reflection on the criminal justice system because they promote these fights and reel viewers in to keep watching, causing a chain reaction of more and more prisoners dying. Although Adjei-Brenyah’s novel is fictional, these fights do occur in the real world. A WBNS news article stated that a correctional officer said, “‘You guys are gonna go in this cell, you’re gonna have four minutes to fight. You guys gotta make it look good. There’s a couple people betting on this fight’” (McEntyre). Prisoners often fight because they are forced to, or because they want to navigate their stress and anger. The words, “There’s a couple people betting on this fight,” discuss how the correctional officer illegally brought outside viewers into the prison to watch a fight. However, this entertainment isn’t only for the public; it is for the officers who work in the prison too. In another instance, the prison guards were so bored and wanted enjoyment that they took inmates out of cells, placed them in cells with each other, and forced them to fight (Crimesider Staff). The phrase, “forced them to fight,” demonstrates that the correctional officers do not care about the inmates’ or their feelings– they just torture them for their enjoyment. The way that this is normalized in prisons is another point that proves how the criminal justice system is falling apart and there needs to be a change. Another reason for fights and death in prison is overcrowding. Overcrowding increases the rate of violence and reduces the amount of staff. An inmate from Wisconsin witnessed two other inmates arguing, and when the cells were unlocked, a man stabbed two other guys, one of whom died. This was done purely out of frustration and isolation (Baker). When you are trapped in prison for so long, you become a different person. Because of this, you can have feelings that you don’t typically feel, causing you to do unspeakable things. Most fights in prison do end up in death, but everyone watching these fights, other prisoners and officers, get enjoyment and entertainment out of it. Prisoners are treated less like human beings and more like sources of entertainment for others. Instead of focusing on rehabilitation or improving inmates lives, both the novel and real prisons show systems that profit from suffering and violence. By turning prisoners' pain into entertainment, society begins to view incarcerated people as objects rather than humans, making cruelty seem acceptable.
When people are imprisoned, they often lose more than just their freedom—they lose their identity and humanity. In both the real world and in Chain-Gang All-Stars, prisoners are dehumanized through systems that treat them as disposable rather than as people. When inmates are treated like this, the death rate in prison increases substantially. Out of these deaths, “suicide is the leading cause of preventable death among prisoners” (Brenyah 292). Adjei-Brenyah uses logos to reveal that prison makes inmates want to kill themselves based on how corrupt it is. The psychological effect that being trapped in prison has on someone will destroy the last glimpse of hope. Another source explains that “Robert recalled 12 people he’s known personally who killed themselves in that timeframe, either while incarcerated or shortly after being released” (Gale). This statistic demonstrates that the damage caused by incarceration often extends beyond prison walls and continues even after release. Rather than rehabilitating people, these systems can create feelings of hopelessness, isolation, and emotional exhaustion that follow prisoners long after their sentence ends. In the CAPE system, you either kill or get killed. These death matches are another leading cause of death throughout the fictional novel. Adjei-Brenyah writes, “Follow me, then when you’re unlocked, you attack. Here, it’s okay to kill. Here, you have to” (Brenyah, 335). The words, “Here, it’s okay to kill” emphasize how prisoners are stripped of their morality and individuality because the system forces them to abandon basic human values simply to stay alive. If you want to survive the match, you have to kill other inmates in fights, regardless of if you want to or not. This loss of humanity is not only shown through violence, but also through the way prison systems treat inmates as if their lives have little value. Many prisoners are poorly represented because of financial status, or just because of the way they are viewed as less than. Some prisoners are “poorly represented and manipulated into accepting 20 years for a crime that really only carried five years” (Elder). Elder demonstrates how vulnerable individuals are exploited by a justice system that often values punishment over fairness. The justice system can trap people in unfair situations simply because they lack resources or support. Prisoners have to accept longer sentences than what is necessary because they are unqualified for a good lawyer or someone to represent them. The absurd world that prisoners live in every day makes the outside viewers believe they are terrible people and should never get released, making them less likely to get released or any help. Prisoners are treated as less than every day, revealing how systems built around punishment can ultimately destroy a person's humanity.
On the other hand, some people may think that anyone who has committed a crime deserves to stay in prison. This is because some people have committed far more worse crimes than others, influencing the stereotype that all prisoners are where they belong. However, some people want to become better people but are not offered rehabilitation in prison, forcing them to stay and be at the risk of death. Mari says, “There has never been a time where men didn’t prey on women…would you release people who have victimized others onto the street?” (Adjei-Brenyah 284) A lot of people in prison are very violent and locked up for a major reason. People like this should not be released. Some correctional officers are trying to benefit others and their communities. Goodwin University claimed that, "Without the criminal justice system, and all those who work in it, there might be havoc, violence, theft, and danger all around” (Goodwin University). When people are this violent and this large of a threat to the public, releasing them could jeopardize the safety throughout communities. The main argument is the safety for members of society in which some inmates should serve their time in prison. In contrast, there are many people within prisons who have served their necessary time for their crime that want to be better. Thurwar says, “A person so unchained despite it all. Staxxx reminded anyone lucky enough to see her that there were parts of a human that could never be chained” (Brenyah 296). Good people who have changed in prison are still trapped there and could die at any moment. These people deserve not only their families and loved ones, but themselves and others that it is possible to become a different person, even if surrounded with negativity. All in all, many people in prison who are harmless deserve to get out and finish their life freely.
Not only are prisoners dehumanized and used for entertainment, but they are also denied true freedom. When you are stuck in prison for so long, even if you were wrongly sentenced, the views from the outside world are making prisoners out to be terrible people. Brenyah wrote, “You could believe there were good people and bad people. And that the good deserved glory and the bad deserved punishment” (Brenyah 398). Even though there are people protesting and people who disagree with CAPE, everyone is still in prison and will continue to lose their humanity every day until a change is made. The protestors, specifically Mari, prove that they want to make a change and want prisoners to be granted freedom. However, when Mari was protesting, the cops shot a black rod into her back (Adjei-Brenyah 371). The use of pathos when the officers shot Mari demonstrate that there are people who have sympathy for the prisoners, but they are risking their lives by fighting for prisoners' release. The idea of fighting for prisoners' lives extends beyond just those who are incarcerated. Brenyah reminds us that many people are imprisoned despite committing no real crime, exposing that, “—and those in the immigration detention camps too. Who were being held for no crime at all except trying to live” (Brenyah 278). The words, “except trying to live” highlights that systems of incarceration can punish vulnerable people for just trying to live, further proving how freedom is stripped away. Additionally, the impact of incarceration goes beyond just those who are incarcerated; it impacts their families too. As Finley explains, “Once a family becomes caught in this repeating cycle of incarceration and abandonment, our dysfunctional criminal justice system just keeps grinding them up” (Finley). Finley demonstrates that imprisonment creates long lasting cycles of suffering that are difficult to escape, showing that in both Chain-Gang All-Stars and in reality, the criminal justice system often takes away not only freedom but also humanity and hope.
All in all, this is an issue that occurs in many books, articles, but most importantly; in real life. Prisoners are getting killed for simply existing under many circumstances, which is a major issue that needs to gain attention. Prisoners have to keep the ounce of hope they have left as motivation, while in reality the treatment they receive is inhumane. An unjust criminal justice system creates cycles of dehumanization and inequality by stripping people of their freedom, humanity, and chances for a better future.
Orange County Criminal Defense Blog
Adjei-Brenyah, Nana Kwame. Chain-Gang All-Stars. Pantheon Books, 2023.
Nana Kwame Adjei- Brenyah is a fiction author known for his satire, dystopian novel about the criminal justice system in America. In Chain Gang All-Stars, he discusses many themes: criminal justice, abolition, technology and government control, etc. He made his novel about a future incarceration system where prisoners fight for their life every day. Through this idea, Adjei-Brenyah criticizes how violence can become normalized. The theme of non profit prisons and the criminal justice system is supported by this book because it shows how inmates are dehumanized and controlled. The novel encourages readers to question how these fights can leave people entertained. This source is important to my theme because it helps readers connect emotionally with the prison issues and understand the need for change.
Baker, Fontaine. “Why Wisconsin Should End Truth in Sentencing.” Prison Journalism Project, 20 July 2023, https://prisonjournalismproject.org/2023/07/20/wisconsin-should-end-truth-in-sentencing/
Elder, Corey. “Rightly Convicted, Wrongly Sentenced.” Prison Journalism Project, 12 March, 2021, https://prisonjournalismproject.org/2021/03/12/rightly-convicted-wrongly-sentenced/
Corey J Elder’s article is about how some people go to prison for longer than what is necessary, most of the time because of their financial state and legal support. He explains that when someone is poor, or has disadvantages, they cannot have someone defend or represent them. This leads to the person having to accept a much longer sentence than what they really needed. Elder emphasizes that the justice system can treat wealthy and poor individuals very differently, creating inequality within the courts. The article also shows how disadvantaged people may feel powerless because they do not have the resources to properly defend themselves. This source is important because it highlights the flaws in the criminal justice system and explains how financial status can affect someone’s future. A prisoner’s perspective makes the article more meaningful because he focuses on the real struggles people face when dealing with unfair sentencing.
Crimesider Staff. “Prison Fight Club: Inmates in St. Louis accuse prison gaurds of forcing them to fight, report says.” CBS News, 2 July, 2013, https://www.cbsnews.com/news/prison-fight-club-inmates-in-st-louis-accuse-prison-guards-of-forcing-them-to-fight-report-says/
Finley, Eric “Incarceration is a Vicious Cycle.” Prison Journalism Project, 1 December, 2021, https://prisonjournalismproject.org/2021/12/01/incarceration-is-a-vicious-cycle/
Eric Finley’s article discusses how incarceration affects both the prisoner and their families. He explains that many parents lose contact with their children while in prison, forcing both parent and child to struggle emotionally with separation. Finley argues that limited communication with loved ones makes incarceration even more difficult. He also describes how incarceration can create a cycle of emotional pain, isolation, and hardships that continue long after a prison sentence ends. Children may grow up without parental support, leading to emotional and financial challenges for families. This article is important because it shows that incarceration impacts entire communities, not just the person in prison. This source helps readers understand the long term emotional consequences of incarceration and why maintaining family relationships is important. Finley’s personal perspective makes the article more powerful and helps the reader understand the human impact of the prison.
Gale, Emily “How Prison Makes Death Routine.” Prison Journalism Project, 9 April 2026, https://prisonjournalismproject.org/2026/04/09/prison-makes-death-routine/
Emily Gale wrote an article explaining how death and violence become normal parts of everyday life in prisons. She shares stories and letters from incarcerated people around the United States to discuss how violence and death affect prisoners emotionally and mentally. Gale argues that prions often do not provide people with enough space or support to grieve, causing incarcerated individuals to become surrounded with trauma, death, and emotional pain. She also explains how constant exposure to death can negatively affect mental health relationships with others. By including first hand stories, the article becomes more realistic for readers, helping them better understand life inside prisons. This source is helpful because it provides personal experiences and emotional insight to prison life, helping readers better understand the effects incarceration can have on individuals. This helps prove the argument that prisons often create trauma, encouraging readers to think more physically about the prison systems in America.
“The Importance of the Criminal Justice System and Today’s Professionals.” Goodwin University, 25 August 2020, https://www.goodwin.edu/enews/importance-of-the-criminal-justice-system/
Goodwin University wrote an article explaining the importance of the criminal justice system and the role it plays in society today. Even though some may think it is unfair, the purpose of it is to create equality across the innocent. guilty, and to keep the citizens safe. The article explains that laws and punishments help keep communities safe by holding criminals accountable for their actions. They claim that without the criminal justice system, there would likely be more violence, crime, and danger because there would be fewer consequences for breaking the law. Convicting those who are guilty is a major part of keeping the people safe. Without the criminal justice system, the dangerous people who are in prison for a reason would be a major threat if they were let free. In addition, police officers, judges, lawyers, and correctional officers all work together to maintain order and protect people’s rights. The article also highlights how important it is for professionals in the criminal justice field to act fairly and responsibly.