World press institute
World press institute
Student JJJ | Jun 9 2026
(Nonfiction): See the truth on American prisons here
Ever wonder what the real dark side of prison is like? What are the real experiences in prison like? While most American prisons have great security, many people face mental health issues and experience the harsh realities of prisons while Adjei-Brenyah, author of Chain-Gang All-Stars, writes about what he thinks the future of incarceration systems will look like fighting arenas and gladiator style fighting for money. Statistics,experiences and storytelling show the truth behind the criminal justice system and life in prison: it is harsh and ineffective on reform and has room for improvement as despite this it causes mental health issues and is inhumane at times for inmates and a high rate of repeat offenders
The criminal justice system is ineffective and inhumane as told through experience and testimonies. One of these testimonies is from Derek Jason Lecompte, a current prisoner and he talks about how he was “in solitary when my father passed away. I didn’t get to talk to him when he was on his deathbed. I never got to say goodbye.”(Derek Jason) American prisons show little compassion for people's loved ones as they don’t allow people to spend time with their loved ones as Jason was stuck in solitary as his own father was in suffering. What would you have done if you were in solitary as your father was dying? Or what could you have done? Prisons don’t show any humanity because prisoners commit crimes which seems inhumane and unjust. Crimes and breaking the law should be punished with reform and not be treated as if you aren’t human and have feelings. No matter what you do in or out of prison you should still be treated like a human, which is the main issue with incarceration as America struggles to balance humanity and captivity with its incarceration system. One other testimony similar to this is Kimberly C. as she talks about her experience with her cellmate questioning her about how she looked and changed since she has been to prison. It states,“Without a good mirror or blunt friend to tell us otherwise, there’s not much we can do to fight back other than believe we look as good as we hope.” Her cellmate is showing signs of mental health issues as she starts to question how she looks and if she has changed since she has been to prison. Questioning yourself can lead to more negativity over time, and since prison does not keep your mind well distracted, it only encourages you to focus on the fact that you are in prison and can’t see your family or go outside. Prison can be so much more than that, but the incarceration system does not really care for its prisoners' mental health. One other experience that Derek Jason had was with a friend in prison and how they both cried as it was his friend's son’s birthday. Derek Jason writes, “Austin Meli told me the only time he had a real good cry was during his son’s birthday.”(Derek Jason) Prisons do a horrible job to address the mental health issues problem as American prisons are built on security not for the well being of people. Some people believe that prison is as if you were put on timeout if you were an adult, so they think the same solution that applied to them when they were young would apply to adults which is wrong and ineffective. If America spent more time on changing its prisons the repeat offender rate or people who commit the same crime again would be way lower.
In addition statistics show the truth behind the criminal justice system and life in prison as mentally cruel and ineffective on reform. In “U.S. Prison System Rated High on Security, Low on Reform” by Megan Brenan it states Just 16% of Americans believe the system does an excellent or good job at rehabilitating inmates so they are less likely to commit crimes in the future, while nearly eight in 10 rate it as only fair (32%) or poor (47%).” 79% of Americans think prisons do a fair to a horrible job on reform showing the extent of the issue of reforms on prisons. This does not even cover ex-inmate or current prisoners but if 79% of Americans believe that this is an issue then it should be addressed. One other horrible fact on prisons comes from Equal Justice Initiative and in their article it states “Nationwide, suicides among people held in isolation account for almost 50% of all prison suicides, even though less than 8% of the prison population is in isolation.” American prisons do so poorly on reform that about 4% of prisons in isolation commit suicide which is a sad and disturbing fact. Imagine getting a phone call that a family member of yours died in prison by suicide. 4% is still a number, a number of people who died for the failure of the American incarceration system. Lastly, one other fact on prisons by Storm Ervin and the Urban Institute is that “One estimate from a systematic review that included 23,967 incarcerated people found that 18.8 percent had experienced physical violence in prison, with women having a slightly higher rate (20.3 percent) than men (18.1 percent)” The ineffectiveness of American prisons affects everyone which is why it need change and it needs it now. The longer the American prison system is like this. The more people get hurt the more that prisoners' mental health deteriorates.
Conversely, American prisons have great security compared to other prisons around the globe. As Megan Brenan, a writer and public opinion researcher says “More than six in 10 U.S. adults say the nation’s prison system does an “excellent” (16%) or “good” (46%) job at maintaining high security to keep prisoners behind bars.” 66% percent of America believes in our prison system's security. Although that may seem positive,all the focus is on the prison security and not the well being of the prisoners, which does not give justice, it spreads negativity and depression and all other mental health issues. According to Morse Watchman,“correctional facility security is often a high-technology operation, with officers operating both the physical and technological components of the system. High-definition video surveillance, complex locking systems, and highly trained guards operate hand in hand to ensure that prisoners keep to designated areas.” Americans put this much dedication into the security of prisons but not into the well being of the people in prison. American prisons security is great but it’s living spaces, harsh environment and it’s prisoners mental health that lacks recognition and action on.
Lastly, storytelling can reveal the truth about American prisons. Adjei-Brenyah writes about incarcerated individuals who fight to stay alive and join the “CAPE” program in future America, but while some live to see the sun, others don’t. Adjei-Brenyah wrote a scene about a woman protesting the “CAPE” program. It states “Mari kneeled down and kept the sign high in the air, proudly speaking the truth. You didn’t get to have it both ways.. The front of the sign said:Where Life Is Precious and the back.. Life is Precious(371)” People protest about the American incarceration system all the time today and for Adeji-Brenyah to include protests in future America shows how incarceration systems have only changed for the worse. By Adeji-Brenyah mentioning this detail he believes that if nothing changes about American incarceration systems now then it will get worse with each passing day revealing how American prisons really treat their prisoners. One other major piece of dialogue is when another protester states “They were all humans, and yet they had completely different ideas about what humanity meant(154)” Incarceration systems lack humanity and don’t leave room for reform and if prisons don’t change soon the dehumanization of prisoners will become greater and greater until the dehumanization of prisoners becomes the new normal. The lack of humanity in incarceration systems today is already concerning but if treating prisoners who commit a crime or multiple crimes don’t get treated like humans it will become the new normal and that has already started to happen. One last major detail is Sunset's daughter. Sunset was a prisoner who joined the ‘CAPE” program and died in a gladiator fight and her daughter started to protest against this program as it states “The woman was sunset’s daughter, Marissa and there she was on the battleground holding a sign that read:WHERE LIFE IS PRECIOUS(366)” One major thing that is common in the Adeji-Branyah’s book and the real world is people dying in prison leaving families devastated and sad. Prisoners should not have to die for other people's entertainment. There is no humanity in that those prisoners have family waiting to see them come home. What if you heard the news of your mother or father dying while they were serving their time in jail? It's a shame that it has already happened to some unfortunate families because the American incarceration system failed them and if there is no change in America's prison system then it will fail thousands of others too.
Overall, experiences show first hand witnesses of the harsh conditions of prison and how they lacked in their mental health while statistics prove mental health issues and the harshness of prison does not just happen to a small few of incarcerated individuals but way more. While Adjei-Brenyah writes Chain-Gang All-Stars to write what he believes future incarceration systems will look like gladiator arenas and people dying for other people's entertainment are to prove a point. American prisons are ineffective on reform, are a brutal and harsh environment and some prisoners suffer with mental health issues and that American prisons need change and that they need it now.
Foreign Policy:
Annotated Bibliography:
Brenan, Megan. “U.S Prison System Rated High On Security, Low on Reform.” Gallup News, 6 November 2025.
https://news.gallup.com/poll/697472/prison-system-rated-high-security-low-reform.aspx
In “U.S Prison System Rated High On Security, Low on Reform” the statistics show that
U.S. prisons are great in maintaining security and low escape rates but at the cost of low reform rates and high repeat offenders. But even though it has low reform rates at least people outside feel safe when people are in prison and are confident in them. 62% of total adults trust prison security as the main goal of prison is to keep prisoners safe and secluded away from society because of something that they did. My source as it comes from Gallup news which has a positive history of being objective. I will use this source as a minor) part of my essay to view both arguments on life in prison.
Lecompte Jason Derek “Why I cry in Prison” Prison Journalism Project , 5 March 2026 https://prisonjournalismproject.org/2026/03/05/why-i-cry-in-prison/
In “Why I cry in prison” Derek Jason Lecompte writes his time in prison is filled with grief as his family was unsupported and some family members dying without him getting to say a proper goodbye but finds comfort in sharing his grief with others. My main argument is for-profit prisons should not exist as they disregard prisoners' mental health. So Derek Jason had to figure out his own way to cope by showing his emotions because emotions are meant to be shared because if held your emotions can do more hurt than good as Crying always brings relief showing how emotions are natural and are a part of our lives that are meant to regulate us. Emotion is also connected to Derek Jason making new friends through grief because he was able to talk to people while he was feeling a lot of emotions. Although even he shared his emotions does not mean the trauma he faces isn't there.This is a major issue in profit prisons. They don’t really care about their prisoners' mental health, they only care about how much money they can make off of people. I will be using this argument in my essay to support my thesis and is a reliable source as the author has experienced this himself.
Larson Doran “Why Scandinavian Prisons Are Superior” The Atlantic
In “Why Scandinavian Prisons Are Superior” Larson Doran talks about people's prison
experiences in northern Europe and how it allowed for reform while balancing positive
living space and allowing more visiting hours to keep prisoners mental health at a all time
high and still having low reform rates of 28%. While the U.S. struggles in reform has horrible living conditions and low visiting hours leaving many prisoners with mental health issues and bad habits that causes a rearrest rate of 65% and 39% out of rearrested felons return to prison. Larson Doran highlights what American prisons struggle on and they need to fix so it can lower rearrest rates and see a change for the better in the American correctional system. This source is reliable because it mentions how it collects data and its process to make articles. I will be using this article in my essay as it is a major component in my counterargument.
Nana Kwame Adjel-Brenyah Chain-Gang all-stars, 2 May 2023
In Chain-Gang All-Stars Adjel-Brenyah writes about a future incarnation system where prisoners compete in death matches to live another day while the prison makes money by hosting these matches in a stadium. Adjel-Brenyah suggests that this could be the future of incarceration systems as most of the prisons in the U.S are for profit and not for the people inside it. This leads to neglected prisoners as most of the money the prison makes is given to staff and the warden but almost none of it goes towards the prisoners living conditions. Eventually leading to mental health issues and other issues and habits that stick with them and eventually when they leave and have served their time the prison does what they were trying to stop. The reason why up 83% of prisoners are repeat offenders is because they attended a for profit prison proving that they are not effective as they focus on money and not what the prison is meant to be, A space where people can think about what they have done and develop as a person but they can’t do that when they are in a hostile environment because the living conditions are bad which is a part of Adjel-Brenyah argument. I will be using this as a part of my main argument in my essay and it is reliable and a credible source as it was published as a book in May 2023.
Shockley, Jeffery. “How jobs work in Pennsylvania Prisons.” Prison Journalism Project , 27 January 2026 https://prisonjournalismproject.org/2026/01/27/what-kind-of-jobs-are-available-in-prisons.
In How jobs work in Pennsylvania Prisons Jeffery Shockley talks about how he was able
to keep his mental health stable through jobs he talks about his past jobs and how they helped him throughout his time in incarceration. He also talks about what he thinks would have happened to him if he did not take these jobs. He thought his time in prison would be miserable until he started working. By Jeffery starting jobs in prison it led to him finding focus. It also allowed him to keep his peace and his mental health high even though he was incarcerated to distract himself. But if it takes Jobs to keep prisoners normal then the prison is not doing what it’s supposed to. One job that Jeffery Shockley had was a janitor but he only made a couple cents an hour while the average janitor makes 20$ an hour. This happens a lot with for-profit prisons as they exploit people's circumstances to profit off of them. Prison is not supposed to be like this, it 's supposed to be a space where you can reflect and not be exploited for labor. I will be using this as a key source in my essay as it is a key topic.