Student MMM | June 7th, 2026
(Nonfiction): Essay detailing how modern aboliton can be applied in American society.
Have you, or anyone you’ve ever met, been wronged by the American justice system? If so, the idea of prison abolition may be of interest to you. Prison abolition is the idea that modern prison systems should be replaced by a system that is able to successfully reintegrate the currently, and formerly incarcerated into society. Prison abolition is an idea, that when implemented into a society correctly it is not only beneficial to all incarcerated individuals by also the citizens of a nation. Impacting both positively through efforts made to not just reform the prison system, but actually abolish it. Prison abolition also covers the goal to rid the world of all forms of slavery that are still present to this day. Abolishing the current prison system would allow for a decrease in incarceration rates, eliminate a system rigged against those of color, and provide a more beneficial solution rather than reform.
The justice system within America is failing both the people, and society as a whole. Mass incarceration is a leading cause of this failure. Both Ashley Nellis and Sabrina Pearce have spoken out against the U.S.’s stagnant dependence on mass incarceration, stating, “Mass incarceration remains a defining feature of the American criminal legal system. The U.S. ranks among the highest worldwide in its dependence on incarceration.”(Nellis and Pearce) The dependence of incarceration stemming from a constant flow of “wars on crime”. The growing dependence on incarceration highlights the failure of the American legal system. Nellis and Pearce illustrate the incapability to have a just justice system in the U.S. The rate at which incarceration grows is seemingly never ending, and even when hope draws near that the tides are turning “The year 2022 marked the first year in a decade where the prison population rose again, by 2%. The prison population continued to rise by an additional 2% in 2023”(Nellis and Pearce). Pearce and Nellis both display how within the current prison system there’s virtually no hope in ending mass incarceration. Leading to the want, and possible need for the abolishment of the current prison system. As it remains inefficient in its ways it becomes obvious that, “This system of control is vast, unevenly applied, and deeply consequential with far reaching social, economic, and political effects.”(Nellis and Pearce) Both Nellis and Pearce are able to convey the need for abolition through revealing the unfairness, and depravity of the justice system’s treatment of the currently and formerly incarcerated. Proving that reform is simply not enough, and the need for complete abolition is becoming obvious. The obviousness becomes apparent throughout the entirety of the quote. The words “vast, unevenly applied, and deeply consequential” highlights the flaws of the current justice system. Which is the constant failure in successfully preparing the incarcerated to rejoin society. Leaving room for a new system for the betterment of everyone. When looking deeper into the effects the prison system has on the formerly incarcerated it becomes clear that the prison system is simply not doing enough. Nellis and Pearce are both able to bring these ideas to light by stating, “Mass incarceration instigates numerous poor, physical, psychological, and economic outcomes for those who experience imprisonment… Imprisonment leads to declining prospects for employment and results in lower earnings in the long term.” (Nellis and Pearce)These truths are able to display the complete and utter failure of the prison system to prepare, and assist the formerly incarcerated reintegrate into society. Nellis and Pearce communicate that despite the forever growing population in the U.S. the prison system is unable to make any reforms to the worsening system, again indicating the need for the complete abolishment of the prison system.
Prison abolition seeks to destroy a system made to target minorities, and ultimately provide a solution to the flaws within the prison system when reform isn’t enough. The authors of the article “The fight for liberation: Prison abolitionists seek to end police and prisons” Ariama Long and Tandy Lau both attest to the idea of Prison abolition, using numerous prison, and policing abolitionists words to convey the need for Prison abolition. Robert Saleem Holbrook who directs Pittsburgh’s Abolitionist Law Center, states his reasons for the abolishment of prisons, and policing stating “‘We seek to dismantle the vestiges of white supremacy, of injustice, [and] of abuses of the carceral state,’ he said. ‘Abolishment is the long-term project, but in the immediate [moment], we seek to erode them and diminish their harmful impacts on our communities [by] freeing people from prison’”(Long and Lau) Holbrook’s commentary on the “vestiges of white supremacy” exhibit the need for the abolishment of the prison system. Conveying the fact that the prison system as a whole is designed to keep mainly those of color in a state of no return. Not only does Holbrook bring this to light, he also illuminates the sad truth that the prison system isn’t beneficial to anyone within American society, remaining detrimental to all. A criminal justice activist who ran for city council in Amsterdam, New York, who is also a formerly incarcerated man himself “considered the question of whether the city should abolish or reform prisons. Instead of discussing his own experience, he spoke about Kalief Browder, another young Black teen, who spent three years on Rikers Island awaiting trial for a low-level crime and committed suicide after his release from jail. Other countries, Salaam said, have criminal and legal systems that humanize even the worst offenders, but the U.S. system is, at its base, punitive.”(Long and Lau) Salaam’s choice to tell the story of a teen who experiences injustices by the justice system similarly to himself displays the constant shortcomings of the prison, and justice system when it comes to actually doing what's right. Again Salaam’s story also demonstrates the continuous mistreatment of minorities within the prison system, with the blatant ignorance of the prison system being put on full display. Brooklyn College professor Alex Vitale comments on how reform just isn’t enough anymore, opting to instead support the complete abolition of prison and policing. While discussing his reasons for supporting the movement Vitale states, “‘An abolitionist says no, the professional unbiased implementation of the law is still unjust because our legal system was designed to enable systems of equality and exploitation’”(Long and Lau) Vitale’s usage of the phrase “unbiased implementation of the law is still unjust” exemplifies the true nature of the current prison and policing system. The nature is to push minorities down to their lowest. Again revealing the persecution of minorities within the prison system. Vitale also covers the fact that reform within our current prison system is just not enough. Determining the approach of complete abolishment to be a necessity. Alex Vitale states, “ ‘we need to create community power, and that means you have to organize around steps you can take right now. The Challenge is trying to take steps that aren’t… religitmating these institutions through superficial reforms.’” (Long and Lau)Vitale’s ability to convey the idea that prison reform is simply not enough is put on full display throughout the quote. Vitale is able to shine light on how prison abolition would create “community power” in turn bettering society as a whole. Having such new “community power” would also allow for the complete annihilation of a system put in place to demean and strip minorities of their dignity.
Despite the numerous benefits of prison abolition and growing support, some may argue that complete abolition of the current system is counterproductive and frankly, unrealistic. Often choosing reform as the more practical alternative when compared to the complete abolition of the prison system. From Daniel Fryer’s “Reforming Abolition” from his perspective abolition is described as an “Abolition is an elusive concept, which allows people with various political views to identify with the idea. This Article unpacks some of the conceptual features that lead to its elusiveness. This imprecision has empowered some to point out the diverse—if not inconsistent—positions that self-identified abolitionists take when articulating the contemporary abolition movement’s demands.”(Fryer) The word “elusive” is able to capture the idea that many have of abolition. That being there is no clear cut definition of the term to many especially when carrying the view that the movement itself contains inconsistencies, and overlapping positions. The so called “elusiveness” of abolition can also create uncertainty of the stability of abolition, or if it could ever actually work. Fryer further pushes this concern when stating, "it comes from those who ground their absolutism in principles inconsistent with the positive features necessary to achieve an abolition democracy. A consequence of this view is that the lines between abolition and reform become blurry. Some abolitionists argue that this blurriness is reason to reject reformist proposals.”(Fryer) which raises the question of whether or not abolition can ever be separated from reform. If there is seemingly no distinction between the two solutions, it can easily be argued that abolition becomes incapable of functioning as an alternative to reform. Since both solutions have overlapping goals of changing, and reducing certain aspects of the current system rather than being completely different approaches. It can be assumed that reform is a more concrete solution because it focuses on the immediate changes to the current system. Often it is argued that discourse between abolitionists reveals that reform is already embedded into many abolitionist beliefs. This idea comes up throughout Fryer’s article, Fryer states “most abolitionists are out to reform something, and the primary source of disagreement within the movement is about what must be reformed,”(Fryer) Fryer conveys the idea that abolitionists are not unified in rejecting reform but are instead divided on how to apply it. This relates to the idea that reform is already within and abolitionist ideals. Fryer later points out that attempts to separate reform from abolition using differing terminology usually don’t resolve any tension, Fryer explains that “the appeal to non-reformist reforms substitutes one elusive term (abolition) for another (non-reformist reforms),”(Fryer) Throughout the quote Fryer suggests that redefining reform does not just eliminate the ambiguity of the word, instead it creates more confusion ultimately pushing some away from the movement as a whole.
Overall, Prison abolition is an idea that when implemented into American society it can create a beacon of hope when faced with normally troubling times. Completely tearing down the current inefficient, and incapable prison system in favor of one that is actually able to assist the formerly, and currently incarcerated into society. At the cost of replacing an old, outdated, and prejudiced system that has plagued many for decades.
“Slavery has been outlawed globally since 1981, when Mauritania became the last country to legally abolish the practice.” freedomcenter.org, https://freedomcenter.org/learn/modern-day-abolition/
The orginization behind the publication of this article is well known for raising awareness of the presence of slavery in the world today. The author of this article displays their credibility through using numerous examples of backed up facts, and statistics regarding slavery in our world today. Reinforcing the idea that action needs to be taken. Based upon the severity that is slavery in the modern day. The article mainly argues that slavery still exists within our world. Similarly, this article discusses major issues within almost every country. A major one that recurs is human trafficking. The author also mentions the 5 forms of slavery that can be found in the world today. The main point of this article is to raise awareness on the topic of modern slavery. Also how slavery remains lingering in the world today, never truly dying out. As I write my essay this source will be used as an introduction to modern aboliton.
Adjei-BrenYah,Nana Kwame. Chain Gang All Stars,Pantheon books, 5/2/23.
This novel depicts the theme of modern abolition through its creation of characters who directly speak out against the CAPE system. Although modern abolition may not be the most recurring theme, or even the most important throughout the novel. Its significance is still depicted through many characters. Modern abolition in Chain Gang All Stars is used as an anchor to reality in a dystopian society. Despite the normalization of violence within the world of Chain Gang All Stars there remains a group of protestors dedicated to taking down the justice system through the ideals of modern aboltion. This novel will be used in my essay to reinforce the idea that is the failure of the U.S. justice system.
(Delete and type descriptive paragraph here)
Ariama C. Long and Tandy Lau,“The fight for liberation: Modern abolitionists seek to end police and prisons,” Amsterdam News, New York Amsterdam News,6/15/23,https://amsterdamnews.com/news/2023/06/15/the-fight-for-liberation-modern-abolitionists-seek-to-end-police-and-prisons/
The main point of this article is to introduce the idea of modern abolition to the reader. As well as how modern abolition has been seen in areas likely close to the reader(New York). Not only do the authors introduce and explain modern abolition, but they provide what it would actually look like in our world. Displaying not just how modern abolition aims to rid the world of slavery, but also the reshaping of the justice system. Using other credible speakers to explain the main argument of the article. The speaker's credibility comes not from being an “expert” on the subject, but instead from how they have been incarcerated and have had first hand accounts of the justice system. This main argument being that modern abolition could, and would be a positive thing to see in our society. Giving examples on how it can be beneficial to many communities. When writing my essay this source can be used to display how modern abolition would actually affect communities. These communites would give former, and currently incarcerated people a real second chance in life.
Fryer, Daniel, “Reforming Abolition.” Michigan Law Review, University of Michigan, November, 2025, https://michiganlawreview.org/journal/reforming-abolition/
The main point of this article is to explain the relationship between modern abolition and reform. The author mainly focuses on the point that abolition should not only focus on completely removing prisons and policing, but also improve society through these reforms. The article explains that people often misunderstand abolition because it can mean different things to different groups of people. The author believes that instead of arguing over whether or not policing, and prisons should be abolished or reformed, both groups should actually work together to make a difference. The article also touches on problems such as racism, mass incarceration, and violence in prisons. Displaying how many changes are needed in the justice system. The author makes his claims credible by using other research, and evidence to support his claims. As I write my essay, this article will be used in the counterargument against simply abolishing the current justice system.
Nellis, Ashley and Pearce, Sabrina “Mass Incarceration Trends,” The Sentencing Project, The Sentencing Project, 4/9/26 , https://www.sentencingproject.org/reports/mass-incarceration-trends/
This article's purpose is to educate people on recent mass incarceration trends, but also how they compare to previous incarceration rates. The authors also convey to the reader how the U.S.A. ranks among the highest of its dependence upon incarceration. To display the truth of these claims the authors use numerous examples of statistics. These statistics are able to dig deeper into the flaws of the justice system, as well as the flaws of the prison system. With the main trend of mass incarceration being the root of said flaws. This source will be central in arguing for modern abolition, and how it would positively impact a majority of the country. Through the goal of modern abolition to create a better society by reshaping the modern prison system into something that actually works.