Caldwell, Kansas was founded in 1871 near the Chisholm Trail.
Methodist circuit riders began ministry in 1873, with Rev. B.C. Swartz organizing the First Methodist Episcopal Church.
The first church building was erected in 1879 and dedicated in 1881.
Despite challenges like grasshopper plagues, the church grew steadily.
A new brick church was built in 1914 and dedicated in 1915, seating 650 people.
A pipe organ was added in 1917; the church hosted high school commencements and revival meetings.
During the 1918 flu epidemic, the church basement was converted into a hospital.
The Methodist denominations united in 1939, forming the Methodist Church.
New furnishings, musical instruments, and memorial gifts enriched worship.
Major updates included a new organ (1952), air conditioning (1955), and parsonage improvements.
The Methodist Church merged with the Evangelical United Brethren Church in 1968 to form the United Methodist Church.
Ecumenical efforts and youth programs flourished.
Extensive renovations began in 1982, including basement remodeling and elevator installation.
Rev. Bill McFall played a key role in overseeing construction and fostering community spirit.
Heritage celebrations, memorial gifts, and stained-glass window tours were held.
The EDUCAN scholarship program was founded in 1995 to support students’ education.
The church hosted events like dinner theaters and lighted Christmas parades.
The tutoring program TOPS ran from 2000 to 2008.
Ongoing updates to the parsonage and sanctuary were supported by donations and memorials.
The United Methodist Women celebrated their 25th anniversary in 1997.