Gender is a key component to an individual's identity. Every student has the right to feel safe and welcomed in the classroom, regardless of their gender identity. As a result, educators are responsible for incorporating gender inclusive language in their classrooms; as defined by Pamela Malins (2016), this approach aims to utilize language that is equitable for all and avoids stereotypes as well as discriminatory assumptions.
As educators, it isn't enough to highlight diverse gender identities at the surface; at that point it's simply performative. The focus of our lessons and resources must shift to not only highlight certain perspectives but to incorporate diverse voices and lived experiences. As outlined by numerous scholars, to achieve this level of inclusivity we require a transformation of lesson content. In other words, we aim to use Gender Transformative Education as our model.
For many students, exposure to diverse voices and identities may only happen at school. As a result, it is our responsibility, as educators, to transform our teaching practices to not only highlight but normalize various gender identities.
To achieve this goal, there are three main strategies outlined by UNICEF (2021):
Teacher education aiming to promote equitable teaching practices (i.e. professional development, pre-teaching program instruction, anti-hate models)
Curriculum reform that strives to incorporate various lived experiences
Teacher to teacher development wherein we collaborate with colleagues and peers to ensure this model spans eqaully across classrooms
Moorhead (2018) proposes a framework that outlines four levels of Gender Transformative Education. This framework provides educators with examples of how to ensure that their lessons are not simply performative but effective.
The four levels are as follows:
This level of the approach focuses on highlighting diverse perspectives on the basis of heroes, holidays, or specific cultural/societal impacts.
In a French classroom, an example of this would be reading a book about a notable Transgender individual on International Day of Trans Visibility and answering reading comprehension questions.
The additive approach incorporates diverse voices and representation without inherently changing the curriculum.
For example, this could be conducting a French novel study that features a non-binary side character; however, the study's main focus still remains on the cis-gendered main characters and their experiences.
The transformative approach is the first goal for educators. This level takes the additive approach and enhances it to not only incorporate but highlight diverse gendered perspectives, while inherently changing the curriculum.
An example of this would be conducting a French novel study in which the main character is non-binary. As opposed to the additive approach, this study would highlight the main characters experiences in relation to their identity.
The fourth approach takes a social justice perspective and aims to promote students to act on certain issues in society. If the previous three levels are successfully achieved by the teacher, students should gain the skills to critically analyze the world around them.
Continuing with the example of the novel study, this means adding a culmulative task that features an element of raising awareness for the issues that non-binary individuals may face at the hands of society.
References
Malins, Pamela. (2016). How inclusive is “inclusive education” in the Ontario elementary classroom?: Teachers talk about addressing diverse gender and sexual identities. Teaching and Teacher Education, 54, 128-138. https://doi-org.ledproxy2.uwindsor.ca/10.1016/j.tate.2015.11.004.
Moorhead, Laura. (2018). LGBTQ+ visibility in the K-12 curriculum. The Phi Delta Kappan, 100(2), 22-26. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26552438.
UNICEF. (2021). GENDER TRANSFORMATIVE EDUCATION: Reimagining education for a more just and inclusive world.