What Piano Do I (or Does My Child) Need?
One of the first questions parents ask when signing up for piano lessons is, "What kind of piano should we buy?" Adults starting lessons ask the same thing, especially if they haven't played in years and aren't sure whether their old keyboard will do.
The good news is that you don't need to spend a fortune to get started. You don't necessarily need a grand piano, a fancy digital instrument, or something that takes up half your living room. But there are a few things that really do matter, and it's worth knowing what to look for before you spend your money.
I have one rule that I always come back to: The best piano is the one on which you (or your child) will actually practice voluntarily! A beautiful, expensive instrument that nobody wants to play isn't doing anyone much good.
Let's start with the biggest decision. Do you need a traditional acoustic piano (an upright or grand), or will an electric/digital piano work?
An acoustic piano produces sound through strings and a soundboard, with hammers striking the strings when you press the keys. There is something very satisfying about the way an acoustic piano responds to your fingers, and the sound has a depth and character that even good digital instruments can find difficult to reproduce.
A good digital piano, on the other hand, can be an excellent choice for a student. It takes up less space, doesn't require regular tuning, and often comes with a headphone option, which can be a real blessing in a busy household. You can find very good digital pianos at a range of prices without having to invest in an acoustic instrument.
Neither option is automatically right for everyone. Your budget, available space, neighbors, and the kind of music you want to play all come into the picture. What matters is choosing an instrument that will allow the student to develop good habits and enjoy playing.
Three Things I Want You to Pay Attention To
When shopping for a piano, there are three things I consider particularly important: the number of keys, the feel of the keys, and the quality of the sound.
1. Get 88 Keys If You Can
A full-size piano has 88 keys, and that's what I recommend for anyone planning to study piano seriously. Smaller keyboards with 61 or 76 keys can be perfectly fine for exploring music or getting started, but students will eventually encounter pieces that require a larger range.
There is nothing more frustrating than getting to a piece in a lesson and discovering that your home keyboard doesn't have enough keys to play it! If you are buying a new instrument, I would skip the smaller keyboards and go straight to 88 keys if your budget and space allow.
2. Weighted Keys Really Matter
This is a big one, particularly if you are purchasing a digital piano. Traditional acoustic piano keys have weight and resistance because they operate a mechanical action that moves the hammers to strike the strings. A digital piano with weighted, hammer-action keys is designed to recreate some of that feeling.
Why does this matter? Learning to play piano involves developing finger control, strength, and the ability to produce different volumes. On an inexpensive keyboard with very light, springy keys, the experience is quite different from playing a traditional piano. A student who practices exclusively on those keys may have difficulty adjusting when sitting down at an acoustic piano.
Look for an 88-key digital piano with fully weighted, hammer-action keys and touch sensitivity. Touch sensitivity means that playing a key harder produces a louder sound, while playing it gently produces a softer one. These features help students develop the technique and musical expression they need as they progress.
And one more thing: your digital piano MUST have a solid, stable stand. I cannot emphasize this enough! Those inexpensive X-shaped or crossbar keyboard stands that wobble when you play are not suitable for a permanent practice setup. The instrument should not rock, sway, or shift when your child plays. Invest in a proper furniture-style stand or another heavy-duty support designed for your instrument. A wobbly piano is distracting, uncomfortable, and simply not a good foundation for learning.
This may seem obvious, but a piano should sound pleasant to your ears. Some inexpensive keyboards have a rather thin, artificial sound that can make playing less enjoyable. A good piano tone should have some warmth and depth, and it should be pleasant enough that you actually want to hear it every day.
Sound quality also matters because students are learning to listen. They need to recognize differences in volume, tone, and musical expression. If the instrument sounds unpleasant or doesn't respond well to changes in touch, it takes away some of the enjoyment of learning music.
If possible, try the instrument before buying it. Play some notes softly, then more loudly. Listen to the sound across the keyboard, not just in the middle. You don't need to be an experienced pianist to notice whether you like what you hear!
You might be surprised by how many features are advertised on inexpensive keyboards. Hundreds of instrument sounds, built-in rhythms, recording functions, flashing lights, and all sorts of electronic extras can make a keyboard look impressive.
But if the goal is to learn piano, most of those features aren't particularly important. I'd much rather see you spend your money on good weighted keys and a pleasant piano sound than on a keyboard that can imitate 200 different instruments but doesn't feel like a piano.
A sustain pedal is also important. It allows students to develop proper pedaling technique as they progress, so make sure your digital piano has one or can accommodate a suitable pedal.
What If I Already Have a Keyboard?
Please don't rush out and buy a new piano just because your child is starting lessons! If you already own a keyboard, tell your teacher what you have. The number of keys, whether they are weighted, and whether the instrument has touch sensitivity will help determine whether it is suitable for your student's current level.
For a complete beginner, an existing keyboard may be perfectly adequate for getting started. If your child enjoys lessons and is making progress, you can discuss upgrading when the time comes. I would rather see a family wait and make a sensible purchase than spend a lot of money before knowing whether piano is going to become a lasting interest.
The same applies to adults. If you have a 61-key keyboard sitting in a closet, bring it out and get started! You can always upgrade later.
What About Buying a Used Piano?
A used acoustic piano can be a wonderful investment, but please don't buy one simply because it looks pretty or because someone is giving it away.
Pianos are complicated instruments with thousands of moving parts. An older piano may look perfectly fine on the outside but have mechanical problems, poor tuning stability, or worn-out parts that can be expensive to repair. Before purchasing a used acoustic piano, have a qualified piano technician inspect it and give you an idea of its condition and any repairs it may need.
A free piano isn't necessarily a bargain if it needs several thousand dollars in work!
Digital pianos are a little easier to evaluate, but you should still try them out if possible. Listen to the piano sound, play the keys throughout the keyboard, check that every key works properly, and make sure the stand and pedal are included or can be purchased separately.
So, What Do I Actually Recommend?
If you're starting piano lessons and buying an instrument for the first time, here's my general advice:
Best overall: A well-maintained acoustic upright or grand piano.
Best digital option: An 88-key digital piano with weighted, hammer-action keys, touch sensitivity, a sustain pedal, and a solid, non-wobbling stand.
Temporary starting point: A smaller keyboard can help someone explore music, but it isn't an ideal long-term instrument for studying piano.
You don't need the most expensive model or the fanciest brand. You need an instrument that feels good to play, sounds good to your ears, and makes you want to come back to it tomorrow.
I have seen students make wonderful progress on modest instruments, and I've also seen beautiful, expensive pianos that barely get touched. The instrument matters, of course, but it isn't the only thing that determines whether a student succeeds.
If your child comes home from school, walks over to the piano, and starts playing without being reminded, you've already won half the battle. If you're an adult who finds yourself sitting down at the piano simply because you enjoy it, that's exactly what we're looking for, too.
The best piano isn't necessarily the most expensive one. It's the one that makes you want to play!
Once you've chosen your instrument, there's one more important step: creating a comfortable place to practice. Read my companion article: Creating a Piano Practice Space That Works.