- Digital Footprint & Digital Permanence
From what companies extract from our data to what we post online throughout our lives, the permanence of a person's "digital footprint" can be lost on even the most information literate of us, so to expect children to comprehend this is pretty crazy.
We have a duty to help students protect their identity and the identity of others online, or our digital reputations while also not using scare tactics to fear technology.
Having a digital reputation is good and there are positive ways to cultivate one, such as:
Photos and videos of people being active in sports, their community, and school;
Positive public comments that add to a discussion or support a friend or business;
Hobbies, artwork, projects, and more
But, there are also things that can darken your digital reputation:
Photos and videos that can be seen as silly now, but could be embarrassing later;
Drugs, alcohol, or showing a party lifestyle;
References to illegal activity;
Negative, hateful, or trolling comments;
Personal information or photos taken of you without consent.
Cyberbullying
What many people don't think about is the permanence of our online activity. Many children, especially adolescents, simply cannot think about future consequences. The Merck Manual notes that risky or non-reflective behaviour stem from neurological development as the areas of the brain that control emotions change and mature during adolescence, resulting in lack of impulse control and emotional turbulence (Merk, 2019).
If we our information banks, our digital footprint is our credit report. We can't shake something we did 20 years ago just as a blip on our credit score still shows up after several decades. Young people don't have the life experience to understand this "forever"-ness.
Many students believe apps like TikTok, SnapChat, & Instagram, which allow for quick stories to appear for a time and then disappear, mean they are protected from digital permanence. This is wholly false. Research has shown that "deleted" photos posted on these types of sites "are just as deleted as any other file" (Techcrunch, 2013).
The Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada highlighted "Reputation and Privacy" as a strategic priority and proposed de-indexing and source takedown as solutions. De-indexing "is the process by which a webpage, image or other online resource is removed from search engine results when an individual’s name is entered as the search term" and source takedown "is the removal of the content from the internet" (OPC, 2018) stating,
"[We] will have helped to create an environment where individuals may use the Internet to explore their interests and develop as persons without fear that their digital trace will lead to unfair treatment" (OPC, 2018)
This is not a one-time lesson, but necessary to repeatedly remind students to consider consequences before posting. This includes future:
Cyberbullying is a huge issue young people face, but being mean online is also a big issue that doesn't get enough attention. Being uncharacteristically mean, or simply showing a version of yourself that doesn't exist in "real" life, is called Online Disinhibition.
Since it's harder to empathize with people we can't see, we all experience some Online Disinhibition. Adolescents, however, often experience this effect more intensely due to their developing minds and emotions (Common Sense Media, 2019).
There are two notable types of Online Disinhibition - toxic and benign. Toxic disinhibition is a tendency to act meaner, say cruel things, or become unnecessarily hostile. Benign disinhibition allows people to open up more, connect better, and can sometimes create a more positive experience online (Common Sense Media, 2019).
Online Disinhibition affects us all, but there are ways we can counter it and improve our digital experience and awareness.
Research is pretty clear on what parents and teachers need to do to making digital citizenship a firm place in students' lives.
Create deeper learning experiences by connecting students interests to the subject matter. A student is more likely to have passion for his or her learning when they're learning about something that actually interests them, so connecting the topic of digital citizenship to something they choose.
Neither deeper learning nor information literacy, however, fit into a traditional teaching model, so to promote deeper learning, researchers suggest education shift from teaching static content to focus on the learning process as a whole, allowing students to develop their own abilities and take charge of their own learning (Loertscher & Wools, 2012; Ontario, 2016).
The ultimate goal of this active learning is not only to promote deeper learning experiences, but to also encourage meaningful connections between students and learning.
Start the research process young. Having kids begin critically evaluating what they are reading, hearing, and saying. This online allows them to begin the process of transferring the skill to thinking critically about their own decisions.
Common Sense Media makes a careful observation. "As young people and adults navigate the digital world, they increasingly face dilemmas and sticky situations that lack clear-cut right or wrong answers, such as
How much communication is too much?
What is the boundary between being authentic, oversharing, privacy, and dishonesty ?
"If someone posts an offensive comment on social media, should I leverage the technology at my fingertips to call them out publicly, even if it might damage my reputation?" (Common Sense Media, 2019)
Don't just cultivate skills . . . cultivate disposition. Common Sense Media, the industry leader in digital and information literacy curriculum, have completed extensive research on implementing a holistic curriculum. In their updated research, they note,
As educators, we often focus on the skills students need to learn but less on fostering the dispositions necessary to actually enact those skills. Dispositions guide students' thoughts and behaviors as they go about their lives. (Common Sense Media, 2019)
We can best support youth dispositions - and our own - when we:
Are aware that learners are still developing the emotional and cognitive skills necessary to place critical thinking over impulse;
Allow learners active participation in their learning by supporting inquiry-based learning with critical assessments of images and other forms of information;
Reframe learning to involve "rings of responsibility," ensuring learners consider their "personal well-being alongside broader moral, ethical, and civic considerations" (Common Sense Media, 2019
Common Sense Media (2019) recommends five core dispositions with supporting steps. These include:
Take a breath and step away.
Check your gut reaction.
Name your reaction and emotions - anger. embarrassment. sadness.
Remember to reflect, don't react.
Consider other points of view.
Try to empathize - put yourself in the other person's place
What are they feeling?
What are they thinking?
What is your responsibility in this situation?
Look for facts.
What are the events you know of that have already happened?
What about what you don't know?
Find more facts from different sources.
Ask friends, family, etc., if needed
What could you do?
What should you do?
What are the possible consequences?
Consider how choices reflect on you as a person.
Decide what to do.
THINK about your actions. Are they:
True
Helpful
Inspiring
Necessary
Kind
Remember: You alone must decide what feels positive and productive.
Ask for help.
Be an ally for others.
Just because we're adults doesn't mean we have this all figured out. It's okay to not have the answers . . . but our students don't have all the questions, either. There are things they experience that we will never know or understand and the best ways to empower ourselves and our students is to:
Open Dialogue - Get kids talking. Have them generate meaningful discussions about things happening in their life - online and offline. Pose questions:
How does it feel when . . .
What are the consequences of . . .
What would you do if . . .
What do you believe is right when . . .
Authentic Activities - Have students explore different scenarios through text, video, and audio and reflect. Can they relate? Can they empathize? Can they challenge themselves to do better or think differently?
Engagement - Incorporate videos and games. Let kids do some of the teaching. Flip the learning. Experiment. Test. Embrace failure. Embrace and practice digital mindfulness.
Integration - The only way learners are going to fully understand digital and information literacy is daily practice, which means integration into daily learning activities.