Since at least the time of Socrates, educators have understood the value of discussion in the classroom . What is there to do, though, when a class is entirely online, meaning the students are often in different locations, even different states or countries? One powerful tool in the online educator's arsenal is the online discussion board. Done correctly, online discussions can harness many of the same benefits Socrates himself enjoyed, without any unpleasant hemlock related side effects. Moreover, as Eric Brunsell notes, because of the way online message boards are set up, students benefit from more processing time in formulating responses than they would in a traditional classroom discussion, and this can have the effect of reducing student anxiety, You might find that students who never participate in class blossom when given the opportunity. This page will provide a quick overview of some best practice for using these tools, and at the end you'll find some additional resources if you want to dig deeper.
Not this kind of message board... Electronic Message Board courtesy of WAMB, image here
Not very high on Bloom's Taxonomy... Picture of note, image here
So the introduction has you hooked (not a surprise, it was quite clever), and you're ready to use a discussion board in your classroom. As an instructor, it's going to be your job to provide a solid framework for each discussion, which you will do by providing a good prompt. The question on the left isn't exactly high on Bloom's Taxonomy, and honestly, it's kind of sad, right? So what does make a good prompt? Here are some tips:
The purpose of class discussion is to enhance and expand upon what the students are learning in class, so it is important to align the questions with your standards and goals. Planning in advance helps a lot here.
There needs to be something for the students to discuss. Ideally, questions should be found higher up on Bloom's Taxonomy, forcing students to engage with the material and each other, deepening the learning.
It's important that students understand what they are being asked, and how they need to respond. Breaking the prompt up into clearly understood pieces can help with this.
Student dressed for "debate"
Anthony van Dyck - Portrait of a A Man in Armor image hereSo you've come up with a brilliant prompt... It's aligned perfectly with your course objectives, it's high on Bloom's Taxonomy , and it's so clear NASA contacted you about using it as the lens on their next space telescope. Now you need to make sure the discussion goes smoothly, and accomplishes all you had planned. Below are some ideas to help keep your students on track, engaged, and getting the most out of your activity:
Before the first post, you should have a clear rubric of how students will be graded, and share it with them. You should also explicitly instruct your students in proper "netiquette" (how they should behave in discussions), so they don't feel like the guy on the left. Let them know how, and how often, they should be responding. Use exemplars.
Make sure all your students know how to use the technology, and how to participate in a message board discussion. Provide an FAQ, a Frequently Asked Questions list which addresses common issues. Use regular announcements which can pre-empt questions as the course progresses.
As Cheryl Hayek relates in this blog post, your duties as facilitator are similar to the host at a dinner party. Welcome everyone. Make sure no one's dominating the conversation. Spread attention equally. Draw out shy "guests" with additional prompting. "Talk" enough to keep the conversation moving, but then step back and allow the "guests" to discuss.
In this voicethread, Dr. Jered Borup identifies some different examples of discussion prompts:
Here is what this might look like:
Above is a tweet from President Trump on November 21, 2018. Think about what we've learned so far in this unit, and write a post addressing the following:
1) What is the argument President Trump is making with this tweet?
2) What is your position on his argument? Explain.
Please make your initial post by Tuesday, December 4.
By Thursday, December 6, respond to the two posts above yours in the thread. Do you agree or disagree? Why? If you were the first person to post initially, please respond to the last two posts in the thread. If you were second, then respond to the one above yours and the last post in the thread.
By Sunday, December 9, respond to the people that have responded to you.
This video (embedded to the right) can be shown to students as an introduction for how to participate in message board activities