Dear Sisters and Friends,
I hope that this Justice Desk update finds you all well. This is the last Justice Desk update before the International Presentation Association 8th Assembly which will take place in late June in Newfoundland. During the Assembly I will report daily to all the Sisters and friends in IRELAND and ENGLAND. Again, as is always the case you only have to engage with that which catches your attention but we would be really delighted if you might share with those who do not have the gift of the internet. In this issue you will find some comment on;
ShamPalm - a stunt to highlight the Human Rights Abuses in poorer countries by staging an event in Dublin in early May. Click the button below for more.
At the end of May we invited the IPA Justice Contacts to come together for a final conversation around the three UN Conferences that have been held earlier this year. We came together to share our unique takes on the work given the context of where we live and work. There continues to be learning for all and you can find out a lot more by clicking the button below.
A satirical comic strip on the issue of homelessness in Ireland.
Citizen's Assembly calls for constitutional protection for our Biodiversity.
Ukraine, what the Global South thinks.
Save the DATE for #DouglasWeek in Cork.
Environmental Justice Zambia and the UK
Good news on Energy Consumption in Europe.
Take Aways on the UN CONFERENCES
Big companies and their deceptive GREENWASHING.
The Water Manifesto - what is it and why is it so important?
Smurfit Kappa, their business interests and their impact on local indigenous communities.
NJPN Conference in Swanwick in July Survival or Sustainability.
Coalition 2030 launched its report, 'Furthest Behind First, or Falling Behind Further? The human stories that challenge Ireland’s claims to be leaving no one behind' in Buswells Hotel, Dublin on Tuesday May 9th.
Meeting the 'Young Pressies' across Zoom for some discussion on Ireland and how we welcome the Ukrainian Refugees.
Meeting with young Social Work Students from Kansas with Sr. Concepta O' Brien.
Department of Rural and Community Development provided updates on departmental SDG progress to the Joint Oireachtas Committee.
News from the JPIC from the English Presentation Province.
We have been forwarded the following article from Sr. Kathleen Storan.
If you have a report, article, evetn, photo or comment then we would love to hear from you on presinterprovjustice@gmail.com
Regards
Brian
A satirical take on the current homelessness crisis in Ireland and also with a nod to the growing hostilty in the welcome for those who flee conflict or persecution or who have just come to Ireland in search of a better life. Irish Times.
Citizen's Assembly calls for constitutional protection for our Biodiversity.
Ireland's Progress on the SDGs with respect those perceived to be of greatest importance.
An important article offered to us by the National Justice and Peace Network in the UK
Click the dropdown to read the full article.
Ukraine: What the Global South Thinks
by Gwynne Dyer
There is a deep and growing rift between ‘the West’ and ‘the Rest’ about the need to resist and defeat the Russian invasion of Ukraine. This is because it is really a war in defence of sovereignty, which ought to be something every sovereign country can buy into – but Western governments publicly insist that it is a war in defence of democracy.
All the chatter about democracy goes down well in Europe and North America, but it reeks of hypocrisy elsewhere. Three centuries of imperialism and conspicuous Western failures to defend democracy in the recent past and present in Africa, the Middle East and Asia make these claims sound absurd to people in the developing world.
So Brazil’s President Luiz Inácio ‘Lula’ da Silva says in China two weeks ago that “the United States needs to stop encouraging war and start talking about peace” in Ukraine.
Russia’s foreign minister Sergei Lavrov, in Brazil a little later, says that “We are grateful to our Brazilian friends for their excellent understanding of this situation’s genesis.”
US National Security Council spokesman John Kirby accuses Lula of “parroting Russian and Chinese propaganda”, but from Indonesia to South Africa to Brazil you hear the same sort of talk.
Rather than join the embargo on trade with Russia, they buy Russian oil and gas at a big discount and make no distinction between the aggressor and the defender. There’s a lot of self-interest in this, but there is also a genuine incomprehension about why Western countries care so much about the invasion of Ukraine.
The West didn’t care a fig about Saudi Arabia’s decade-long military intervention in Yemen. Its only visible concern in war-torn Sudan is getting its own citizens out. Yet it pours money and arms into Ukraine even as soaring energy prices and crushing debt hit living standards and destabilise governments all across the developing world.
The ‘Global South’ sees only double standards and racism in this. Do the Ukrainians matter more because they are white Europeans? Good question.
The West hasn’t helped its case by claiming that its aid to Ukraine is part of a global struggle for democracy. That is not an argument that appeals to authoritarian regimes. They would be much more receptive to an argument based on sovereignty, so why do we hear so little about that?
Western governments stick to the ‘democracy in danger’ line because it resonates far better with their own domestic audiences than some abstract legal argument about defending the international law on the inviolability of borders. However, it’s Ukraine’s whole independent existence that’s at risk, not just its political system.
Russian president Vladimir Putin definitely doesn’t like democracy, and he has been very hostile when countries on Russian’s own borders have democratic revolutions. But the idea that he has embarked on some crusade to crush democracy – indeed, that his ambitions extend beyond the former borders of the old Soviet Union in any way – is simply ludicrous.
In practice, the Russian invasion of Ukraine is the heritage project gone wrong of an ageing dictator. Putin wanted to build a monument to himself by unifying the three countries that were known as ‘all the Russias’ under the Russian Empire (now Russia, Belarus and Ukraine).
They all speak Eastern Slavic languages, but so what? The Czech Republic, Poland and Slovakia all speak Western Slavic languages, but they are independent countries. Putin’s dream was a folly that could only be achieved by force – and it turned out that he didn’t have quite enough force, because the rest of Europe stood in the way.
The West’s countries didn’t come unanimously to Ukraine’s defence because they loved Ukrainians. They did so because Russia was breaking the sacred post-1945 rule on which the United Nations was founded: borders may no longer be changed by force. Conquest, hitherto the motor of most historical change, is henceforth illegal.
This revolutionary change was only accepted because nuclear weapons turned war into an apocalyptic, existential threat. It is taken most seriously in the developed countries, whose wars were already the most destructive, but it has also spared many countries in the Global South from cross-border wars that would have been inevitable under the old rules.
The new rules have been broken too, most notably in the US invasion of Iraq in 2003, but they have been respected over the past 77 years to an extent that would amaze our ancestors. That’s the real principle that Western countries see at stake in Ukraine: inviolable sovereignty, not ‘democracy’.
Would it be worth the West’s while to explain more clearly what its real bottom line is in Ukraine? No, probably not. Nobody in the developing countries would believe it, even though it happens to be true.
_________________________________
Gwynne Dyer’s new book is ‘The Shortest History of War’.
Save the DATE for #DouglassWeek in Cork.
CALL FOR CONTRIBUTIONS
Every year, #DouglassWeek commemorates historical figures such as Frederick Douglass and provides a forum to discuss contemporary issues such as identity, race and equal rights. We are excited to host #DW2023 in Rochester, NY, where Douglass lived with his family for over 25 years. We would love for you to join us in July in Rochester and online, and we invite you to share your ideas and inspiration as a participant.
Wondering how to become part of #DW2023?
Develop an idea about a project, presentation, or panel!
Visit www.douglassweek.org
Submit your project idea via our online form
Contact us with questions and to plan the event
Become part of the #DW2023 program!
Our program will come out in June!
If you have any questions, suggestions or ideas, as always, email us and check out our website at www.douglassweek.org!
Environmental Justice in Zambia and the UK
from Edmund Rice International Carbon Rangers Newlsetter
Court Victory in the UK for Zambia. Alarmed by the pollution produced by the Konkola Copper Mines operation in the Copperbelt Province of Zambia, Chilekwa Mumba organized a lawsuit to hold the mine’s parent company, Vedanta Resources, responsible. Chilekwa’s victory in the UK Supreme Court set a legal precedent—it was the first time an English court ruled that a British company could be held liable for the environmental damage caused by subsidiary-run operations in another country. This precedent has since been applied to hold Shell Global—one of the world’s 10 largest corporations by revenue—liable for its pollution in Nigeria.
Copper Revenue Significant. Zambia is one of the largest producers and exporters of copper in Africa. Some 77% of the country’s exports come from the mining industry and 25% of government revenue is from mining royalties and taxes. The Konkola Copper Mines (KCM) is one of the largest mining operations in Zambia and the country’s single largest employer.
Open Pit Mine 7 Miles Long. KCM’s Nchanga copper mine is located just outside of Chingola city limits in the Copperbelt Province, with an operation that spans 11 square miles along the Kafue River. The mine complex includes an open-pit mine, underground mines, a smelter, a sulfuric acid plant, a tailings leach plant, and a refinery. The open-pit mine—the second largest in the world—is seven miles long. READ MORE
Good News ON ENERGY CONSUMPTION in Europe
And in respect of the most recent UN Conferences...
The Water Manifesto - what is it and why is it so important?
We were prompted to lobby on the issue of Smurfit Kappa (recently taken from the IT) by Sr. Maureen O' Connell PBVM South West.
I have been asked to open the National Justice and Peace Network conference in Swanwick on the Friday, and I will also be offering two workshops on the Saturday whilst trying to gather the discerned thoughts on the Sunday.
Coalition 2030 launched its report, 'Furthest Behind First, or Falling Behind Further? The human stories that challenge Ireland’s claims to be leaving no one behind' in Buswells Hotel, Dublin on Tuesday May 9th at 12pm.
This report was developed in recent months via consultation with the 70 Coalition 2030 members including the Presentation Justice Desk. The resulting document makes an emotive case for reaching the furthest behind first so that no one is left behind, and is a clarion call for increased action, ambition and leadership on reaching the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in Ireland.
The event was moderated by political commentator and journalist, Alison O'Connor.
On the panel was:
Mary Collins, Traveller Community Health Work (Primary Care), Pavee Point
Belinda Nugent, Community Development Project Leader, ICON (Inner City Organisations Network)
Susanne Rogers, Research And Policy Analyst, Social Justice Ireland
Dr. Salome Mbugua, CEO, AkiDwA
John Doyle, Service user at RehabCare Limerick West
John-Mark McCafferty, CEO, Threshold
See below:
The Government must appoint a Future Generations Commissioner to ensure no public policy actions undermine the quality of life of future generations. That’s according to Coalition 2030, which launched a report, ‘Furthest Behind First, or Falling Behind Further?’, documenting Ireland’s progress on the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) from the perspective of those ‘left behind’. The report parallels Ireland’s own SDG Review, due for presentation to the UN in July.
The Coalition, of over 70 organisations, is also calling for responsibility for the SDGs to be moved from the Department of Environment, Climate and Communications to the Department of the Taoiseach; for all new public policies to be SDG-proofed to ensure they are aligned with the Goals; and for the annual Budget process to become linked to progressing the SDGs.
Commenting at the report launch, Louise Finan, Chair of Coalition 2030, said: “Too often, important decisions are taken without due regard for the implications for future generations. But the challenges the world and Ireland face defy quick solutions within a single budget or electoral cycle. We have seen this, for example, with the housing crisis. Complex challenges demand responses that span decades.
“We urge the Government to acknowledge this by establishing a Future Generations Commissioner on a statutory footing. The Welsh Government has demonstrated international leadership by creating such a post for their own jurisdiction.”
Ms. Finan also called for responsibility for progressing the SDGs to be centralised within the Taoiseach’s Department. “In order to demonstrate the political ambition required to achieve the SDGs, we believe responsibility for their oversight and implementation must lie with the Department of the Taoiseach,” she said. “We also want to see the Goals hardwired into the annual Budget process. To date, the SDGs have never meaningfully featured, but we are facing a windfall Budget again this year, so there is a real opportunity for the Government to move beyond lip service and ensure that the financial choices and investments we make are made with those who are furthest behind in mind.
“The SDGs provide us with a powerful blueprint and pathway to create a fairer, more environmentally sustainable Ireland, where everyone has access to quality healthcare, quality education, quality housing and does not fear a life lived in poverty. Alignment with the SDGs should be the driving objective of State policy from this point forward. We are calling on the Government and the Opposition to ensure that the Goals are embedded in all new national policies, in local authorities’ city and county plans, and in the work of community-based structures such as Public Participation Networks, Local Environmental Networks, and Education and Training Boards.”
The report published by Coalition 2030 features the real-life stories of people in Ireland who, according to the Coalition, are being “left behind” as the country continues to develop. These include disabled people; current and former residents of the Direct Provision system; people experiencing poverty and homelessness; lone parents; and older people.
Commenting at the report’s launch, its author, Sorley McCaughey, said: “An underlying principle of the SDGs is to ‘reach the furthest behind first’. But the case studies featured in our report show there are many people in Ireland being left even further behind as the country develops.
“The worsening of poverty rates, the destruction of the biosphere, or the continued marginalisation of certain groups is clearly never the intention of policymakers. However, these are outcomes more likely to occur when policy decisions are not guided by human rights principles and aligned with the SDGs.
“With a General Election to be held by March 2025, and the Goals due to expire in 2030, now is a critical juncture for the Government and opposition parties to put the necessary measures in place to help Ireland play its role in progressing the SDGs and leaving no-one behind.”
At the launch, Coalition 2030 praised the Government for the international leadership it has shown on the SDGs but called for similar action and ambition to be demonstrated at home.
“Few countries can claim to have been as influential on the SDGs on the global stage as Ireland”, said Dearbháil Lawless, CEO of AONTAS and a member of the Steering Committee of Coalition 2030. “Under Irish and Kenyan leadership, the Goals were painstakingly negotiated before being agreed by the United Nations General Assembly in 2015. Since then, the Government has been a vocal advocate for the SDGs. This summer, Ireland and Qatar will lead a series of high-level discussions in advance of presenting a political declaration at the SDGs Summit in September.
“However, Ireland's international commitment to the SDGs is not matched by the same ambition at home. We remain the only country in western Europe without universal primary healthcare. Our ongoing housing crisis is forcing families into homelessness and creating enormous collective anxiety and stress. Our employment rate for people with disabilities is one of the lowest in the EU. Our Direct Provision system violates multiple human rights. And the State is yet to live up to a long-standing promise to contribute 0.7% of Gross National Income to overseas aid.
“Our failings at domestic level run the risk of undermining Ireland's moral leadership on the SDGs while also contributing to sections of Irish society falling further behind. In the lead-up to the UN Summit this September, the Government has an opportunity to demonstrate real commitment to the SDGs by making policy choices at home that align with their international rhetoric.”
Headline asks from the our Shadow Voluntary National Review as put together with the help of the members of Coalition 2030.
The report below highlights 5 key actions which could accelerate Ireland’s achievement of the SDGs and ensure that Ireland reaches the Furthest Behind in all its policies. 1. Lead from the Top: Move the SDG Unit from the Department of Environment, Climate and Communication, to the Department of the Taoiseach who should have overall responsibility for SDG oversight and implementation. 2. Budget for the SDGs: the SDGs should be hardwired into the planning and budgetary processes across the State, an important political signal in itself, and one that allows for more effective monitoring of progress towards the Goals. 3. SDG-Proof Policy: Coalition 2030 recommends that all future financial and policy commitments in Ireland include mandatory SDG conditions to ensure progress across all sectors of Irish society and enable policy coherence for Sustainable Development. 4. Measure What Matters: Identifying inequalities and discrimination requires evidence and data collection and disaggregation beyond gender, geography and age. It must include all grounds of discrimination prohibited under international law, ensuring that areas and root causes of inequalities are identified and addressed. 5. Establish a Future Generations Commissioner: We call on the State to be visionary and to think beyond the usual 3 to 5-year political cycle. The launch took place at a pivotal moment for Ireland with regard to the SDGs. In July, Ireland will present its SDG progress to the UN for the first time in five years. Ireland has the key role of co-facilitating the Political Declaration for the SDGs, to be unveiled at the SDG Summit in New York in September, which the UN Secretary-General has called the "central event of 2023."
Meeting the Young Pressies across Zoom for some discussion on Ireland and how we welcome the Ukrainian Refugees.
In mid-May I had was invited by Gemma Thomson from Australia to address the "Young Pressies" group who gave up their lunch break to hear how Ireland as a country have been working to ensure a proper welcome for women and children who have come to Ireland as refugees fleeing the war in Ukraine. We also alerted all to the Presentation response to this felt need by explaining how a previoulsy used convent was offered to 55 of the first arrivals in Fethard. I also offered Gemma a recently published article that appeared in Global Sisters Report that gave an account of the contribution that our Sisters in Slovakia have made to those who flee war and cross the border into Slovakia for their support. More HERE
In early May at the invitation of Sr. Concepta I met with a group majoring in Social Work from Kansas that were being hosted by Sr. Concepta on foot of a letter that she received some of which I include below by way of explantion. I spoke to the group along with Sr. Imelda Wickham on New Directions and Brian Fitzsimons on iScoil.
Sr. Concepta,
My name is Trisha Waldman and I am a cojourner (associate) with the Presentation Sisters in Aberdeen, South Dakota. I taught at Presentation College in Aberdeen for 14 years before moving to Leavenworth, Kansas and taking a job at the University of Saint Mary (sponsored by the Sisters of Charity – Leavenworth) last year. I am currently co-teaching an International Social Work class that will be taking a trip to Dublin May 9 – 18. A focus of the course is understanding other cultures, identifying and assisting with needs within the community, ministries that exist serving these populations, etc. I would love to bring the students to visit the Presentation Sisters while in Dublin, hear about your ministries/history of Nano. The spirit of Nano is definitely in line with the mission of this course, and I think would be great to share with the students. There are 13 students, plus myself and another faculty for a total of 15 individuals. I greatly appreciate your help and am excited to share the Sisters’ mission with our students in Kansas! Please let me know how you’d like to best proceed.Thank you again! Trisha
Check throught the gallery below.
Departmental SDG Progress.
On Wednesday 1st March at 9:30am officials from the Department of Social Protection and the Department of Rural and Community Development provided updates on departmental SDG progress to the Joint Oireachtas Committee on Social Protection, Community and Rural Development and the Islands.
Coalition 2030 made a submission, see below. We were given an extremely tight time-frame (2 days). However note that the submission is not saying anything new, it collates information from already agreed documents such as the letters sent to Oireachtas members in 2022 (see attached letter to Committee Chair Denis Naughten Nov 2022).
There was some advocacy to Committee members to ensure they are up to speed with our key asks.
Sr. Jacinta from England forwarded News from the JPIC Commission in England.
Media report with respect to the Coalition 2030 Shadow Voluntary National Review.
Media Reporting on Coalition 2030 Shadow Voluntary National Report on Ireland's implementation of the Sustainable Development Goals at home and abroad.
We have been forwarded the following article from Sr. Kathleen Storan.
More HERE