Introduction
Robel Anshebo
The idea of death is always a difficult subject. Even more so, many of us struggle to conceptualize our enventual passing and fail to place our priorities in order before then. In this discussion we'll cover the concept of an ideal death or passage. We'll also consider the special case of Helga and her family's wish to continue her on life support against the care team's wish to withdraw it.
Megan Blake:
How would you define a Good Death?
For me personally, a good death would be quick, painless, and surronded by those that I love. I would not want to suffer or have a prolonged death that is seemingly never ending. To be surronded by those that I love would be preferred over dying alone, as it would allow for a final goodbye, a way to ensure closure.
If I were in Helga's shoes?
I would personally not want to be left on Life-support for an extended period time. Having personalyl worked with patients who are being kept alive by ventilators, I have seen the toll that prolonged life has on a person's body. The inevitable bedsores, the breakdown of skin from incontinence, and the lack of quality of life. I would want my family to be present when life support is withdrawn in order for them to say goodbye and allow them the oppurtunity to process what has happened. My Ikigai would be to live a qulaity life over extending the qusntity of life.
Beverly Sumanti
How would you define a “good death?” For me I would like to live to be over a hundred years old. At my death, I would want to be surrounded by loved ones at home. I would like to know that I have succeeded in fulfilling my lifelong goals.
If you were the Helga, what would be an ideal situation for you? If I were Helga, I would want to die a death with dignity. I would have completed a POLST form, and explained what type of medical care I would want in that specific situation. I would want to be removed from life support and to be given medication to assist with comfort. I would want to be surrounded by loved ones in a supportive environment. From my ‘ikigai' perspective, I would not desire to live in a completely dependent existence.
Robel Anshebo
Q1: How would you define a good death? What would be the ideal scenario for you.
I think the ideal death varies between each individual. Many people would have an ideal way of passing over that is based on their religion, culture, experiences, and goals. It's difficult to creat an ideal scenario because I don't share the same perspective or situation as an older individual. I would consider several different criteria when determining a good death. This includes being in a painless state, settling financial decisions for my family, and being surrounded by loved ones.
Q2: If you were Helga, what would be an ideal situation for you?
I would like to experience an expected death when the time comes. Even If I find myself in Helga's situation, my family could still experience my expected passing by refusing life support. I think this would also allow them to grieve appropriately and save them from the financial strain of maintaining life support.
Sherwin Afable
I would consider a good death to be peaceful and without regret nor pain. I believe that most people’s preference would be to die at home but that is not a luxury most are afforded. If I were given a terminal diagnosis I would want to have a living wake for myself so that I could surround myself with all of my loved ones a final time. Afterwards, I would probably want more individual time spent with people as well as time by myself to reflect on the life I lived. I’m undecided if I would want to have others in the room when I take my last breath. I probably wouldn’t notice they were around but the thought of having someone present is comforting, yet I wouldn’t want to traumatize them with seeing my death happen in real time.
Helga’s story is another reminder that “Everyone knows they’re going to die, but nobody believes it.” I would never fault the family of a patient in PVS to want to keep their family member alive. I believe that hope is a powerful thing in illness and wanting to keep someone alive in that condition is meant to be an act of love for the people you love, as if to let them know you’re doing the most that you can for them in an otherwise helpless state. Helga’s story also reminds us of the importance of having an advanced directive or polst form filled out prior to any kind of incapacitation. It’s impossible to know what the personal experience of being in that state is like. Medical science would tell you that the absence of brain activity is already a form of death. All things considered, I lean towards preferring to be removed from life support in those situations.
Conclusion
Robel Anshebo
Death awaits us all whether we like it or not. We often failt to recognize our mortality and carry on with our daily lives without thinking about how we'd like to pass on from this life. This can be problematic for our loved ones who may be forced to pick up the pieces of our unpreparedeness. Many of us have commonalities in our idea of an ideal death. This concept commonly includes settling advance directives and being surrounded by loved ones as discussed above. The case of Helga has highlighed the importance of thinking ahead and preparing now.