At the end of the special project, I should be able to:
Develop Chapters 1-5 through evidence based content;
Develop an ePortfolio containing my results, process, and reflection;
Apply knowledge of research and analysis in the educational context;
Critically reflect on my experiences and evolving philosophy of education;
Defend the ePortfolio to the panelists; and
Acquire desirable professional work attitude and skills.
This is the initial project plan, aligned with the identified need to conduct a research study, focusing on the gap presented by the absence of a formal curriculum.
These approaches, strategies, and methodologies were used to develop the research project.
Collapse each section to reveal the description.
Qualitative Research Approach
Focused on understanding experiences and gaining in-depth insights rather than testing hypotheses. It is aligned to the research aim of exploring the individual challenges and coping strategies in a specific context.
Phenomenological Design
This aims to identify and describe the essence of a lived phenomenon, without the researchers' assumptions regarding the phenomenon (Delve & Limpaecher, 2022).
Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis (IPA)
This is considered a methodological approach and an analytical method, which is rooted from phenomenology. In this approach, instead of simply determining the lived experiences of the participants, the researcher will provide interpretations on the responses, while developing codes, themes, and patterns (Delve & Limpaecher, 2022).
Purposive Sampling
This is the intentional selection of specific individuals as participants of the study, relative to the research questions and phenomena (Golzar et al., 2024).
Participant Observation
This is a research method wherein the researcher is involved in the participant setting while observing their interactions, behaviors, and practices (George, 2023), while ensuring minimal interference.
Semi-Structured Interviews
The researcher prepared the interview questions in advance to help direct the discussion while allowing for improvisation and flexibility (“The Essential Guide to Coding Qualitative Data,” 2024).
Triangulation through CIPP Evaluation Tool
This is a framework by Stufflebeam in 1983, which is used to evaluate a curriculum, program, or an environment, focusing on the institution’s context, input, process, and product (Aziz et al. 2018). This study evaluated ABC's program to determine whether it is appropriate for the students of today's generation, which was used to support the main interpretation of this study (see Appendix H).
These theories were used to analyze and interpret the data of this study.
Collapse each section to reveal the description.
Curriculum Theory
It is believed to be the set of analysis, interpretation, and understanding of what and how to teach (McCutcheon, 1982 as cited in Aslan & Yaşar, 2021, p.240). Curriculum theory and practice describe curriculum as a continuous process that involves planning, acting, and evaluating as it is transmitted and attempting to achieve outcomes (Smith, 2000), emphasizing its significance. Hence, without a curriculum, a school is not organized and has no clear set of goals to achieve, making learning less appropriate and less effective for the learners.
Role Strain Theory
According to William Goode (1960, as cited in Nickerson, 2023) this theory describes how an individual may experience strain when they cannot meet their roles’ demands. It often occurs when individuals have multiple roles, unclear expectations, insufficient support or resources, and overlapping responsibilities, causing a decline in performance to fulfill their roles (Nickerson, 2023). In the context of this study, the absence of a formal curriculum contributes to such role strain. Teachers are expected to deliver quality education and promote student development, yet they lack a structured framework to guide their efforts. This uncertainty and added workload can lead to stress, inconsistencies in instruction, and reduced professional satisfaction, making role strain a relevant and insightful framework for understanding the challenges they face.
Constructivist Learning Theory
This theory was mostly established by Dewey, Piaget, Vygotsky, Gagne, and Bruner (Kurt, 2021). This theory highlights learner-centered, experience-based, hands-on, and exploratory learning approaches (Kurt, 2021). This theory states that learners are active as they reflect on previous experiences and construct new knowledge (Kurt, 2021). This approach is essential to support children’s cognitive, emotional, and social development. However, the absence of a formal curriculum can hinder teachers from fully applying constructivist principles. Without a structured framework, it becomes challenging to ensure that classroom activities are developmentally appropriate, scaffolded effectively, and aligned with long-term learning outcomes. As a result, teachers must independently interpret and apply constructivist approaches, often without the necessary guidance or support, adding to their professional burden and potentially impacting the quality of early education provided.
Transactional Model of Stress and Coping
This theory, by Lazarus and Folkman (1984 as cited in Chowdhurry, 2019), posists that individuals use both cognitive and behavioral efforts to manage specific internal or external demands that are perceived as tiring or exceeding their resources. According to this model, coping is not a one-size-fits-all response; individuals may adopt different coping strategies even when facing similar problems. For example, when not provided with teaching materials, one teacher may choose to create visual aids like flashcards, while another may rely on oral discussions to deliver content. These differing responses illustrate the personal and contextual nature of coping. In this study, it is therefore significant to investigate the range of coping strategies employed by teachers, as this will reveal how the challenges impact their teaching methods and whether their strategies are sustainable or effective in the long term. Furthermore, understanding these coping strategies can inform the development of more standardized policies, curriculum frameworks, or institutional supports that better meet the needs of teachers in similar contexts.
Hermeneutics (Theory of Interpretation)
This theory is grounded from the philosophical traditions of IPA. It was majorly influenced by Schleiermacher, Heidegger, and Gadamer (Charlick et al., 2016). Schleiermacher (1998) believed that interpretation involves two aspects: grammatical (i.e., focused on the literal text) and psychological (i.e., focused on the individual or deeper meaning behind the text). On the other hand, Heidegger (1962) highlighted how interpretation is linked to the making of meaning from lived experiences. In IPA, this reflects the idea that a phenomenon may be described but understood and uncovered by the researcher (Smith et al., 2009 as cited in Charlick et al., 2016), especially since Heidegger believed that interpretation is shaped by the researcher’s preconceptions, which requires reflection. Additionally, Gadamer (1990) further suggested that in interpreting, ‘meaning’ is co-constructed by the researcher and the participant, and a phenomenon can have multiple conceptions (Charlick et al., 2016).
Idiography
This is also grounded from the philosophical traditions of IPA. It operates at two levels: (1) thorough and systematic depth of analysis; and (2) the understanding of how an experiential phenomenon is interpreted from the perspective of particular people (Smith et al., 2009 as cited in Charlick et al., 2016). Idiography supports the concept of this research since it focuses on collecting the lived experiences of each participant. Instead of focusing on the general realizations, it focuses on the detailed and unique story of the particular participant. Specific and meaningful data of every participant in this research will be determined through the application of hermeneutics and idiography, which will significantly contribute to the shared understanding of all participants.
These concepts were discussed in the reflection part of this ePortfolio.
Conceptions of Curriculum
Academic Rationalist - Curriculum developers focus on academic subjects using a teacher-centered approach and traditional evaluation methods (Arsad, 2016).
Humanistic - Curriculum developers focus on how learners independently reach their full potential using experiential learning and other active approaches, as well as lenient qualitative evaluation methods (Arsad, 2016).
Process of Curriculum
Planned Curriculum - usually prepared by school or other authorities (Arsad, 2016)
Implemented Curriculum - curriculum put into practice, which can be modified (Arsad, 2016)
Achieved Curriculum - how the learner made sense of the planned and implemented curriculum (Arsad, 2016)
Cone of Experience
Visual analogy of how much people remember depending on their experience in learning (Cloke, 2023).
Piaget's 4 Stages of Development
Preoperational Stage - Second stage of development for children aged 2-7 years old, wherein they start improving language and thinking but struggles to use logic (Chery, 2024).
Upon visiting the locale, the researcher determined an interesting institutional gap, which is the absence of a formal curriculum in the kindergarten (ABC). Hence, further research has been done and literature review shows that there are limited studies on formal institutions with no formal curricula, which is a significant research gap, causing the teachers to face challenges as they need to independently design and implement instruction without a guide, while ensuring the effectiveness of learning. Additionally, many studies focus on the evaluation of a curriculum and its implementation, while there are fewer studies that highlight the perspectives or lived experiences of teachers. Moreover, literature states that the latter would provide significant information on curriculum development since teachers have unique knowledge and experiences, making them determine what curriculum developers do not see. Therefore, the author has decided for this research to focus on the challenges and coping strategies of teachers at ABC, operating without a formal curriculum (refer to the research paper, specifically the chapter 2 or the literature review).
I, the researcher, have decided to focus on the absence of a formal curriculum since as a BES student, the course EDUC 103: Principles & Processes in Curriculum Development taught me that having a curriculum is significant because it is a guide on what, how, and when to teach, as well as the impact of teaching (Print, 1993). It is an ongoing process of planning the learning experiences, implementing with modifications to align to the learners, and achieving in different ways (Arsad, 2016). Therefore, I imagined the system of a kindergarten without a formal curriculum and how the stakeholders are affected, leading to a research project that determines the lived experiences of teachers at ABC.
To focus on the lived experiences of the teachers at ABC, I utilized a phenomenology design as a descriptive, qualitative study. Under the latter design, the IPA methodology was used to interpret or make sense of the teachers' lived experiences, which was planned to be collected through semi-structured interviews and observation. Additionally, the analysis was supported by the ABC's program evaluation using the CIPP evaluation model, to provide a richer interpretation. These are inspired from the course EDS 195: Introduction to Education Research and EDS 196: Education Research Methods, which helped the researcher develop her research project plan.
These are the research questions that guided the researcher in developing the study:
1. What are the perceptions, experiences, and challenges faced by teachers in a kindergarten without a formal curriculum guide?
2. What are the kindergarten teachers' coping strategies to adapt to the absence of a formal curriculum, including the resources they use?
3. How do these challenges affect their teaching strategies and classroom management?
4. Is having a formal curriculum significant in teaching kindergarten at ABC?
This e-Portfolio is submitted in partial fulfillment of the capstone requirements for the degree of Bachelor of Education Studies.
Presented to the Faculty of Education at the University of the Philippines Open University, Los Baños, Laguna.
EDS 199: Special Project 2T-3T-24-25 | jfto@up.edu.ph | 2025