The Something Old, Something New, Something Borrowed (well, mostly Borrowed) award goes to New In Town, which borrowed:
From Fargo: the Minnesota setting and culture, the character with the last name of Gunderson, and the patriarch named Harve
From Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore: the waitress named Flo
From Baby Boom: the homemade food business, and the antagonist-turned-love relationship who rescues the fish-out-of-water woman from her stranded car
The Product Placement? award goes to The Proposal. In a scene in Manhattan, we can see a store called Tate's, and Sandra Bullock's character's name is Margaret Tate.
The Can't Get This Song Out of My Head award goes to Katherine Heigl, whose The Ugly Truth and Grey's Anatomy both had the song Pocketful of Sunshine.
The Kreskin award for the best use of ESP goes to Winston in Sunshine Cleaning. He accepts Rose's invitation to her son's birthday party and shows up, but she hadn't told him what time it is.
The Only Sporadic Use of ESP award goes to Race to Witch Mountain. AnnaSophie Robb can read minds, but after Dwayne Johnson talks to the government agents, she asks him "They're here for us, aren't they?".
The Wheel of Fortune award goes to Alan Arkin, whose appearance in Sunshine Cleaning following his appearance in Little Miss Sunshine has Pat and Vanna devising a Before and After puzzle: Little Miss Sunshine Cleaning.
The We Got the Pun award goes to The Time Traveler’s Wife. Eric Bana says to his dad “he‘s a Republican, and a hunter”, and his dad says “oh, dear” … or was it “oh, deer”?
The "Man, Is He Obsessed With Keeping a Schedule!" goes to Confessions of a Shopaholic. When Rebecca interviews with Luke, the clock on his desk shows 1:10. In a later scene in Luke's office, the clock also shows 1:10.
The All the English Teachers Just Cringed award goes to The Informant!, which has the line “You have a reason for embarrassing my partner and I ?”.
The She's Got You Conored award goes to Jennifer Aniston, who starred in 2 movies (He's Just Not That Into You and Marley and Me) with a character named Conor.
The Yeah, Sure, Just a Coincidence award goes to A Serious Man. It features the Jefferson Airplane song Somebody to Love, and the movie opened on Grace Slick's birthday.
The Crimes and Misdemeanors award goes to I Love You, Beth Cooper. When Rich and Beth escape after Rich is attacked by Kevin, Rich rattles off the list of crimes that Beth could be charged with, but he neglects to include the fact that she is driving without a seat belt.
The Ed Wood Would Be Proud award goes to I Love You, Beth Cooper. When Rich and Beth escape, the skies turn from daylight to night in a matter of seconds, a salute to Plan 9 from Outer Space.
The Ed Wood Would Be Proud award (runner-up) goes to Avatar. Sigourney Weaver says "You see? You see?". To complete the salute to Plan 9 from Outer Space, she would have added "Your stupid minds! Stupid! Stupid!".
The In High School Literature Class, We Called This a Foreshadow award goes to Did You Hear About the Morgans?. The bad guy makes a phone call and asks if he has reached Columbus, Ohio. Later in the movie, Lucy sings "Crazy Little Thing Called Love", a salute to Dwight Yoakum, who is from Columbus, Ohio.
The Don't Leave Home Without Them award goes to Did You Hear About the Morgans?. Hugh Grant and Sarah Jessica Parker go out jogging in the countryside, jog into town, and see a new store. They emerge with with purchases, proving that you never know when you may need cash or a credit card when you go out jogging.
The What Goes Around Comes Around award goes to Daniel Stern for Whip It. In 1979, he played a teenager in Breaking Away, where the athletic event is a race around a track (bicycling), takes place in a city with a major university (Bloomington, Indiana), where one of the teenagers pretends to be from Italy to impress a coed, and where a parent finally embraces the child's sport and comes to the championship event late. Thirty years later, he played a parent to a teenager in Whip It, where the athletic event is a race around a track (roller derby), takes place in a city with a major university (Austin, Texas), where one of the teenagers pretends to be 5 years older to join the team, and where a parent finally embraces the child's sport and comes to the championship event late.