The Case of the Disappearing Wall award goes to Mystic River. In one scene, the cops are facing Sean Penn and Laura Linney, who are sitting in a cafeteria booth that is against a wall. When the scene switches its camera angle to the left of Sean and Laura, we can see that there is walking room where the wall should be. Director Clint Eastwood should put Dirty Harry on this case.
The Let's Plug His Next Movie award goes to The Recruit. In one scene, Colin Farrell calls Al Pacino, and Al says "You know that Phone Booth you're calling from?".
The These Guys are Professionals? award goes to The Italian Job. The good guys eavesdrop on Ed Norton calling the cable company for service, the cable company says they will send someone in a week, Mark Wahlberg calls Edward Norton's security guard, pretends to be from the cable company and says that they have someone in the area and will be right over. But, Mark Wahlberg doesn't call the cable company to cancel the order. And, the security guard apparently didn't have Caller ID, or he wasn't suspicious about the caller.
The Trading Spaces award goes to Lindsay Lohan for Freaky Friday. In The Parent Trap, she traded places with her sister, and in Freaky Friday, she traded places with her mother. At this rate, in her next movie, she will trade places with her grandmother. She must have been influenced by Jamie Lee Curtis, who plays the mother and appeared in the movie Trading Places.
The Previous Experience Required award goes to Ashton Kutcher for Just Married. Similar to his experience in Dude, Where's My Car?, he has a heated exchange over an intercom box.
The Deja Vu award goes to Lindsay Lohan for Freaky Friday, who earlier in her career had the line "this is so freaky" in The Parent Trap.
The Deja Vu award (runner-up) goes to Ben Stiller in Duplex. In a drugstore, a customer asks "how much is Nicoret?", and Ben had tried to buy Nicoret in a drugstore in Meet the Parents.
The You're a Good Man, in Japan award goes to Charlie Brown, whose name was referred to in both Lost in Translation and Kill Bill, Vol 1 (which had a an actress named Lucy, to boot).
The They Don't Know Their Right From Their Left award goes to Kill Bill, Vol. 1. Uma Thurman's voice over says "The pretty lady on O-Ren's right is Sofie Fatale", but Sofie is on O-Ren's left.
The Perfect Opportunity to Capitalize on My Name Gone Astray award goes to sportscaster Jack Arute, who failed to land a role in Kangaroo Jack.
The Thinly-Veiled Remake in Disguise award goes to Old School. The City Slickers movies had 3 middle-aged men trying to re-discover themselves, a character named Mitch, a character named Curly, and a character who quotes from The Godfather. Old School has 3 middle-aged men trying to re-discover themselves, a character named Mitch, a character with curly hair (Will Ferrell), and a character whose nickname is The Godfather. As if we wouldn't notice.
The Perfect Opportunity to Sponsor a Movie Gone Astray award goes to the Dell Crossword Company. For the movie Elf, they could have designed an ad that had:
E
WILL
FERRELL