ds-9

- NAPS Rao on Dvaita List

dwAdash stOtra - 9

DVADASHA STHOTHRA 9A

While writing about Sthothra 8, it was said that Acharya Madhva goes lyrical from this sthothra onwards indicating his own intense devotional state. In this sthothra, The second line "Shubhathamakathaashaya paramasadoditha jagadekakaarana Raama ramaaramana" is repeated at the end of each shloka. The very tenor and manner of singing and repitition of this line enables concentration of one's mind totally on the request coming at the end of the first line - "bhava mama sharanam". In this sthothra Acharya Madhva is extolling the Dashaavathaara of Vishnu . While understanding this sthothra, it will be necessary to try to understand the mind of the Supreme Devotee - Jivotthama - Acharya Madhva to the extent possible. For this purpose, let us remember the texts of Anuvyakhyana -

"Ghoshaah sarve'pi vedashscha sarve vedashcha yathpadam indram mithram yamindram cha prathamam samkruthisthathaa naamadhaah sarvadevaanaam yeka ithyaadikaa shruthih pramanam uktha vishaye".

In the Bhashya on the Brahma Suthra "Thatthu Samanvayath", Acharya Madhva has stated that all the Vedas have as their main purport, the description of the Supreme Being - Vishnu. Subsequently, he has shown in the Bhashya and Anuvyakhyana, as demonstrated by detailed analysis by Sri Teekacharya that all the words occuring in the Vedas - including those which are commonly understood as referring to other entities or gods such as Jyothi, Indra, Akasha etc refer to the Supreme Being as their main meaning. Acharya Madhva has given a detailed picture of how such words would simultaneously refer to other entities and the Supreme Being - while our usage may be essentially due to common acceptance, the reference to the Supreme Being is by derivation of the word roots. But this understanding is beyond the capacity of most of the souls, and only Chathurmukha Brahma has the capacity to fully understand the purport of the Vedas in this manner. There are also other Vedic texts whch show that all other sounds in nature like the roaring of the Sea, the rolling of thunder etc. also denote God. Acharya Madhva can explain this, because he himself is fit to attain the position of Brahma. The same sense is conveyed by the words of Praathahsamkalpagadya of Sri Raghavendra Swamiji - "Laukika Vaidika bheda bhinna varnaathmaka dhvanyaathmak asheshashabdaartha rigaadisarva vedaartha . " - that God is described by all words, letters, sounds of all types in the Vedas or others in the world.

Thus, when Acharya Madhva describes His master in Dvaadasha Sthothra, in addition to the conventional meanings attached to the words out of which sentence meanings are derived by us with the help of Teekas, one would expect an infinity of meanings being stated - most of which will be beyond our comprehension either in their derivation or even if derived, in our understanding. Out of the infinite qualities of the Supreme Being, our comprehension is also strictly limited to a few, which we can grasp by their similarity to the inferior worldly examples, but which would be as different from them as a Sun is from a candle. An example is the statement often made - Kotisuryaprakasha. Even if one were unable to grasp and understand the exact and complete entity, our knowing that, what we can understand is only a glimpse of the tip of the iceberg, when we try to grasp the qualities of the Supreme Being (which are understood to a far greater degree by superior souls) would itself give us a greater degree of devotion and reverence. It is for this reason that the sthothras and devaranaamas composed by great devotees and Aparoksha Jnanis have special sanctity and capacity to take us to the Supreme Being as they are the result of deep, exact and comprehensive knowledge and direct congnition (Sakshi Prathyakasha).

With this thought, let us look at the meanings of the sthothra No. 9. First, the sthothra as a whole is stated :

atimatatamogirisamitivibhedana pitAmahabhUtida guNagaNanilaya |

shubhatama kathAshaya paramasadodita jagadekakAraNa rAmaramAramaNa || 1||

vidhibhavamukhasurasatatasuva.nditaramAmanUvallabha bhava mama sharaNam.h |

shubhatama kathAshaya paramasadodita jagadekakAraNa rAmaramAramaNa || 2||

agaNitaguNagaNamayasharIra he vigataguNetara bhava mama sharaNam.h |

shubhatama kathAshaya paramasadodita jagadekakAraNa rAmaramAramaNa || 3||

aparimitasukhanidhivimalasudeha he vigata sukhetara bhava mama

sharaNam.h |

shubhatama kathAshaya paramasadodita jagadekakAraNa

rAmaramAramaNa || 4||

prachalitalayajalaviharaNa shAshvatasukhamayamIna he bhava mama

sharaNam.h |

shubhatama kathAshaya paramasadodita jagadekakAraNa

rAmaramAramaNa || 5||

suraditijasubalaviruLitama.ndaradhara vara kUrma he bhava mama

sharaNam.h |

shubhatama kathAshaya paramasadodita jagadekakAraNa

rAmaramAramaNa || 6||

sagirivaradharAtaLavaha susUkaraparamavibodha he bhava mama

sharaNam.h |

shubhatama kathAshaya paramasadodita jagadekakAraNa

rAmaramAramaNa || 7||

atibaladitisuta hR^idaya vibhedana jayanR^ihare.amala bhava mama

sharaNam.h |

shubhatama kathAshaya paramasadodita jagadekakAraNa

rAmaramAramaNa || 8||

balimukhaditisutavijayavinAshana jagadavanAjita bhava mama

sharaNam.h |

shubhatama kathAshaya paramasadodita jagadekakAraNa

rAmaramAramaNa || 9||

avijitakunR^ipatisamitivikhaNDana ramAvara vIrapa bhava mama

sharaNam.h |

shubhatama kathAshaya paramasadodita jagadekakAraNa

rAmaramAramaNa ||10||

kharataranishicharadahana parAmR^ita raghuvara mAnada bhava mama

sharaNam.h |

shubhatama kathAshaya paramasadodita jagadekakAraNa

rAmaramAramaNa ||11||

sulalitatanuvara varada mahAbala yaduvara pArthapa bhava mama

sharaNam.h |

shubhatama kathAshaya paramasadodita jagadekakAraNa

rAmaramAramaNa ||12||

ditisutavimohana vimalavibodhana paraguNabuddha he bhava mama

sharaNam.h |

shubhatama kathAshaya paramasadodita jagadekakAraNa

rAmaramAramaNa ||13||

kalimalahutavaha subhaga mahotsava sharaNada kalkIsha he bhava

mama sharaNam.h |

shubhatama kathAshaya paramasadodita jagadekakAraNa

rAmaramAramaNa ||14||

akhilajanivilaya parasukhakAraNa parapurushhottama bhava mama

sharaNam.h |

shubhatama kathAshaya paramasadodita jagadekakAraNa

rAmaramAramaNa ||15||

iti tava nutivarasatataraterbhava susharaNamurusukhatIrthamuneH

bhagavan.h |

shubhatama kathAshaya paramasadodita jagadekakAraNa

rAmaramAramaNa ||16||

*******************************************************

Athimatha thamogirisamithivibhedana pithaamahabhoothida

gunagananilaya

Shubhathamakathaashya parama sadoditha jagadekakaarana raama

Ramaaramana |

The first line addresses the Supreme Bieng by giving His qualities. He is Athimatha as He is worshipped by the Jnanis fully or He is well known only by Yogis. It can also be interpreted as meaning that He can not be known completely by any one. He is the destroyer (vibhedana) of the groups (samithi) of mountains of primordial ignorance - Thamogiri He gives the Aiswarya or all capacity, powers, wealth etc. to Chathurmukha Brahma. (Bhuthi - sampath) He is the repository of infinite auspicious qualities like Jnana, Ananda etc. (The word Nilaya shows that He is the source from which others get some little parts of those qualities). He is also the subject of enquiry (kathaashaya) which is the most sacred (shubhathama) leading to redemption from Samsara (the most auspicious result attainable). The word Shubhathamakathashaya can also be split a Shubhathamakatha, and Aaashaya, to give the meaings that He is the most auspicious entity in the world and discussion about Him gives the most auspicious result, while Aashaya means Aashraya - one who supports every thing and every one.

Parama - Sarvotthama - the greatest entity in the world. Sadoditha - Sadaaprakaashana - one who is always of the essence of pure knowledge or effulgence.

Jagadekakaarana - the most important and primary cause of the world.

Raama - Aathmaaraama - One who enjoys Himself, One who is of the nature of pure infinite bliss. Sri Vishvapathi gives a quote from Paadmapurana - "Ramanthe yogino yathra sathyanandachidaathmani ithi Raamapadenaaithath param brahmaabhideeyathe" _ the word Rama also denotes that He is one of the essence of Sath, Chith and Aananda in whom the yogis revel in bliss in their meditation.

Ramaaramana - Lord of Lakshmi or Ramaa.

Bhava mama sharanam occurs in the next stanza and should be added here to indicate the purpose of addressing and describing the Lord thus. - This means - Be my shelter or protector. Though all these could be summed up in a pargraph, it is better to note the myriad meanings which convey the Lord's qualities, when we recite the shlokas and pray that He may redeem us.

Vidhibhavamukhasurasathathasuvanditha ramaamanovallabha

Bhava mama sharanam

Shubhathama .

You are worshipped with great diligence and concentration by the

gods headed by Brahma (vidhi), Ishwara (bhava). You are the

dearest object of the mind of Sri Ramaa Devi.

Please be my protector -

Aganithagunaganamayasharira he vigathagunethara

Bhava mama sharanam

Shubhathama .

You have your body composed of infinite groups of auspicous

qualities like bliss. You are completely free (vigatha) of

defects and shortcomings (gunethara).

Please be my protector -

(While discussing the infinity of the auspicious qualties of the

Supreme Being, one is reminded of the following shloka of Sri

Hari Kathamruthasara).

"ondugunadolananthagunagalu

onduroopadolihavu lokado-

londuroopadi dharisi thadgathapadarthadolahorage

bandaladavoliddu bahupesa

rinda karesutha poornajnaanaa

nandamaya paripari vihaarava maadi maadisuva" - Vyapthi Sandhi

31

Which explains the Bhagavatha shloka

"Mayyananthagune ananthe ." and

the Geetha shloka - "Ihaikastham jagathsarvam"

The qualities of the Supreme Being are Apraakrutha - not made of

ordinary worldly stuff. Thus, His bliss (Ananda) is not just

pure bliss, but also has in it other qualities like knowledge,

beauty etc, in the same manner as his limbs are not performing

only some functions like ours. His beauty is not one that lies

in the eyes of the beholder alone - but has a number of other

qualities as its constituents. The groupings of His qualities

themselves are infinite and each of them is infinite in

magnitude, though we can hardly understand concepts like

Infinite beauty, kindness etc. For instance, it is well known

that the concept of beauty depends very much on the species - it

is difficult to conceive of a beautiful Pig or Tortoise for us.

But, the form of the Lord in Varahavathara or Kurmaavathaara

would be as beautiful to us as the form of Hayagriva, or Rama

and Krishna who were in human forms. Being of the essence of the

Supreme Being Himself, they have no intrinsic difference between

themselves, but can be distinguished for our understanding as

different qualities due to the Vishesha - just like the

whiteness of cloth is non-different from it, but can be cognised

as a quality of the cloth.

Aparimithasukhanidhivimalasudeha he vigathasukhethara

Bhavamama sharanam

You are an unlimited ocean of bliss. Your body is pure and

exquisite. You are completely free from sorrow.

Please be my own protector -

Unlike all other souls, God alone is never afflicted by dukha or

sorrow (called sukhethara). [This applies to His consort Lakshmi

too]. But, He is the only one who has infinite bliss always.

"prachalithalayajalaviharana shaashvathasukhamayameena he

bhava mama sharanam"

Acharya Madhva is extolling the Mathsya form of the Lord. You

are sporting in the primordial ocean of dissolution

(pralayajala) which is being disturbed by violent winds. You are

full of bliss (sukhamaya), unchanged and undisturbed.

(shashvatha).

This shloka reminds one of the Upanishath - "Yeko naraayana

aaseeth, na brahmaa na cha shankarah"

"Vaasudeva idamagra aaseeth"

"Suradithijasubalavilulitha mandaradharavara koorma he

bhava mama sharanam"

When the Ksheerasamudra was being churned by the Devas and

Asuras with great strength, the Mandara mountain used as churn

was sinking into the sea. You lifted and supported it on your

back as Kurma. [This demonstrates that only Lord Narayana could

do it as the combined might of all the Gods and asuras who were

acting in concert for a specific purpose was unable to prevent

it.)

"Sagirivaradharaathalavaha susookara parama vibodha he

bhava mama sharanam"

In your Varaha form you took upon your horns the entire earth

with its huge mountains. You are of the nature of Jnana itself.

"Athibaladithisuthahrudayavibhedana jaya nruhare amala

bhava mama sharanam"

You tore into the heart of Hiranya Kashipu of immense strength

and valour. You are absolutely pure and victorious.

Note : Hiranya kashipu's strength was not only natural to him,

but was added to by the boons secured by him from Brahma. Thus

only Nrusimha form of Vishnu could destroy him. The reference to

purity and victory is also siginificant. Nrusimha is imvoked by

Acharya Madhva himself in Kathaa Lakshana -

"Nrusimhamakhilaajnaanathimiraashishiradyuthim

sampranamya pravakshyaami kathaalakshanamanjasaa"

Nrusimha is like the Effulgent Sun in destroying the darkness of

primordial ignorance.

"Narasimho akhilaajnaanamathadhvaanthadivaakarah

jayathyamithasajjnaanasukhashakthipayonidhih"

Lord Narasima is the Sun destroying the Ajnana Matha - Maya

Vada, which considers that all except the Chaithanya is

superposed and unreal.

He is to be remembered always to get out of the coils of Ajnana

or Mithyajnana. The word Amala suggests this. The word "jaya"

suggests the shloka from Yamaka Bharatha of Acharya Madhva -

"Yadanigrahi poornathvaath bhimah sarvaanareenanahi

poornathvaath

adahadbaahubalena krodhaagnaavaahithaannijaahubalena"

Bhima, the great devotee of God and emancipator of the good

people, remembered the Narasinha form of the Supreme being with

Manyu Suktha and offered all his enemies in his sacrificial fire

of anger. Even the destruction of his enemies was done as an

offering to Lord Narasimha.

"Balimukhadithisuthavijayavinaashana jagadavanaajitha

bhava mama sharanam"

You destroyed the victory of the Asuras headed by Bali (over the

gods). You are the protector of the entire universe

(Jagadavana), You are never defeated yourself (Ajitha). This

refers to the Vaamana form of the Lord.

"Avijithakunrupathisamithivikhanadana ramaavara veerapa

bhava mama sharanam "

You destroyed completely the entire groups of evil Kshathriya

kings who could not be defeated by any others. You are the Lord

of Lakshmi. You protect the good heroic persons like Bheeshma,

(though they were also Kshathriyas).

"Kharatharanishicharadahana paraamrutha raghuvara maanada

bhava mama sharanam "

You destroyed the hated cruel Asuras like Ravana, Kumbhakarna

and Khara. Your are called Para, as you are superior to and

different from all else. You are Amrutha as you have never had

any form of destruction or dimunition. You are Maanada as you

give Jnana to the devotees headed by Hanumaan.

"Sulalithathanuvara varada mahaabala yaduvara paarthapa

bhava mama sharanam "

You have an exquisite, delicate and beautiful body (Sulalitha

Thanu). You are Varada because you gave bons to your devotees

like Akrura, Kubja etc. You are also called Varada, as you

destroyed great Asuras like Naraka (Varaan asurashreshtaan

narakaadeen dyathi). You are the greatest of the Yadu race. You

have immense and immeasurable strength (Mahaabala). You

protected the sons of Kunthi or Pruthaa. You protected Arjuna

specially in the Mahabharatha war.

"Dithisuthamohana vimalavibodhana paragunabuddha he

bhava mama sharanam ".

You deceived the sons of Dithi or Daithyas - Dithisuthamohana.

But you taught gods headed by Brahma the correct truth with no

flaws - vimalasubodhaka. You increase the true knowledge of the

good people. Your are Paraguna, as you have qualities which are

superior to all others. Buddhaavathaara is being addressed.

"Kalimalahuthavaha subhaga mahothsava sharanada kalkeesha he

bhava mama sharanam "

You burn away the evil impurities supported by Kali that vitiate

the mind and lead peaople astray from the path of virtue . You

are Subhaga, as you are a beautiful person. When you are seen,

people will get tremedous joy of the mind - Mahothsava. You

protect and give shelter to the virtuous who ask for help. Kalki

avathaara is being addressed.

"Akhilajanivilaya parasukhakaarana parapurushotthama

bhava mama sharanam "

You are the cause for the creation and destruction of the world.

You give the Innate bliss to the Muktha Jivas according to their

worth. You are Para or completely endowed needing none else for

your existence, bliss or capacity etc. You are the greatest

Purusha - Purushotthama, being superior to both the Kshara and

Akshara entities constituting the Universe.

"Ithi thava nuthivarasathatharatherbhava susharanamuru

sukhatheerthamunerbhagavan"

In this manner, Ananda Tirtha is always engaged in extolling

you with this great sthothra. Bhagavan, who is full of

auspicious qualities, please protect me always.

NAPSRao.

> "Achyutho yo gunairnithyamevaakhilaihi

> prachyutho asheshadoshaih sadaa poorthithah

> ucchyathe sarvavedoruvaadairajah

> svarchyathe brahmarudrendrapoorvaih sadaa

> preenayaamo . "

There is a clarification possible in respect of the first line -- in

particular, the use of the term `guNairnityamevAkhilaiH'. It is possible

to object that Shruti does not in fact state that the attributes of

Brahman are `nitya', unlike what has been claimed -- in fact, they clearly

show in places that the ultimate Reality is without form. This idea is

dealt with by Srimad Ananda Tiirtha in several places, such as in the

karma-nirNaya:

na cha --

`eko devaH sarvabhUteshhu gUDhaH sarvavyApI sarvabhUtAntarAtmA |

karmAdhyaxaH sarvabhUtAdhivAsaH sAxI chetA kevalo nirguNashcha ||'

(shve. u. VI-11)

-- ityAdivirodhaH | sattvAdiguNAbhAvoktestatra | anyathA

`eko devaH sarvabhUteshhu gUDhaH' ityAdInAmapi guNatvAt.h

svoktivirodhaH |

Not also are:

"The One Deity, Who is unknown to all beings, is All-encompassing,

is the Inner Motivator of all beings, is the Owner of all action,

is resident in all beings, is a Witness, is responsible for all

knowledge, is not tied to the insentients, and is also without

qualities,"

-- et cetera, opposed. As lack of qualities such as `sattva', is

indicated therein. Otherwise, since even "the One Deity Who is

unknown to all beings," etc., denote qualities, there would be

self-contradiction.

I include without translation Sri Jayatiirtha's commentary on this part of

the text as an aid to those who may be inclined to delve more deeply into

this issue.

TIkA --

nAnumAnena brahmaNaH saguNatvaM siddhyati, nirguNashrutivirodhAd.h,

ityata Aha -- `na cha' iti | virodhaparihArasamuchchitenaiva

anumAnena saguNatvaM siddhyatIti chashabdaH samuchchaye |

nirguNashchetyetAvadudAhartavye.anyAMshodAharaNamuttaratropayoxyate |

kuto na virodha, ityata Aha -- `sattvAdi' iti | kevala iti

sharIrAbhAve pratipAdite tatra hetvAkAN^xAyAM sharIrasambandhe

yatvAnna virodhaH | prakR^itaguNAbhAva evArthaH kiM na syAt.h ?

kuto.arthAntarakalpanA? ityata Aha -- `anyathA' iti |

shruteranumitsitaguNAbhAvaparatve svoktivirodhaH kiM na syAt.h |

kutaH ? `eko deva' ityAdipadairuktAnAmekatvAdInAmapi guNatvAt.h

svayamevaikatvAdiguNAnabhidhAya tadabhAvaM vadantI shrutiH

kathaM `me mAtA vandhyA' itivat.h svoktiviruddhA na syAt.h ?

ato.arthAntare yojyeti | ekatvAdyanuvAdena tadabhAvo bodhyata

iti chenna | j~nApakAbhAve vaiparItyasyApi sambhavAt.h ||