P. F. (Paul Frederick) Kluge arrived in Saipan as part of one of the earliest Peace Corps groups in Micronesia. I learned of his existence because he was the editor of a quarterly journal called The Micronesian Reporter, in which I eventually published an article about the school where I was teaching. I only learned of his experiences when I read his two books set in Micronesia, which are described in my book list. I was much taken with the account he wrote of his own return to the islands in The Edge of Paradise, which was generally a depressing experience for Fred.
Here is how he re-interpreted the disconnect between the outlook of Micronesian and many of the Peace Corps Volunteers.
The groups of volunteers who came to Micronesia were numbered, something like military historians number the days around an invasion, D-Day Plus One, and so forth. I was part of Micronesia Five, but there were still some Micronesia One volunteers around when I completed training and arrived on the island of Saipan, in the Northern Marianas. Finishing up their stints, they regaled us with tales of what it was like, having been the first to hit the island beaches: weeks of receptions, invitations, parties. Everyone knew their names. “A new kind of American” was arriving. That was the impression. Just as the Spanish had yielded to the Germans, the Germans to the Japanese, the Japanese to the Americans, now the American period itself was mutating from naval administration to Department of the Interior control and now . . . Kennedy’s children, who spoke a little of the local language, shunned automobiles, moved into beat-up village houses, enthusiastically sampled local foods. Oh, they’d had a good war all right, the men and women in Micronesia One, but by the time I arrived the honeymoon was over.
People were wising up. Many of the career administrators in the Turst Territory government felt that the Peace Corps made them look bad. Some of them were ex-marines, blood-on-the-reef irredentists, quick to resent the long-haired, pot-smoking, draft dodging hippies who now cluttered what used to be a simple, neo-colonial landscape. Peace Corps volunteers hassled them. The architects didn’t order building supplies through government channels, the lawyers encouraged local clients to sue the government. Down in Yap, some guys showed up with island tattoos, chewed betelnut. A girl or two went topless. What the Peace Corps brought wasn’t a new era or a new regime so much as another level of American presence, a stratum of cut-rate Americans, cheaper by the dozen, a buffer state between the Trust Territory government ….
The Saipanese—all of the Micronesians—were less impressed as well. Game and likable as the volunteers might be, they were youngsters in a place that valued seniority, innocent and unarmed in a place that respected clout and—surprise!—they were poor in a society that esteemed wealth. That was the crushing lesson: Voluntary poverty did not impress. “Living on the level of the people” came off as naïve, as downright wacky, when it was from that level people were trying to escape. We learned local languages while locals learned English. We hitch-hiked while they shot by us in brand new cars. We wore zoris—rubber thonged sandals—while they aspired to white Bally loafers. The conflict was basic, classic, poignant. The Peace Corps worried about American military bases while the islands’ brightest kids rushed off to Guam to enlist in the very war many of us had come to Micronesia to avoid. We worried about identity--theirs, not ours--culture, ecology, the life-giving reefs, the unspoiled islands, dying handicrafts, and clean lagoons, while locals pondered fast roads, new cars, big hotels, and a ticket to Honolulu.
It didn’t take long for the Peace Corps staff to figure out that volunteers did best outside of district centers--modern settlements--like Saipan or Koror. The farther away, the better. Thus, most Peace Corps stints combined the charms of spearfishing on outlying atolls with long, lonely battles on behalf of sanitary waterseal toilets, and hours of teaching English in a baking classroom right out of The Bridge on the River Kwai. I, thank God, escaped all that.
from The Edge of Paradise, pp. 18-19
I had never heard such a stinging indictment of the Peace Corps idea (other than when some newspaper in the midwest suggested that it was unpatriotic to join the Peace Corps, when there was a war to be fought in Vietnam). On the other hand, I knew that part of what Kluge wrote was on target.
I will never forget a brief conversation I had with Welter John, my school principle at the time, an extremely intelligent and hardworking Pohnpeian who was in the chiefly line of the nanmwarki. There was a beautiful sunset, and Welter and I were standing on the shore behind the dock (where there was no mangrove forest to block our view) and looking out across the lagoon at the nearby islets of Debehk and Takeiou.
"That," I said in my sincerest Pohnpeian, "is what Americans consider to be a genuinely beautiful view--just the water, the trees, and the sky. "What I would consider to be beautiful," Welter replied, again in all serenity and sincerity, "would be to see hotels all lit up on the shore over there." And we were just talking aesthetics, not money or status. To him those multistoried towers were truly beautiful.
At least one reviewer took serious issue with Kluge's cyncism. In ISLA, A Journal of Micronesian Studies (1:1, 1992), anthropologist Glenn Peterson remarked,
"Fred Kluge wrote the Preamble to what has since become the FSM Constitution. It is a piece of power and grace. I have always enjoyed reading it to students, explaining that Micronesia's leaders had the savvy to hire a professional speechwriter to draft it for them. I do not think I can tell them that anymore, aware that I shall henceforth remember him for this bitter
attack on a people he hardly knows."