VIIII:  References

 Just the Facts

The goal of the 3DSF.info Astro-droid Pages is to be as definitive and accurate as possible. So much droidy information out there is pure guesswork. Or it mixes up what happened during one point in Star Wars filmmaking history with another. Or it’s a combination of fact and conjecture.

But there is a historical reality that actually happened, a long time ago.

Is this really that important? Well, no. Obviously. It’s just a bunch of geeky info about an old fantasy movie franchise. But in an age of lies and propaganda, I want even this little pile of nerd information to be definitively factual!

Setting up the droid landing scene, filmed in Tunisia. Extensive plywood sheeting was required to allow R2 to roll across the shifting sands.

Verifiable primary and secondary sources are key. If something is a reasonable theory, especially with some circumstantial evidence, it will specifically be labelled “conjecture”. Which isn’t a bad thing - a conjecture is a theory or supposition for which there's simply insufficient evidence, and which hasn't yet been proved. Or I'll use words like "probably" or "it seems likely" so it's clear.

I will not make up some random idea and present it as truth. Also, this thing is a live document. Significant chunks of this material been rewritten and corrected as new information comes to light.

And finally, why VIIII rather than IX? Well, the former is arguably not incorrect, as Roman numerals weren't fully standardized. But it's mainly so that this chapter alphabetizes correctly at the end of the table of contents.

What sources do we have?

So what avenues of research are available, decades after the original films were made? Well, there's actually a lot of information out there. In fact, there's more information available to the public today than there's ever been on the topic of our favourite droid.

Dramatis Personae

John Stears and team puzzle over an uncooperative three-legged R2 on the Tunisian sands.

What we know for sure.

Records from the production period are probably going to be more accurate than reconstructed information noted down years later. However, even in this regard there are many open questions.

For example, when someone refers to the number of droids built, do they count domes? Domes and bodies? Domes with partial bodies? Of course a blueprint midway through production may well be superseded by last-minute undocumented changes. Or, for example, Roger Christian has said in recent interviews that at least one fibreglass R2 body was built without John Stears’ involvement and perhaps even his knowledge, so presumably the Peteric records will not list those.

George Lucas (left) and John Barry (right) examine early fibreglass feet and ankles – test versions not used in the final film. Kenny Baker is standing in the wide stance required to fit within the R2 body. Note also the fibreglass body skirt on the floor.

Another point: many people contributed their labour and talents to the films over the years. And for many of these behind the scenes folks the Star Wars films represent the pinnacle of their careers. Certainly, given the success of the movies, it's something that they can look back at proudly, and rightly so. But sometimes there appears to be a little credit inflation going on. There's an objective difference between "I contributed certain components to the construction of R2-D2" and, "I built R2-D2!"

It also appears that some individuals who worked on ESB and other sequels either hint or state that they worked on ANH, when there is no evidence for this. This may be another case of credit inflation, or it may be that they simply meant “Star Wars” as a franchise whole, rather than the specific film that was released in 1977 under that name.

Finally, it’s entirely possible that people not directly responsible for hands-on work in the shop may only have had a basic understanding of specific numbers or details, even though they had a supervisory role. For instance, in a 1978 interview art director John Barry says that the holoprojectors are made from air vents from a Caravelle. Which isn’t of course technically true - the final droids had reading lights from a Vickers Viscount; another passenger aircraft from roughly the same time period. This kind of thing doesn't matter to most people, but it's the sort of detail that matters if you're obsessively researching the history of an ancient artefact!

What we know from evidence on-film.

This is a view of R2 from reaction shots during the holochess scene aboard the Falcon from ANH. Now - was this a continuity error? This shot should show the Falcon's computer console, and Han Solo in his chair, in the background. It actually resembles the wall of the first Death Star control room in the film.

Known factual records and statements, 1977-80

Specific facts from Electronics Today, Electronics Tomorrow, and Interface Age.

These were three publications that came out in 1977/78 that covered the construction of the droids in notable detail. Here are some specific facts and claims drawn directly from the magazines.

The three-leg R2

A pair of R2 units on the Dagobah set of Empire.

The two-leg Kenny R2s

Statements made in the years post-production

R5-D4 versus R2-D2.

There are a handful of differences between the way R5 and R2 appeared in ANH. It does seem that the original idea was that they were essentially the same type of robot – just that R5-D4 had a different head, and had the red panel stripes and red manipulator arms. However, because of technical problems shooting the droid auction scene, a fibreglass droid was cobbled together to represent R5.

There are behind the scenes photos showing technicians setting up the RC R2 as an R5 - red stripes and all. However, in the film the RC droid is never shown playing R5. Instead, it appears that two different R2 bodies were used to represent R5 in the auction scene.

The sequence opens with a red-painted two-legged droid shuffling across the desert. This is most likely a repainted Kenny droid. However, the three-legged R5 shown rolling along immediately prior to losing its “motivator” is different. It has a strange undersized middle foot with no side details, a side leg substituting for a middle leg, and really tall wheels. This is because it was a fibreglass 2-leg R2 unit hastily converted on-set into a rolling 3-leg R2 unit.

The photo above shows the "these aren't the droids you're looking for" scene being filmed. It's a screenshot from analogue video footage, which is why it's pretty blurry. The camera is on the ground to the left of the image, and Luke's landspeeder is about to halt further to the right. It looks like a camera may have been set up on the scaffolding, but no footage from this vantage point was used in the finished film. Producer Gary Kurtz is to the back, wearing a tan hat and probably taking a stills photo. And John Stears is half-visible behind the temporary wall, with the radio-control pack for the RC droid.

Two droids can be seen, ready to roll along the temporary plywood surface, to halt in front of a blank wall - they're just there for foreground interest and flavour! The modified R5 is seen repainted yellow, and its high wheel stance is quite visible. Next to it is the RC R2, which has had green stripes applied, and a temporary white dome installed. Its feet are much closer to the ground. The yellow droid was actually hauled on a string for this shot. Behind the scenes footage exists where you can see a crouching person by the wall, carefully pulling fishing line hand over hand to propel the robot forward.

Areas of uncertainty.

ILM's Steve Gawley makes a purchase. The droid panels look particularly dark, suggesting that this might be the droid that believed to have been painted black for the bluescreen work in ANH (the X-wing cockpit scenes).

Not Appearing in this Film

Unfortunately, certain individuals have overstated their contribution to Star Wars history. Why do I care? Well, for one thing the names of the people who actually did design and construct R2-D2 in 1976 are nearly forgotten today, in part because of these exaggerated competing claims. In fact, early drafts of this document contained some inaccurate attributions because of these widespread but false narratives.

This historical inaccuracy is regrettable. Since the emphasis of my work is on carefully researched and verifiable facts, I highlight the following.

Links and references.

Websites

Astromech.net. The first stop for people wanting to build their own full-sized composite droid replica.

OpenR2. An ambitious site filled with detailed first-hand documentation on the original R2 droid.

The R2 builders club on Facebook.

Michael Baddeley's 3D printed R2-D2 Patreon site. Based around the club plans.

https://www.therpf.com/forums/threads/r2-innovation-three-aluminum-r2-d2-builds.170825/

https://astromech.net/forums/showthread.php?32846-R2-Identity-Guide/page1

Video Documentaries

The Making of Star Wars TV special, 1977.

Star Wars on BBC Arena, 1978. Intolerably smug presenter; useful interviews.

Star Wars Episode I: Bad Droid Karma webisode

Books

Alinger, Brandon. Star Wars Costumes. Titan Books, 2014. Has an excellent section on R2-D2.

Arnold, Alan. Once upon a Galaxy: A Journal of the Making of the Empire Strikes Back. Ballantine Books, 1980. A remarkably frank look at the making of the film.

Christian, Roger. Cinema Alchemist: Designing ‘Star Wars’ and ‘Alien’. Titan Books, 2016. Set decorator Roger Christian's biography.

Daniels, Anthony.  I Am C-3PO - The Inside Story. 2019. Daniels' Threepio autobiography.

Duncan, Paul. The Star Wars Archives 1977-1983. Taschen, 2018. Includes large photos from the Lucasfilm archives.

Miller, W.R.. The Star Wars Historical Sourcebook: Volume One: 1971-1976. Pulp Hero Press.

Rinzler, J.W. Star Wars: the Blueprints. 47 North, 2013. Extensive collection of blueprint reproductions from the Original Trilogy.

Rinzler, J.W. The Making of Star Wars: The Definitive Story Behind the Original Film. Aurum Press, 2007. Assiduously researched and authoritative. Enhanced edition contains high-resolution photographs.

Rinzler, J.W. The Making of the Empire Strikes Back. Aurum Press, 2010. The successor volume, covering ESB.

Uncredited. Star Wars Blueprints. Ballantine, 1977. An unusual format - a vinyl pouch containing reproductions of 15 blueprints from the original film. Includes R2-D2. Sadly the draftspeople and designers are not credited.

Magazines

American Cinematographer, July 1977. The Filming of Star Wars. https://theasc.com/magazine/starwars/

Bantha Tracks, July 1978. The official Star Wars fan club magazine. https://www.jeditemplearchives.com/specialreports/banthatracks/

Cinefantastique, volume 6, no 4/volume 7, no 1, double issue 1978. Star Wars interviews.

Electronics Tomorrow, Winter 1977: http://starlogged.blogspot.com/2012/08/1977-star-wars-droids-in-electronics.html

Electronics Today, December 1977: http://cyberneticzoo.com/early-mobile-robots/1975-6-r2-d2-from-star-wars-john-stears-british/

Interface Age. April 1978. Short article written by John Stears.

Web articles

Want to build your own droid? http://astromech.net/gallery2/main.php?g2_view=core.DownloadItem&g2_itemId=83871

Lee Towersey and Oliver Steeples: How two British superfans built Star Wars' new R2-D2. https://www.wired.co.uk/article/star-wars-force-awakens-r2-d2

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0299485/releaseinfo

http://www.r2-d2.de/index3.htm

Brandon Alinger's 2013 interview with Peteric's David Watling.

Brandon Alinger's 2005 interview with Brian Johnson.

Remembering Tony Dyson. An interview with the man whose company built the ESB droid shells.

Ben Burtt and Star Wars' sound.

Ben Burtt, brief informal interview.

Galactic Renaissance Man: Model Maker and Droid Maestro Don Bies Talks Artoo, Becoming Boba Fett, and More: interview with Don Bies.

The Club Spec:Revisited specifications, to create blueprints for a more screen-accurate R2.

Star Wars in Death Valley: the Jawas Hunt R2-D2. Fan Mitch Darby retraces R2's steps in Tunisia and Death Valley.

World of Wayne De Agostini R2-D2 build video log.

Thanks.

Most of this stuff came from a lot of poring over old R2 photos, doing endless amounts of research, reading books and articles. But online discussions have also been massively valuable.

Thanks to Robert Jackson and Mark Kiger for countless excellent comments and corrections. These guys have done a tremendous amount of research on the topic of the original droids over the years. And Chris Reiff, Oliver Steeples, Brandon Alinger, Astromech's FrettedLogic and Edwardo for terrific contributions to Facebook, R2 Builders Club, and Astromech.net discussions.

Thanks, all!

Copyright.

This text was written entirely by and for 3Dsf.info. Feel free to make copies for your own use, but I ask that you not repost it for download elsewhere. The reason is I'm updating these pages all the time for accuracy and development purposes. So the most up to date page should always be available at 3Dsf.info!

The majority of the photos are copyright their respective owners. They're either the property of Lucasfilm or of various people who have posted images online; specific provenance is mostly not known. They're reproduced here for the purpose of criticism and research.

Contact

If you have any corrections or comments, feel free to drop a line:

contact@3dsf.info