This is our Research Proposal.
1. INTRODUCTION:
In 2006, the two-wave flood incident in Malaysia raised concerns over the victims' economic, sociological, and psychological impact. However, not many realised that the tragedy has been worsening due to Malaysia's current water resource management system structure. The research proves that the related problem to water resource management in Malaysia is due to the inexact division of power between the Federal and the State Governments and the broken legislation on Malaysian water. (S.A., R., & R.M., K. , 2009)
In this experiment, the investigation of the effect of distance on the pressure in a pipe is tested. The idea is inspired by the Malaysia water distribution system to various households, hence, a scaled-down version of the water system will be made for the investigation.
A source of life is water, which is a part of our livelihoods and prosperity, an essential element that maintains life, needed for the survival of all living things. Water has been well known for millennia in human survival and ecosystem conservation depending on the reliable availability and adequate water that is good quality. Lack of water, all living things would not exist and not survive. The only planet in-universe is Earth, with an abundance of water, with 71% of Earth's surface filled with water, allowing living things. However, 98% of the water on Earth's surface comes in the form of salt water, and only 2% of the water on Earth is freshwater, found in lakes, inland seas and rivers, approximately 99% trapped in glaciers and ice caps, in soil moisture or found in water tables too deep to access. Therefore, only around 1% of Earth's freshwater is available for living things to consume. Water is an integral part of living survival for social and economic purposes. Food production, hygiene and sanitation, health and the environment is affected under the water's influential role. Water is famous for its prehistoric times in food and agricultural production. Water-food interrelationships are significant. Access to safe drinking water and sanitation is critical to human well-being. Many development agencies, communities and experts worldwide are increasingly recognising the critical role that water can have on poverty reduction. (Ahmed, F. & Chamhuri, Siwar & Begum, Rawshan., 2014)Now, it is documented that provisioning safe drinking water and adequate sanitation services can form the basis for reducing poverty. This improves livelihoods, creates jobs for local communities in developing countries, removes the cycle of diseases that reduce the productivity of the people who have limited access to health services, and re-directs the health sector's savings to other imperatives. Thus, water plays a central role in the economic growth and sustainable development of a nation.
The situation in Malaysia is that the average annual rainfall they receive is about 3000 mm. Water resources development has been a stimulus for the country's socio-economic development during the past decades. Water transportation from rivers is mostly from dams, kilometres of pipelines, and canals to adhere to agricultural, industrial needs. In 1998, Malaysia's primary water supply resources were the Ampang intake built-in 1906, the Klang Gates Dam constructed in 1928, and the Semenyih Dam completed in 1984. These Dams are the main water resources of Malaysia. However, the turn of abundance to scarcity of water is caused due to the large population of Malaysia these recent years. Growth in population, development, progress and irrigated agriculture impose rapid growth demands and pressure on the water resources. This contributes to the rise of water pollution. Water management has become more comprehensive and complicated due to large population concentrations. Many commercial activities and industries around the cities increase water consumption, which leads to an increase in water pollution—scrutiny from conservationists and environmentalists for a new development of water resources.
This research topic is essential as distributing water is much more environmentally friendly and cost-efficient. It would be more suitable when the distribution reservoir is higher than the target community. Such as mountainous areas to reach consumers living in high elevated areas. The pressure zones are allocated under the network, separating pressure reducing stations, check valves and gate valves. Water can be transported by gravity flow; a distribution network usually operates. High pressure might cause pipes to burst. Hence, it is best to avoid high pressure. Instead, the system should have adequate pressure. Efficient distribution is required for all consumers to receive water with the required flow rate. Thus, the same pressure in the pipelines is crucial, allowing water to reach every place.
There are 2 different kinds of water distribution systems that we would like to mention, the gravity system and the pumping system. However, the focus of our experiment is on the gravity system. The following are the advantages and disadvantages of the 2 types of water distribution systems.
The advantages of the gravity systems are that no energy is required to function the system as water is supplied with the help of gravity, and a pump is not required. But the gravity system is not applicable on plain or flat terrain where there is no available elevation source. Water might be lost if leakage is present and comparatively higher. This system also requires a break-in pressure to reduce the tension in pipelines.
Some advantages of the pumping system are that water can only be pumped when required. This also results in low water loss caused by leakage. Even with that said, there are a few disadvantages, such as system breakdown, which may occur from time to time if power fails. Maintenance of the system is costly as well. Transporting of water through leaks may cause contamination to the water system.
In the 19th century, when technology dates, New York City was required to build their apartments and buildings higher than six stories to be equipped with a rooftop water tower. Only 3 companies constructed New York City's water towers, Rosenwach Tank Company, Issek Brothers and American Pipe and Tank/ The 3 companies are family-run, operating for 3 generations. The Rosenwach Tank Company's best-known company began in 1866 on the lower east side by barrel maker William Dalton before hiring a Polish immigrant Harris Rosenwach. After William Dalton passed away, Harris Rosenwach bought the company for $55 and expanded services over the past few decades to include historic building preservation, outdoor site furnishings as well as new water technologies. Rosenwach boasts that the only company that mills its quality wood tanks in New York City is them. In 1890, the Isseks Brothers were opened and overseen by David Hochhauser and his sister. According to Scott Hochhauser in the NY Times, there have been few changes to the company's water tank construction over the past century. Despite this, many people are curious about the tanks. "Some are interested in the history; many artists like them, for the beauty, and there are people who are into the mechanics of them. But I do not get too many people to call up to say, 'Hey, tell me about those steel tanks.'" (Gannon, D., 2017)
According to their website, American Pipe and Tank is about "sons apprenticing with their fathers," proudly claiming their business as being generational. Although the company has since expanded from its original services, the American Pipe & Tank Lining Co. remains the group's oldest. They still prepare, install and repair hot water tanks and fuel oil tanks in New York City. (Gannon, D., 2017)
The barrel makers were the first to make the original water tower, expanding their crafts to meet modern needs as the city grew larger and taller. Until today, no sealant has been used to fill water.
Why use wood? While the hand-made wooden barrels make us sentimental, they are the most effective for the water tank’s job. Even the city’s most luxurious buildings, like 15 Central Park West, for example, feature wooden tanks. Rosenwach uses Western cedar for their tanks, a cheap, lightweight material.
Plus, wood is much better at moderating temperature than steel tanks. Steel tanks, while sometimes used, are more expensive, require more maintenance and take more time to build. A wooden tank that can hold 10,000 gallons of water costs roughly $30,000. A steel tank of the same size can cost up to $120,000. Furthermore, water stored in the wood will not freeze in the winter and stay cool during the hot summer months.
Afterwards, the wood will rot and need to be replaced after about 30-35 years. Kenny Lewis, a Rosenwach foreman, explained the process of the tank infrastructure to amNY: “When you first set them up, they leak, but when they fill [with water], the wood expands and becomes watertight. Then, it is like a giant toilet. When people use the water, the level goes down. All ballcock lets more in, and that water is pumped from the basement.” (Gannon, D., 2017)
Wooden walls in the water tower are held together with steel cables or straps. However, water would still leak through the gaps when first filled. After the water is absorbed into the wood, allowing it to expand, it swells and closes the gaps, becoming more impermeable. Usually, rooftop towers store about 25,000 to 50,000 litres of water until it is necessary for the building underneath. The top portion of water is set for everyday use while the water in the lower tower is in reserve to fight fire. Once the water drops below a particular litre in the water tower, the pressure switch or float valve will activate a pump or open a public water line to refill the water tower.
How to calculate pressure? Placing a container of water on top of a stool increases the gravitational potential energy and acts as the water tower. A pipe will be connected to the container, allowing water to flow from the “water tower” to the pipe. Attached to the pipes are straws, which water will flow to. The water that enters the straw will determine the pressure travelling through the pipe. The research topic is the investigation of the effect of distance on the effect on the pipe. Water exerts pressure caused by its weight and the air above it, equally in all directions. The direction of the pressure is not equal in all directions. However, it is usually controlled, in a great measure, by the shape of the containing vessel, for example, a round cup having a flat bottom; hence the pressure is equal and most significant over the whole base. On the Earth’s surface, the air pressure exerted on us results from the weight of air above. The pressure is reduced as we climb up in altitude, and the weight of air above us decreases. However, underwater, the pressure exerted on us increases with increasing depth. In this case, the pressure exerted upon humans results from the weight of water above and the atmosphere. The air pressure changes on an elevator ride that transports many stories, but humans only need to dive a meter into the pool to feel the pressure increase. Water is about 775 times denser than air.
Research Questions
How does the height of the “water tower” play a part in transporting water through the pipe without the help of technology?
Research Hypotheses
As the water flows from the container, as gravitational potential energy decreases from the height of the container to the sink, kinetic energy increases. Pushing the water with a higher pressure by gravity to transport water along the pipe.
Controlled variables
(a) The same water level in the container
(b) The height from the countertop to the container of water
(c) The length between the container and the end of the pipe has to remain the same
(d) The speed of the water pump
2. Method
Equipment list:
big container
water dispenser
pipe
straws
sink
water
water pump
tripod stands
glue gun
Fig 2: Experimental setup 1
2.3 Procedures: Detail all procedures and experimental design to be used for data collection
Drill 4 holes on the upper walls of the container to place retort stands into them to ensure that the water dispenser is tightly secured.
Drill 3 holes along the pipe and secure the straws in place with a glue gun. Ensure that all straws are of the same length.
Set up the experiment as shown in the diagram above, placing the water dispenser on the stool, connecting the pipe connectors and the pipes attached with straws.
Once the setup is complete, get a bucket of water and dye the water with dark food colouring for more obvious results.
Pour the coloured water into the water dispenser and ensure that the tap is closed.
Once all the water has been poured into the water dispenser, open the tap and allow the water to flow.
Observe the water flow to the straw and record a video of the whole process.
To calculate the height of water, rewatch the video and screenshot two instances from the video where all the straws contain water.
From the screenshots, measure the height of water in the straws according to the pictures. Measure the height of the straws in real life and do an estimation of the water level in the straw in real life.
2.4 Data Analysis
11. After finding out the results, place them into the table below
2.5 Risk, assessment and management:
Identify any potential risks and safety precautions to be taken.
#1
Risk : The experiment consists of drilling the container for a hole to put in the pipe, there might be a chance that someone might get injured.
Assessment : Medium
Management : Ask a teacher for guidance/supervision when doing the procedure, if it is too dangerous, get a teacher to help you do it.
#2
Risk : When handling with water, there might be spills, hence making the floor wet, causing people to slip and fall.
Assessment : Medium
Management : Clean the floor if is wet, ensure no one is walking on and across the wet floor for their safety.
#3
Risk : The glue gun is hot, if not handled properly someone might get scalded.
Assessment : Medium
Management : Get adult supervision or wear gloves to prevent getting scalded.
3. Results
The results of our experiment are as shown below:
Table 1: Table of results
Figure 2: graph
4. Discussion
4.1 Key Findings, Comparison and explanations
From the data collected, a drop of pressure in water can be seen in the results. The height of the water in each straw decreases as the distance increases. The height of the water in the straws is equal to the amount of excess pressure in the water. Hence, we were able to see the significant decrease of excess pressure in the water through the water level drop throughout the 6 straws. To ensure that the results were more visible to compare the height differences in the amount of water in each straw, we decided to film the experiment with a solid grey background, along with adding brown food colouring to the water used in the set-up.
Another experiment we have found was on water pressure at depth from Edication.com, which explains to us what atmospheric pressure is and how it affects us, examples are swimming and scuba-diving. However, this experiment does not show us the difference between the increase or decrease in the distance of the water source to the opening. Our experiment has a larger number of data compared to this experiment, hence, it is more accurate, and reliable. (Education.com, 2013)
As shown from the results, we can conclude that as the distance from the water source increases, the pressure in the water decreases. Hence there was a noticeable drop in the height of the water in the straw.
The distance range increased consistently from 17.3 cm to 88.3 cm, the average height of the water decreased from 31.15 cm to 0 cm.
The results have shown that there would be a higher water pressure if the straws were closer to the water source compared to the straws that are further away from the container. This experiment allows us to know that there would be a decrease in the pressure as the distance from the water source to the pipe increases.
This ties with the Bernoulli’s equation because it explains the relationship between pressure, gravitational potential energy and kinetic energy in water distribution systems. The Bernoulli’s equations state where points 1 and 2 lie on a streamline, the fluid has a constant density, the flow is steady and there is no friction.
This experiment addresses some of the UN 17 Sustainable Development Goals, clean water and sanitation, affordable and clean energy, as well as sustainable cities and communities.
4.2 Limitations and Recommendations
Due to time restrictions, we could not get a heat shrink wrap; hence we had to replace it with duct tape to connect the water dispenser bottle and the pipe connector. The lack of the heat wrap caused some water leakage, which might cause the experiment to be less accurate because the decrease in water would cause the height of water level to drop.
Another problem is the presence of the air bubbles, causing the height of water in the straw to be inconsistent. The air enters through the air spaces, resulting in the overwhelming amount of air bubbles in the straws, causing inaccurate results. We have come up with different solutions as to why there were a lot of air bubbles in the straws, such as shaking the tube filled with a little bit of water then carrying on with the experiment to reduce the trapped air bubbles, but it failed.
The last problem we had was measuring the height of the water in the straws. This was a problem because the air bubbles added to the height of the water, so it was difficult to measure the height of the water only. So, we had to measure the total height of the water with the air bubbles minus the height of the air bubbles to find the final answer. However, the answers might differ.
4.3 Evaluation of Hypothesis
The hypothesis presented that the height of the water in each straw and the horizontal distance decrease linearly. However, the experiment proved the hypothesis to be inaccurate and incorrect. The results of the experiment showed that there was a bell curve drop in the results, unlike our hypothesis that we have predicted. The distance range increased consistently from 17.3 cm to 88.3 cm, the average height of the water decreased from 31.15 cm to 0 cm. Hence there was a noticeable drop in the height of the water in the straw.
5. Conclusions
5.1 Summary of findings
The investigation showed the benefits of the experiment and how it can influence the rest of the world to adapt to this radial pattern water distribution system. This allows the transportation of water to be faster, more efficient and reliable, enabling everyone in the unit or area to receive water without disruptions. Most pipelines in Singapore’s water systems are approximately 20–30 years of age, with an expected asset lifespan of 70 years, using the concept from this experiment would increase the lifespan of the pipes, without needing to change it regularly.
5.2 Contributions of research
Through this investigation, we have contributed through carrying out this experiment, finding out the drop in pressure by making a gravity water distribution system. Our authentic findings would be very useful to town designers when they are planning the landscape of buildings and infrastructure. The knowledge gained from this research can be shared with professionals and amateurs alike in developing a better and more efficient and reliable water distribution system for residents. The knowledge also contributes to Singapore’s National Water Agency, PUB, by providing information on how to better distribute water without the use of pumping stations and rooms.
5.3 Practical Applications
Pressure drop in a pipe will affect the water distribution in the town, along with the development of towns. Development of towns is generally built-in radial pattern which would be more efficient in transporting water compared to linear pattern towns where the citizens will have to go to a water. These results can be shared with town developers and designers, as the base of walls of buildings is made wider to reduce the pressure exerted by them. There are many other applications such as making sure that pressure in tyres are reduced etc. More practical applications can be found on Online Science Notes.
5.4 Areas for further study
We are curious to find out how the experiment results would differ if the diameter of the pipe increases or decreases, affecting the rate of the water flow, resulting in different pressure in water. Hence, we would like to find out what diameter of the pipe is most suitable for household water distribution systems. We researched to deepen our understanding, and found a website, Pipingmart Blog, explaining how the different diameter affects the pressure of water. They also explain how the pipe size affects flow, water pressure, and how pipe length affects water pressure and flow rate. This allows us to better understand how the different variables could change the results.
6. References:
Journal Article
Ahmed, F. & Chamhuri, Siwar & Begum, Rawshan. (2014). Water resources in Malaysia: Issues and challenges. Journal of Food, Agriculture and Environment. 12. 1100-1104.
Website
Education.com. (2013, December 4). Water pressure at depth: Science project. Science project | Education.com. Retrieved March 3, 2022, from https://www.education.com/science-fair/article/earth-science_squirter1/
Gannon, D. (2017, July 12). NYC Water Towers: History, use, and infrastructure. Retrieved January 20, 2022, from https://www.6sqft.com/nyc-water-towers-history-use-and-infrastructure/#:~:text=For%20 over%20100%20 years%2C%20 water,of%20New%20York%20City's%20skyline.&text=With%20up%20to%2017%2C000%20water,the%20structures%20into%20the%20mainstream.
How is water distributed? American Geosciences Institute. (2016, November 17). Retrieved March 3, 2022, from https://www.americangeosciences.org/education/k5geosource/content/water/how-is-water-distributed
Humagain, S. (2019, March 24). Pressure (practical applications of liquid pressure). Online Science Notes. Retrieved March 7, 2022, from https://onlinesciencenotes.com/pressure/#:~:text=Practical%20applications%20of%20pressure%3A,the%20pressure%20exerted%20by%20them.
KSKB-water-tower: Jeks Group of Companies. (n.d.). Retrieved January 21, 2022, from https://www.jekseng.com/portfolio/kskb-elevated-water-tower/kskb-water-tower/
MALAYSIA’S WATER VISION: THE WAY FORWARD - The Malaysian Water Partnership. (n.d.). Retrieved January 20, 2022, from https://www.fao.org/3/ab776e/ab776e02.htm
OpenStax. (n.d.). Physics. Retrieved January 20, 2022, from https://courses.lumenlearning.com/physics/chapter/11-4-variation-of-pressure-with-depth-in-a-fluid/
Piping MartPipingmart is B2B portal specializes in industrial. (2022, February 17). Does increasing pipe size increase water pressure? Pipingmart Blog. Retrieved March 7, 2022, from https://www.pipingmart.com/blog/other/does-increasing-pipe-size-increase-water-pressure/#:~:text=In%20water%20flowing%20pipeline%2C%20pipe,area%20of%20conveyance%20is%20reduced.
Poudel, E. M. K. (2021, December 7). Water Distribution System | Layout of Distribution Network | 3 Methods of Water Distribution System. Dream Civil. https://dreamcivil.com/water-distribution-system/
Recommended house water pressure. (n.d.). Retrieved January 20, 2022, from https://www.waterpumpmalaysia.com.my/recommended-house-water-pressure/
Singapore, P. U. B. (2016, July 21). Managing the water distribution network with a smart water grid - smart water. SpringerOpen. Retrieved March 3, 2022, from https://smartwaterjournal.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40713-016-0004-4#Sec3
Water distribution. (n.d.). Retrieved January 20, 2022, from https://www.avkvalves.com.my/en/water-supply/water-distribution
Water pressure. Experiments | Naked Scientists. (n.d.). Retrieved March 3, 2022, from https://www.thenakedscientists.com/get-naked/experiments/water-pressure
Report
S.A., R., & R.M., K. (2009). WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT IN MALAYSIA: LEGAL ISSUES AND CHALLENGES (Rep.). Retrieved January 20, 2022, from https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.735.2203&rep=rep1&type=pdf
7. Bibliography
Journal Article
Ahmed, F. & Chamhuri, Siwar & Begum, Rawshan. (2014). Water resources in Malaysia: Issues and challenges. Journal of Food, Agriculture and Environment. 12. 1100-1104.
Investigation of pressure drop in horizontal pipes with different diameters. (2017, May 1). ScienceDirect. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0301932216305109
Website
Education.com. (2013, December 4). Water pressure at depth: Science project. Science project | Education.com. Retrieved March 3, 2022, from https://www.education.com/science-fair/article/earth-science_squirter1/
Gannon, D. (2017, July 12). NYC Water Towers: History, use, and infrastructure. Retrieved January 20, 2022, from https://www.6sqft.com/nyc-water-towers-history-use-and-infrastructure/#:~:text=For%20 over%20100%20 years%2C%20 water,of%20New%20York%20City's%20skyline.&text=With%20up%20to%2017%2C000%20water,the%20structures%20into%20the%20mainstream.
How is water distributed? American Geosciences Institute. (2016, November 17). Retrieved March 3, 2022, from https://www.americangeosciences.org/education/k5geosource/content/water/how-is-water-distributed
Humagain, S. (2019, March 24). Pressure (practical applications of liquid pressure). Online Science Notes. Retrieved March 7, 2022, from https://onlinesciencenotes.com/pressure/#:~:text=Practical%20applications%20of%20pressure%3A,the%20pressure%20exerted%20by%20them.
KSKB-water-tower: Jeks Group of Companies. (n.d.). Retrieved January 21, 2022, from https://www.jekseng.com/portfolio/kskb-elevated-water-tower/kskb-water-tower/
MALAYSIA’S WATER VISION: THE WAY FORWARD - The Malaysian Water Partnership. (n.d.). Retrieved January 20, 2022, from https://www.fao.org/3/ab776e/ab776e02.htm
OpenStax. (n.d.). Physics. Retrieved January 20, 2022, from https://courses.lumenlearning.com/physics/chapter/11-4-variation-of-pressure-with-depth-in-a-fluid/
Piping MartPipingmart is B2B portal specializes in industrial. (2022, February 17). Does increasing pipe size increase water pressure? Pipingmart Blog. Retrieved March 7, 2022, from https://www.pipingmart.com/blog/other/does-increasing-pipe-size-increase-water-pressure/#:~:text=In%20water%20flowing%20pipeline%2C%20pipe,area%20of%20conveyance%20is%20reduced.
Poudel, E. M. K. (2021, December 7). Water Distribution System | Layout of Distribution Network | 3 Methods of Water Distribution System. Dream Civil. https://dreamcivil.com/water-distribution-system/
Recommended house water pressure. (n.d.). Retrieved January 20, 2022, from https://www.waterpumpmalaysia.com.my/recommended-house-water-pressure/
Singapore, P. U. B. (2016, July 21). Managing the water distribution network with a smart water grid - smart water. SpringerOpen. Retrieved March 3, 2022, from https://smartwaterjournal.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40713-016-0004-4#Sec3
Water distribution. (n.d.). Retrieved January 20, 2022, from https://www.avkvalves.com.my/en/water-supply/water-distribution
Water pressure. Experiments | Naked Scientists. (n.d.). Retrieved March 3, 2022, from https://www.thenakedscientists.com/get-naked/experiments/water-pressure
Encyclopedia Article
Britannica, T. Editors of Encyclopaedia (2019, January 30). pressure. Encyclopedia Britannica. https://www.britannica.com/science/pressure
Youtube video
Historychannel (Director). (2011, March 11). The Science of Water Pressure | History [Video file]. Retrieved January 20, 2022, from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0B0EhuxJsts
How Water Towers Work. (2018, December 10). YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yZwfcMSDBHs&t=3s
Report
S.A., R., & R.M., K. (2009). WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT IN MALAYSIA: LEGAL ISSUES AND CHALLENGES (Rep.). Retrieved January 20, 2022, from https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.735.2203&rep=rep1&type=pdf
Water Supply (Network) Department Public Utilities Board. (2009). HANDBOOK ON APPLICATION FOR WATER SUPPLY. https://www.pub.gov.sg/Documents/RPUB00003.pdf
references : (provided by adele)
link : recommended house water pressure - Water Pump Malaysia
link : Malaysian Water Partnership
link : Water distribution - AVK Malaysia
link : (PDF) Water resources in Malaysia: Issues and challenges
link : WATER RESOURCE MANAGEMENT IN MALAYSIA
link : NYC water towers: History, use, and infrastructure | 6sqft
link : pressure | Definition, Measurement, & Types | Britannica
references : (provided by mr tan)
link : KSKB-Water-Tower | JEKS Group of Companies
link : science articles
references : (provided by paris)
link : Water Distribution System | Layout of Distribution Network | 3 Methods of Water Distribution System
link : https://www.pub.gov.sg/Documents/RPUB00003.pdf
link : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yZwfcMSDBHs&t=3s
8. Acknowledgements
Words cannot express our gratitude for the many people who have given input and help this project become a reality.
We would like to express our utmost appreciation to our teacher, Mr Ng and Mr Tan, for guiding us through the entire project.
We express gratitude to Ms Su and the lab staff for loaning us the equipment needed for this experiment.
We thank all of those people from our heart for supporting us through this journey.
We would like to appreciate each other's help and support through these difficult times of carrying out the experiments together.