Sustainable Shopping
Basics
Sustainable shopping often involves these themes:
Environmental impacts
Human health
Animal welfare
Worker wellbeing
Common Problems
Chemicals of concern
Very complicated topic.
- Only a fraction of chemicals are tested for their impacts
- FDA doesn’t regulate many cosmetics, even those suspected of being harmful
- Example Chemicals: Fragrance, flavoring (natural & artificial), sulfides, phthalates, phosphates, chlorine, BPA, POP, PAH, PFAS, hormones, PFAS, chlorine and halogens, VOC…
- Example Production Processes: Tanning of leather, whitening of virgin paper, production of some plastics, chemical reaction with other products (e.g., the container)
Off-gassing: A product releases gaseous chemicals. This can happen over a long period.
Obsolescence
- Planned: Companies engineer products to break quickly, causing consumers to buy more
- Perceived: Consumers consider their product out of date despite functioning (e.g., fashion trends)
Pollution
- heavy metals
- nutrients
- air pollutants
- nonpoint source water pollution
- point source water pollution
Exploitation
- Conflict minerals
- Labor trafficking
- Child labor
- Factory farming
- Waste pickers
- Saviorism (Sometimes seen in social enterprises, when a company "rescues" rather than empowers communities)
Antibiotics
- Used to prevent infections in animal
- Overuse is known to breed drug-resistant bacteria
- Makes antibiotics pass to humans
- New emerging communicable diseases from animals
Monoculture
Problems
Deforestation
loss of pollinator and plant diversity
large scale pesticide use
practices that degrade the soil
Common monoculture items
corn
palm oil
bamboo
soy
Common Solutions
Used or DIY
- All around, the best approach if possible.
- Downside is safety. For example: leaded paint in toys, expiration dates, industrial strength (breakability), accuracy of information
Transparent & Responsible Sourcing
- Enables companies to track the lifecycle impact of their goods and conditions for employees
- This can be impossible to fully report in some industries and companies (ex: electronics supply chains are very complex, making it difficult for companies to fully trace the origins)
- Some reporting may be misleading or incomplete (ex: “cage free” could refer to a very small time)
- Stakeholder owned and cooperatives ensure the profits go directly to the workers
- Fair trade (see certifications), the most popular sourcing approach, may have drawbacks. For example, some people in areas without fair trade might not have any better alternatives.
Durable & Modular (repairable)
- Fewer wasted parts with modular design
- Durable parts can more readily be upcycled
- Must still properly dispose of finished parts (see recovery and end of life sections)
- Beware of planned obsolescence, where it may be difficult to find replacement parts
- Look at manufacturer’s warranty- longer warranty often indicates confidence in their product
Philanthropy
- Some companies have policies to donate money to a charity or cause
- This can require scrutiny to determine if the charity is reputable and the company’s commitment is deeper than a surface-level
Organic
- Generally, means food was created without GMO seeds, synthetic fertilizer, or synthetic pesticides
- Traditionally sustainable practices like crop rotation are more common (not universal) in organic
- Links between organic and health benefits are weak
- Organic has lower ecotoxicity but more land use than conventional agriculture
- Organic pesticides/herbicides/insecticides are toxic, just like synthetic ones (a toxin is a toxin 🙁)
- Organic goods can be lower quality or have a shorter lifespan
- Smaller scale organic farms often use more sustainable farming practices than large scale organic farms
- Other agriculture practices to look for: Regenerative
Vegan
- Absence of animal or animal-derivative ingredients or products
- Lower resource footprint like water, climate, and land use
- Less potential for antibiotic resistant bacteria
- (In food) Less exposure to persistent organic pollutants and greater energy transfer efficiency
- Fewer animal welfare concerns
- Greater waste if parts are discarded. For example, the non-vegan United By Blue upcycles discarded leather.
In-season
- Grows with less effort and resources overall
- Often cheaper (a rarity in sustainable shopping!)
- Also, look for “ugly” produce
Local
- Often organic and seasonal
- Supports local community
- Often handmade, more traceable, and careful practices
- Not as big of an impact on climate as other options like reducing animal products
- It can still have issues; for example, sugar cane burning in Florida and hog farming in North Carolina
GMO
- Despite the versatile possibilities, most commercial GMOs are breed either to be resistant to insecticides or to increase the plant’s inherent toxicity to insects
- GMOs overall will have an important role to play in adapting to climate change and development
- GMOs are highly regulated in the U.S. and are generally safe for human consumption
- In some cases, the GMO may be safer than traditionally bred crops
Concerns
- Glyphosate is the major environmental/social concern with GMO
- Incidents of allergic reactions, although rare, have been reported
- Accidental pollination and breeding with undesired plants such as weeds
Recoverable (7R's)
- Refuse
- Reduce
- Reuse
- Refill
- Repair
- Recycle
- Rot
Learn More
Hidden Ingredients
- Corn-based Ingredients (Most items on this list can come from other sources, too)
- Animal-Derived Ingredients List (Many items on this list are no longer derived from animals- douehe for questions about specific products.)
- 25 Sneaky Names for Palm Oil
GMOs
- The Nobel Laureates’ Campaign Supporting GMOs | ScienceDirect
- National Academies’s Research on GMOs
Recommended
- How bad are Bananas? The Carbon Footprint of Everything
- Inconspicuous Consumption: The Environmental Impact You Don't Know You Have
- Story of Stuff
- What Would the Buddha Recycle?: A Mindful Guide to an Eco-Friendly Life
- Ecological Intelligence: The Hidden Impacts of What We Buy
- Food Revolution documentary about regenerative agriculture
- Kurzgesagt YouTube Playlist introduces many food concepts like GMOs, organic agriculture, and effects of meat.