Lesson 5.01: Trial and Error

Introduction: It’s Not Cheating, It’s Strategy

For years, you’ve probably been told to stop guessing and start "doing the math." Because of this, using guess-and-check might feel like you're taking a shortcut or even cheating, but it is actually a powerful tool for tackling complex problems.

The real strength of this strategy isn't just about getting lucky; it’s about organizing information into a useful form so you have a place to start. By using a systematic approach, you can understand the problem better and eventually learn how to convert these guesses into formal algebraic equations.

To use this method effectively, you need more than just a calculator; you need the right attitude. You have to believe you can solve the problem even if you don’t fully understand it at first. Through persistence and organization, you can turn a random guess into a refined solution. The secret weapon here is a chart to keep track of your guesses and the operations you use to check them.

Math isn't always about knowing the answer immediately. It’s about building a thought process. Mastering the organization of your chart now is the key to writing complex algebraic equations later on.

The trial and error strategy is designed for cases when the logic of the question is not easy to see or diagram. It succeeds by prodding the question, and then studying the response. One can learn from the process only by trying one case, and then another in which one of the variables is changed.

Unlike those cases that succumb to systematic listing, the strategy works when there are infinite possible options.

Why Guessing Beats Just "Doing the Math"

Usually, algebra requires you to understand the entire problem before you even start writing. With guess-and-check, you develop a deeper understanding of the problem as you work through it. It isn't just a backup plan; it actually helps you build the skills you need for high-level algebraic concepts

Pro-Tips

To make this strategy work like a pro, you can’t just scribble numbers on a napkin. You need a system. Here are the keys to success:

Just Start Guessing

Don't stare at the paper. As you work through your first guess, you’ll naturally start to learn how the different parts of the problem interact

Stay Organized or Fail

The chart is your best friend. If you don't keep your work organized, you’ll end up defeating yourself

Bracket the Answer

Start with small numbers and build up. Use your guesses to "bracket" the answer so you know it’s somewhere in the middle

Rate Your Guess

Always ask: Is this too high or too low? Sometimes you’ll misrate a guess, and that’s okay—just be patient and pay close attention to your previous attempts

Watch Out for Math Errors

A simple arithmetic mistake can send you guessing in the wrong direction or make you skip over the right answer entirely

Label Everything

Use descriptive column titles so you don't forget what your numbers represent. If the problem involves different units (like miles per hour or total hours), put those units directly into your chart

The Secret Weapon: The Difference Column

If you are comparing two different sets of data in your chart, add a "difference column". This helps you see exactly how far off your guess is and makes it much easier to determine if your next move should be higher or lower.

Page updated

Report abuse