Conferences & Meetings

Decoding Ceramics Symposium – British Ceramics Biennial

Unveiling the pigments used in Portuguese azulejos

Márcia Vilarigues, Susana Coentro

October 11, 2023   |   Stoke-on-Trent, England

ECerS 2023 – XVIIIth Conference of the European Ceramic Society

Lead antimonate in the pigments of Portuguese decorated tiles: experimental replications and scientific characterisation

Umberto Veronesi, Mario Bandiera, Marta Manso, Andreia Ruivo, Alexandre N. Pais, Lurdes Esteves, Márcia Vilarigues, Susana Coentro

July 2-6, 2023   |   Lyon, France

Abstract

Beginning towards the end of the 16th century, the chromatic palette of Portuguese decorated tiles (azulejos) expanded dramatically. Besides white and blue, the colours now include purple, brown and different shades of yellow, orange and green. Although the lack of local sources severely limits our knowledge of how the colours were achieved, existing analytical data suggest that lead antimonate (Pb2Sb2O7) is one of the most frequently recurring compounds in pigment mixtures. Known as Naples yellow, lead antimonate represents the main component of yellow pigments and, mixed with a number of other oxides, formed the base for olive green, orange and orange-brown.


Using a technical historical approach, this paper addresses the role of lead antimonate within the colour technology of Portuguese azulejos. First, an ensemble of historical azulejos (16th-18th century) was investigated through a multi-analytical approach, to obtain information on their chemical composition (EDXRF) and to identify the main colouring agents (UV-VIS FORS and µ-Raman spectroscopy). Moreover, colourimetric measurements of the different hues were performed to address the relationship between colour and chemical composition. All analyses were performed non-invasively on the surface of the tiles. Our results confirm the widespread use of lead antimonate, on its own (yellow) or in combination with zinc (orange), iron (brown) and cobalt (olive green).


Further to the work on historical samples, a number of lead antimonate-based pigments were replicated in the laboratory following contemporary recipes from the Italian majolica tradition. Once obtained, the pigments were applied on test tiles, over a white glaze, and fired again. The resulting tiles were analysed with the same suite of techniques. Micro Raman indicates that the molecular profile of test tiles matched that of the historical ones, confirming the role of lead antimonate as the main compound in many of the colours. Our replications also confirm that additional ingredients strongly affect the hue, as is the case of alkali fluxes, zinc or tin oxide. On the other hand, the addition of smalt, a cobalt-based preparation, or copper oxide, gave olive green decorations, while the presence of iron oxide turned the pigment a dark orange to brown.


This article sheds new light on the role of lead antimonate as the main ingredient in three major colours found in Portuguese tiles. Our experiments show that by skilfully dosing a variety of reagents in the pigment recipe, painters could count on a rich palette of hues to accommodate their chromatic needs.

EMAC 2023 – 16th European Meeting on Ancient Ceramics

The colours of Portuguese azulejos. A multi-analytical characterisation of decorated tiles and the replication of historical pigment recipes

Mario Bandiera, Umberto Veronesi, Marta Manso, Andreia Ruivo, Alexandre N. Pais, Lurdes Esteves, Márcia Vilarigues, Susana Coentro

June 12-14, 2023   |   Pisa, Italy

Abstract

The chromatic palette of Portuguese azulejos in the first half of the 17th century presented a diverse set of colours ranging from blue and white to different shades of green and yellow, through to orange, purple and brown. Despite the enormous importance of azulejos in the history of Portuguese art, we have no primary sources on how to prepare the colours and glaze the tiles.

The aim of the present paper is to shed light on the colouring technique of an assemblage of 17th to 18th-century Portuguese glazed tiles (azulejos), stored in the National Tile Museum (Lisbon, Portugal). The study includes the characterisation of each colour through a suite of analytical techniques. SEM-EDS and EDXRF were employed to obtain qualitative and (in some samples) quantitative information on their chemical composition. UV-VIS FORS and µ-Raman spectroscopy allowed us to identify the main colouring agents. Finally, to address the relationship between colour and chemical composition, colourimetric measurements were performed as well. To further understand the production of different shades of analysed colours, a number of pigments were replicated following historical recipes from Renaissance treatises.

The analytical results of historical tiles’ experimental replications show that Portuguese painters followed traditional pigment recipes. The colours were obtained through a few base ingredients, namely cobalt (blue), lead antimonate (yellow/orange), manganese (purple), iron (brown) and copper (green). Moreover, by combining some of these components and by adding specific reagents, the palette could be widened to a variety of shades.

This multidisciplinary approach offers key insights into artistic practices and technological choices, filling the gap left by the absence of textual evidence. Our results reaffirm the importance of technical art history as a cross-disciplinary approach to the study and preservation of cultural heritage.

TechnArt 2023 – International conference on analytical techniques in art and cultural heritage

 A multi-analytical non-invasive approach to characterise the colour palette of 17th-18th century azulejos

Mario Bandiera, Umberto Veronesi, Marta Manso, Andreia Ruivo, Alexandre N. Pais, Lurdes Esteves, Márcia Vilarigues, Susana Coentro

May 7-12, 2023   |   Lisbon, Portugal

Abstract

This work  aims to study the colours used to paint 22 Portuguese glazed tiles (azulejos) stored in the National Tile Museum, in Lisbon, Portugal. The tiles are dated from the 17th to 18th century and represent different colour combinations used throughout several decades.

Building on a previous study where the basic chemical composition of the 17th-century colour palette was identified [1], we used a non-invasive methodology to further identify compositional differences among identical colours within a wider timeframe.

The colours (blue, white, yellow, orange, purple, green and brown) were analysed by EDXRF to obtain qualitative and (in some samples) quantitative information on their chemical composition. UV-VIS FORS and µ-Raman spectroscopy were used to identify the main colouring agents. Finally, colourimetric measurements of the different hues of each colour were performed to address the relation between colour and chemical composition. All analyses were performed on the surface of the tiles.

The analytical results showed that green colour could be obtained through copper base pigment or a mixture of a lead-antimonate-based pigment and a cobalt-blue pigment. Although cobalt is the colouring agent of the blue pigments, the compositional differences detected through the analyses suggest using different raw materials or adding other elements to modify the hue.  On the other hand, different yellow hues (from lemon-yellow to orange) were manufactured by mixing lead-antimonate base pigment with zinc, tin, or iron oxide. A manganese ore was used to make the purple pigment.


[1] Coentro, S., Mimoso, J., Lima, A., Silva, A., Pais, A., & Muralha, V. (2012). Multi-analytical identification of pigments and pigment mixtures used in 17th century Portuguese azulejos. Journal of the European Ceramic Society 32, 37-48

Materiais 2023 – XXI Congresso da Sociedade Portuguesa de Materiais and XII International Symposium on Materials 

Lead antimonate: A base ingredient for yellow, orange, and green decorations in Portuguese azulejos

Umberto Veronesi, Mario Bandiera, Andreia Ruivo, Marta Manso, Márcia Vilarigues, Susana Coentro

April 3-6, 2023   |   Guimarães, Portugal

Abstract

The chromatic palette of Portuguese azulejos (decorated tiles) went through a period of expansion from the 16th to the 17th century. Besides white and blue, panels show brown and purple decorations, as well as various shades of yellow, orange and green. Since no local sources are available, we have limited information on how the many colours were achieved. What we know from the data gathered so far is that among the materials employed to make the pigments, lead antimonate (Pb2Sb2O7) appears to occupy an especially relevant spot. Also known as Naples yellow, lead antimonate was the main component of yellow decorations. Mixed with other ingredients, lead antimonate yellow formed the base for two other key colours, namely olive green and orange-brown.

This paper addresses the role of lead antimonate as the base to make pigments used to decorate Portuguese azulejos. Following historical majolica recipes, a number of preparations were replicated in the laboratory. The pigments synthesised were then painted on test tiles, over a white glaze, and fired again. It was observed that where lead antimonate was the main ingredient, the result is a yellow decoration. The presence and quantity of reagents such as alkali fluxes, zinc or tin oxide were found to strongly influence the colour, resulting in a broad spectrum of hues. On the other hand, the addition of smalt, a cobalt-based preparation, or copper oxide, resulted in olive green decorations, while the presence of iron oxide turned the pigment a dark orange to brown.

The molecular and chromatic profile of all the pigments produced were also characterised. Micro Raman analyses confirmed that Naples yellow is the main crystalline phase in all colours, with characteristic bands that indicate the presence of different reagents according to the colour. Colorimetric coordinates further confirm that by mixing different ingredients into the lead antimonate base, pigments go from pale yellow to brown to olive green.

This article sheds new light on the use of lead antimonate as the main ingredient in three major colours found in Portuguese tiles. Our experiments show that by skilfully dosing a variety of reagents in the pigment recipe, painters could count on a rich palette of hues to accommodate their chromatic needs.

ACS Spring 2023: Crossroads of Chemistry

Technical art history and the chromatic history of Portuguese azulejos. The case of yellow.

Umberto Veronesi, Mario Bandiera, Andreia Ruivo, Marta Manso, Márcia Vilarigues, Susana Coentro

March 26-30    |   Indianapolis, IN & Hybrid

Abstract

The chromatic palette of Portuguese azulejos expanded dramatically during the 17th century, with colours ranging from blue and white to different shades of green and yellow, through to orange, purple and brown. Despite the enormous importance of azulejos in the history of Portuguese art, we have no primary sources on how to prepare the colours and glaze the tiles.

This paper presents data from an ongoing research project that investigates the chromatic history of Portuguese azulejos through their colour chemistry. We started with yellow, a very versatile but technically challenging colour to achieve. We know that Naples yellow (lead antimonate) was employed as the pigment of choice, but questions still remain as to how exactly it was manufactured and what recipes were followed to achieve the many shades of yellow that we can see on artwork.

To answer these questions, we first replicated a number of Naples yellows according to recipes from well-known Italian Renaissance treatises. The resulting colours span from pale yellow to dark orange and confirm that small adjustments to the recipe provided artists with an extensive palette, accommodating their chromatic needs. Then, we painted our experimental pigments on test tiles, over a white background, to assess the influence that the glazing process had on the colour. All our experiments were analysed for their chemical, molecular and chromatic profiles. Finally, by comparing and contrasting our data with data obtained from historical azulejos, we selected three Naples yellow recipes as the most representative of the Portuguese tradition.

We argue how the combination of scientific analyses and experimental replications offers key insights on artistic practices and technological choices, filling the gap left by the absence of textual evidence. Our results reaffirm the importance of technical art history as a cross-disciplinary approach to the study and preservation of cultural heritage.

Veronesi_et_al - 2022 - Poster ICOM-ATSR.pdf

9th Interim Meeting of the ICOM-CC Art Technological Source Research Working Group

POSTER: What colour is it? Experimental replications and the quest for yellows in Portuguese azulejo

Umberto Veronesi, Mario Bandiera, Andreia Ruivo, Marta Manso, Márcia Vilarigues, Susana Coentro

24-25 November 2022 - Paris, France

Abstract

The chromatic palette of Portuguese azulejos reached a peak during the 17th century. Chemical analyses have shown that Naples Yellow (lead antimonate) was the pigment employed in azulejos, but questions remain as to its technology. Using recipes from Renaissance treatises on painting and glazing, we replicated several Naples Yellows containing various types of additives. The resulting colours range from pale yellow to dark orange and confirm that artists could count on an extensive palette by tweaking the recipes (e.g. firing temperature or fluxing agent). The experimental outcomes give us insights into the artistic process that gave rise to the range of yellows witnessed in Portuguese azulejos while putting new questions on the table. The results also reaffirm the importance of technical art history as a material-centred, holistic approach to studying and preserving cultural heritage.

encontro CIÊNCIA'22

What colour is it? Experimental replications and the quest for yellows in Portuguese azulejo  

Umberto Veronesi, Mario Bandiera, Andreia Ruivo, Marta Manso, Márcia Vilarigues, Susana Coentro

16 May 2022 - Centro de Congressos de Lisboa, Portugal

Abstract

The chromatic palette of Portuguese azulejos reached a peak during the 17th century. Chemical analyses have shown that Naples Yellow (lead antimonate) was the pigment employed in azulejos, but questions remain as to its technology. Using recipes from Renaissance treatises on painting and glazing, we replicated several Naples Yellows containing various types of additives. The resulting colours range from pale yellow to dark orange and confirm that artists could count on an extensive palette by tweaking the recipes (e.g. firing temperature or fluxing agent). The experimental outcomes give us insights into the artistic process that gave rise to the range of yellows witnessed in Portuguese azulejos while putting new questions on the table. The results also reaffirm the importance of technical art history as a material-centred, holistic approach to studying and preserving cultural heritage.

CORES Seminar

A story of the Portuguese azulejo told through its colours

Susana Coentro

4 May 2022 - FCT-NOVA, Caparica, Portugal

Abstract

In this seminar dedicated to the PhD students of the CORES program, but open to the public, we shared the many questions that we are trying to answer in our project while telling the history of the chromatic evolution of the Portuguese azulejo.

AzLab #75

ChromAz: A history of the colours in Portuguese azulejos

Susana Coentro, Umberto Veronesi, Márcia Vilarigues

20 April 2022 - Online - Available here on AzLab Youtube channel

Abstract

In the 75th AzLab conference, three members of the ChromAz team present the project, its goals, and the results obtained so far. 

22nd Congress of the Association International pour l'Histoire du Verre & ICOM Glass Annual Meeting 2021 - AIHV22

White tin-opacified glass, glazes, and enamels – a review of historical recipes

Susana Coentro

13 - 17 September 2021 - Lisbon, Portugal

Abstract

Tin-opacification of ceramics are believed to have started around the turn of the 9th century AD in today’s Iraq. It is also believed that this invention was an attempt to imitate porcelain [1]. Similarly, in the mid-15th century, it was the arrival of Chinese porcelain that inspired the Venetian glassmakers to produce white blown-glass objects, which were initially called porcellano [2]. For centuries, white glazes and glass have been associated with luxury objects.

To produce glazes, glass, and enamels, empirical knowledge initially surpassed the theoretical one. The “secrets of the trade” were learned by observing and practicing, and were mostly kept within families and passed through generations. Fortunately, some processes were written down and we can find historical recipes of tin-opacified glass materials dated as early as the 11th century AD [3]. In this work, important sources such as Abu’l Qasim’s Persian treatise on tin-glazed ceramics (14th century), Neri’s Italian treatise on glass L’Arte Vetraria (1612), Piccopalsso’s famous treatise on majolica (“The three books of the potter’s art”, ca. 1557), or Kunckel’s Ars Vitraria Experimentalis (Germany, 1679), will be addressed.

This study will gather and compare historical sources on the production of tin-opacified glass-based materials, addressing the technological transfer process among different arts – glass, enamels, glazes, and mosaic – from the 11th to the 18th century.

 

[1] Tite, M.S. (2009). The production technology of Italian maiolica: a reassessment, Journal of Archaeological Science, 36: 2065–2080.

[2] Verità, M., Zecchin, S., & Tesser, E. (2018). Venetian filigree glass along the centuries: Some technological  considerations. Study Days on Venetian Glass: Venetian Filigrana Glass through the Centuries, 176-I: 1-12.

[3] Holakooei, P. (2013). Technological study of the seventeenth century haft rang tiles in Iran with a comparative view to the cuerda seca tiles in Spain [PhD Thesis]. Università degli Studi di Ferrara.