Study Dot Point: approaches to learning that situate the learner within a system, as illustrated by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander ways of knowing where learning is viewed as being embedded in relationships where the learner is part of a multimodal system of knowledge patterned on Country.
Introduction to this KKDP
It is estimated that there are more than 370 million indigenous people spread across 70 countries worldwide. Practicing unique traditions, they retain social, cultural, economic and political characteristics that are distinct from those of the dominant societies in which they live. Spread across the world from the Arctic to the South Pacific, they are the descendants of those who inhabited a country or a geographical region at the time when people of different cultures or ethnic origins arrived. The new arrivals later became dominant through conquest, occupation, settlement or other means.
•Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples are among the oldest known continuous cultures in the world. There is a diversity of nations, clans, languages, cultural practices and spiritual beliefs that have survived for over 50 000 years
•knowledge and skills are based on interconnected social, physical, and spiritual understandings, and in turn, inform survival and contribute to a strong sense of identity
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples’ Ways of Knowing
Broad commonalties in ‘ways of knowing’ shared between distinct Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander language groups (clans):
• Connected to the landscape
• Relational
• Spiritual and based on deep connection to ancestral knowledge
• Holistic/wholistic
• Oral cultures (traditionally)
However, always recognise the diversity between groups and contextualise examples in relation to local expressions and contemporary expressions.
• There are some broad generalities across the various Indigenous cultures of the world, but also great diversity
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples’ ways of knowing are a distinct group of Indigenous oral cultures.
Check out this Map of Indigenous Australia - How many countries do you see?
https://aiatsis.gov.au/explore/map-indigenous-australia
Learning is multimodal by nature, meaning that they use a variety of methods
Multimodal = using a variety of methods
How is Learning Embedded in Relationships?
The process of learning for Australia’s First Nations is deeply embedded in relationships.
Theses include:
Relationships between concepts.
• Relationships between learner and teacher.
• Relationships between individuals, families, and communities.
• Relationships between all of the above and Country
Throughout this lesson so far, you have read about the relationality (everything relating to each other) of Indigenous learning systems. In other words, you have learnt that different knowledge is deeply interconnected within complex systems and that learning is embedded within Country. In this way, learning is holistic and involves understanding the relationships between things, living beings, spirituality, and how they all interconnect with each other.
Additionally, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples understand that human beings are interconnected with each other, the past, the ancestors, and the natural world, all at once. This is reflected in the very purpose of learning for Aboriginal communities, which is to remember and share cultural and survival knowledge to maintain cultural continuity and to protect complex ecosystems and biodiversity. Through the establishment and maintenance of these holistic systems of knowledge and learning, First Nations communities have thrived for millennia.
EIGHT WAYS OF LEARNING
- demonstrates how learning for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders is multimodal.
Story-sharing: Learning takes place through narrative and story-sharing.
Learning maps: Planning and visualising processes and knowledge.
Non-verbal Sharing: knowledge through non-verbal means, including dance, art, and observation.
Symbols and images: Learning through images, symbols, and metaphors.
Land links: Learning and knowledge are inherently linked to nature, land, and Country.
Non-linear: Thinking outside the square and taking knowledge from different viewpoints in order to build new understandings.
Deconstruct/ Reconstruct: Breaking down a concept from whole to parts, and then applying it. Knowledge or skills are demonstrated (modelled - observational learning), and then a learner is guided through each part in turn. Learners engage by watching and then doing.
Community links: Connecting learning to local values, needs, and knowledge. Learning does not occur in a vacuum, but rather is shared with others and used to meet the needs of the community.
• The term contains complex ideas about place, law, spirituality, language, cultural practice, material sustenance, family and identity.
Country (in relation to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures) traditional lands of a particular language or cultural group, including both geographical boundaries and the spiritual, emotional, and intellectual connections to and within it
Two ways:
1. Through kinship relationships
2. Through knowledge being encoded in the landscape
1. Kinship structures are a kind of pattern. They define relationships between people and place, and therefore access to knowledge.
• Based on place, kinship determines who can hold which kinds of knowledge, who can transmit knowledge to whom, and when they can do so.
• “Learning embedded in relationships”.
2. Country holds and transmits knowledge
• Songlines, are the ultimate example of knowledge that is patterned on Country.
• Ownership of songs is determined by kinship structures
• Songlines form a pattern of interconnecting pathways across Country.
1. All entities on Country have their own language.
• The winds, tides, night sky, animals, plants, rivers, etc.
• These occur in different senses - scent, sound, sight, texture.
• Learn to observe relationships between entities on Country.
• When a particular constellation rises in the north sky, the winds are coming.
• When a particular plant is flowering, the fish are plentiful in the river.
• Learning is learning to listen, observe, and sense Country.
• Country is a multi-modal system of knowledge.
2. Learning occurs through multiple-modalities
• Young people learn stories from elders whilst on Country.
• Learning through story, song, dance, art, making, doing.
• Songlines = sung narrative, but also expressed in art and dance - multiple modes.
1. **Identify the significance of Country in the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander ways of knowing and explain its role. (2 marks)**
- Identify the significance of Country (1 mark).
- Explain its role in learning and knowledge systems (1 mark).
2. **Define relationality in the context of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander learning processes and provide one example of how it is manifested. (3 marks)**
- Definition of relationality (1 mark).
- Identify one manifestation of relationality in these cultures (1 mark).
- Explain how this example illustrates relationality (1 mark).
3. **Name the primary method of knowledge transmission in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures and explain why it is considered effective. (2 marks)**
- Identify the primary method (1 mark).
- Explain its effectiveness (1 mark).
4. **Describe what is meant by a holistic approach to learning in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures and give one example of how this approach is applied. (3 marks)**
- Describe the holistic approach (1 mark).
- Identify one example of its application (1 mark).
- Explain how this example demonstrates the holistic approach (1 mark).
5. **Compare Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander ways of knowing with observational learning by identifying one similarity and one difference. (4 marks)**
- Identify one similarity (1 mark).
- Explain the similarity (1 mark).
- Identify one difference (1 mark).
- Explain the difference (1 mark).
6. **Propose one way Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander ways of knowing could be integrated into mainstream educational systems and discuss one potential benefit. (3 marks)**
- Propose one integration method (1 mark).
- Identify one potential benefit of this integration (1 mark).
- Discuss how this benefit could impact education (1 mark).
1. **Identify the significance of Country in the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander ways of knowing and explain its role. (2 marks)**
- **Exemplar Response:** The significance of Country in these cultures is its role as a living entity that is integral to identity and learning (1 mark). It is not just a place but a source of knowledge, spiritual connection, and sustenance, teaching individuals about their culture, history, and the environment through direct interaction and experiences (1 mark).
2. **Define relationality in the context of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander learning processes and provide one example of how it is manifested. (3 marks)**
- **Exemplar Response:** Relationality refers to the interconnectedness and relationships among people, the land, and all living things (1 mark). An example is the practice of storytelling, where knowledge is shared within a communal context, strengthening bonds between individuals and across generations, and embedding learning within a web of social and environmental relations (1 mark). This illustrates relationality by showing how knowledge transmission fosters community cohesion and connectedness to Country (1 mark).
3. **Name the primary method of knowledge transmission in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures and explain why it is considered effective. (2 marks)**
- **Exemplar Response:** Storytelling is the primary method of knowledge transmission (1 mark). It is considered effective because it allows for the preservation and sharing of cultural histories, lessons, and values in a way that is engaging and memorable, ensuring knowledge is passed down through generations (1 mark).
4. **Describe what is meant by a holistic approach to learning in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander cultures and give one example of how this approach is applied. (3 marks)**
- **Exemplar Response:** A holistic approach to learning integrates spiritual, emotional, physical, and intellectual dimensions, reflecting the interconnectedness of all aspects of life (1 mark). An example is the use of land-based learning, where students learn about the environment, sustainability, and cultural practices directly from their interactions with Country (1 mark). This approach demonstrates holism by connecting knowledge about the natural world with cultural identity, spirituality, and practical skills (1 mark).
5. **Compare Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander ways of knowing with observational learning by identifying one similarity and one difference. (4 marks)**
- **Exemplar Response:** A similarity is that both emphasize learning through direct engagement and observation of the environment or behaviors (1 mark). This hands-on approach facilitates deep learning and retention (1 mark). A difference is that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander ways of knowing incorporate a spiritual and communal dimension, where learning is connected to ancestral knowledge and the broader community, unlike the more individual-focused observational learning (1 mark). This emphasizes the role of collective wisdom and cultural continuity not present in the observational model (1 mark).
6. **Propose one way Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander ways of knowing could be integrated into mainstream educational systems and discuss one potential benefit. (3 marks)**
- **Exemplar Response:** Integrating land-based learning programs that connect students with local Indigenous communities and environments could incorporate Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander ways of knowing into mainstream education (1 mark). A potential benefit of this integration is the enhancement of students' understanding and respect for Indigenous cultures and environmental stewardship (1 mark). This could lead to a more inclusive curriculum that values diversity and promotes a deeper, holistic understanding of the world (1 mark).
EXAMPLE OF WAYS OF KNOWING:
Lets look at a scenrio that encapsulates the ways of knowing and its multimodal approach
Imagine a scenario in a remote Aboriginal community located in the Kimberley region of Western Australia, where the local Yawuru people are preparing for an annual cultural festival. This festival is a vibrant celebration of Yawuru culture, and a significant part of the event is dedicated to teaching younger generations about their heritage, environment, and traditional practices through a holistic and multimodal approach to learning, reflecting Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander ways of knowing.
PREPARATION PHASE
In the weeks leading up to the festival, elders of the Yawuru community organize a series of workshops for the youth. These workshops are designed around the concept of "Learning on Country," where the natural environment serves as a classroom. One such workshop is focused on traditional fishing techniques, crucial for both sustenance and cultural practices.
LEARNING ON COUNTRY
Elders take small groups of young people to the mangroves at low tide, where they share knowledge about the tidal patterns, moon phases, and how these influence the best times for fishing, demonstrating the interconnectedness of environmental knowledge and cultural practices. This experience not only teaches practical skills but also instills a deep respect for the land and sea, illustrating the holistic aspect of their learning.
STORYTELLING AND DANCE
In the evenings, the community gathers around fires where elders share stories of the Dreamtime, explaining the creation of the land, the sea, and the significance of various animal totems to the Yawuru people. These stories are accompanied by traditional dances that visually represent the narratives, incorporating symbols and non-verbal cues that reinforce the oral teachings. This combination of storytelling and dance exemplifies the multimodal nature of knowledge transmission, engaging learners through auditory, visual, and kinaesthetic means.
ART AND SYMBOLISM
Leading up to the festival, another workshop involves the creation of traditional artworks, using natural ochres found in the country. Elders explain the meanings behind various symbols and how they represent stories, laws, and connections to Country. Participants then create their own pieces, expressing their individual connections to the stories and knowledge shared. This activity highlights the use of symbols and images as another modality of learning and knowledge preservation.
COMMUNITY INVOLVEMENT
On the day of the festival, the entire community, including visitors, is invited to participate in ceremonies that begin with a Welcome to Country, acknowledging the ancestral spirits and the traditional owners of the land. The young people, having learned traditional dances, songs, and stories, perform these in front of the community, showcasing their newly acquired knowledge and skills. This communal aspect of the festival emphasizes the importance of relationships in learning processes, connecting individual, family, and community in a shared experience.
HOLISTIC AND MULTIMODAL LEARNING OUTCOMES
Through these experiences, young Yawuru people learn not only about their cultural identity and heritage but also about environmental stewardship, community responsibilities, and the importance of sustaining their cultural practices. The holistic approach is evident in the integration of spiritual, environmental, and communal knowledge, while the multimodal aspect is reflected in the diverse methods of teaching and learning employed—spanning oral storytelling, practical engagement with Country, dance, art, and communal ceremonies.
This scenario showcases how Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander ways of knowing and learning are used to pass on knowledge in a manner that is both holistic and multimodal, ensuring that cultural traditions and environmental stewardship are carried forward to future generations.