Organic vs Chemical Fertilizers

Research Findings on Organic vs Chemical Fertilizers

EPA Information on Fertilizers + Watershed:

  • Nitrogen + phosphorus (animal manure // chemical fertilizers)

  • “When these nutrients are not fully utilized by plants they can be lost from the farm fields and negatively impact air and downstream water quality”

  • Precipitation (stormwater) carries pollutants from rooftops, the ground, sidewalks, and roads into local waterways

  • Wastewater (sewer // septic) → if not operating properly, nitrogen and phosphorus discharge into waterways

  • IN AND AROUND HOME:

    • Fertilizers, yard and pet waste, certain soaps and detergents contain nitrogen + phosphoru

      • Need to be properly used and disposed of

    • “Amount of hard surfaces and type of landscaping can also increase the runoff of nitrogen and phosphorus during wet weather”


The Effects: Human Health

  • Nutrients and excessive algal blooms = toxins + compounds in water

  • drinking/swallowing/swimming in contaminated water can result in:

    • Stomach or liver illness

    • Respiratory problems

    • Neurological effects

  • “Nitrate, a compound found in fertilizer, can enter drinking water in agricultural areas”

    • “Infants are more susceptible to the health effects posed by nitrates, which can be serious and sometimes fatal”


Causes:

  • Bacteria:

    • Coliform gut bacteria from animals can causes multiple health issues if ingested by humans

    • More of a huge problem with reservoirs and other places where drinking water comes from

  • Sediments:

    • Melting snow washes salt and other sediments into water/streams

  • Sediments block sunlight from aquatic plants → lack of food and fertilization for life in the river

  • Nutrient Blooms:

    • Nutrients (nitrogen and phosphorus) that wash into river cause algae blooms

    • Extra fertilizer from farms washes into river → compounds in fertilizer are toxic for the life in the river, or they feed algae blooms

    • cattle/livestock operations → manure (poop, chemicals, toxins from gut) wash into river

Action Plan:

  • Sediments:

    • figure out benefits/conving way of getting sand used in dover

  • Nutrient Blooms:

    • Get word out/reach out to farmers about using more environmentally friendly fertilizers for crops

    • Don't over apply fertilizer → use organic or slow release fertilizer instead

https://www.nature.org/en-us/what-we-do/our-priorities/protect-water-and-land/land-and-water-stories/how-we-protect-watersheds/

What you can do

  • Home

  • Lawn

    • Fertilizers only when necessary and recommended amount

    • No fertilizers before windy/rainy days

    • Avoid applying fertilizers close to waterways

    • Apply as close as possible to period of max uptake + growth (usually spring and fall)

    • Do not overwater lawn; use soaker hose → porous hose that releases water directly to the ground, which reduces overwatering that carries away fertilizers

    • Fill fertilizer spreaders on a hard surface so spills are easily cleaned up

    • Properly store unused fertilizers + properly dispose of empty containers

    • Maintain lawn equipment to reduce nitrogen oxide emissions

  • Community

  • Classroom


EPA Tips on Combating Watershed:

  • Conserve water daily → shorter showers, fix leaks, turn off faucets

  • Don't pour toxic chemicals down the drain → cleaners/detergents… take to dump or hazardous waste center

  • NEVER POUR OIL OR ANTIFREEZE DOWN DRAIN OR ON STREET

  • Use plants that require little water in yard

  • Pick up after dog ( even in yard?) → ask about that one bc i dont have dog

  • Look for leaks in car + fix

    • Many pollutants come from gasoline/chemicals in cars and other vehicles


Did you know…

Organic Fertilizers…

  • “Improve water movement into the soil, and in time, add structure to the soil”

  • “Feed beneficial microbes, making the soil easier to work”

  • “Don’t make crust on the soil”

  • “Gardeners want materials rich in calcium, including clamshells, oyster shells, wood ashes, dolomite, and gypsum”


Inorganic Fertilizers…

  • “Since they are lost from the soil quickly, you may have to fertilize plants several times during the growing season”

  • If managed improperly, can impact animal and plant life negatively.

    • “Impacts include algae blooms causing the depletion of oxygen in surface waters, pathogens and nitrates in drinking water, and the emission of odors and gases into the air”



https://extension.oregonstate.edu/news/heres-scoop-chemical-organic-fertilizers

https://www.ag.ndsu.edu/publications/environment-natural-resources/environmental-implications-of-excess-fertilizer-and-manure-on-water-quality

Notes From Company Blogs


Organic Fertilizer

  • No risk of toxic buildups of salts when using organic fertilizers

  • “Renewable, biodegradable, sustainable, and environmentally friendly”

  • Feed microorganisms that build and sustain nutrient levels in the soil → really hot/cold days, reduce excessive nitrogen exposure

    • “Microorganisms create a living soil which is a naturally controlled-release nitrogen source, which prevents lawn diseases and will not cause excessive growth”


Inorganic Fertilizer

  • Nutrients will show improvement quickly

  • Inexpensive

  • Made from fossil fuels/nonrenewable resources

  • Kill microbes in soil

  • Lack of organic matter -- long term exposure can result in damage to soil


https://organolawn.com/blog/pros-and-cons-of-organic-fertilizers-vs-chemical-fertilizers/